WRESTLER FILE
Johnny Gargano
WrestleFile archive coverage across reviewed Event Files. These numbers describe the matches and events indexed by WrestleFile, not a complete career record.
COMPARE THIS WRESTLER38Reviewed Matches
35Event File Appearances
27Indexed Opponents
9.0Average Match Score
WRESTLEGRADE
Best Reviewed Match
A+10.0
NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia (2018) - Jan 27, 2018
Andrade Cien Almas def. Johnny Gargano — NXT Championship
OPEN EVENT FILEARCHIVE TRAIL
Recent Event Files
NXT Stand & Deliver 2026Apr 4, 2026
A-8.6
SummerSlam 2025Aug 2, 2025
A-8.6
Royal Rumble 2025Feb 1, 2025
A-8.8
WrestleMania XL (2024)Apr 6, 2024
A9.1
NXT Stand & Deliver 2023Apr 1, 2023
B+8.0
Elimination Chamber 2023Feb 18, 2023
A9.1
Royal Rumble 2023Jan 28, 2023
B+8.4
NXT WarGames 2021Dec 5, 2021
B7.9
NXT TakeOver: In Your House (2021)Jun 13, 2021
B7.7
NXT TakeOver: Stand & Deliver (2021)Apr 7, 2021
A9.1
NXT TakeOver: Vengeance Day (2021)Feb 14, 2021
A9.3
NXT TakeOver: WarGames (2020)Dec 6, 2020
A9.0
MATCH FINDER DATA
Top Indexed Opponents
01Adam Cole3 reviewed matches · VIEW MATCHES
Top 3 reviewed matches against Adam Cole
Johnny Gargano def. Adam Cole — NXT Championship (Two out of Three Falls)NXT TakeOver: New York (2019) · Apr 5, 2019A+ · 9.9Adam Cole def. Johnny Gargano — NXT ChampionshipNXT TakeOver: XXV (2019) · Jun 1, 2019A+ · 9.7Adam Cole def. Johnny Gargano — NXT Championship Two out of Three Falls MatchNXT TakeOver: Toronto (2019) · Aug 10, 2019A- · 8.9OPEN ADAM COLE'S WRESTLER FILE →02Akam3 reviewed matches · VIEW MATCHES
Top 3 reviewed matches against Akam
The Authors of Pain def. DIY — NXT Tag Team Championship Ladder MatchNXT TakeOver: Chicago (2017) · May 20, 2017A · 9.3The Authors of Pain def. #DIY and The Revival — NXT Tag Team Championship Triple Threat Elimination MatchNXT TakeOver: Orlando (2017) · Apr 1, 2017A · 9.2The Authors of Pain def. DIY — NXT Tag Team ChampionshipNXT TakeOver: San Antonio (2017) · Jan 28, 2017B+ · 8.4OPEN AKAM'S WRESTLER FILE →03Dash Wilder3 reviewed matches · VIEW MATCHES
Top 3 reviewed matches against Dash Wilder
DIY def. The Revival — NXT Tag Team Championship Two-out-of-Three Falls MatchNXT TakeOver: Toronto (2016) · Nov 19, 2016A+ · 9.6The Authors of Pain def. #DIY and The Revival — NXT Tag Team Championship Triple Threat Elimination MatchNXT TakeOver: Orlando (2017) · Apr 1, 2017A · 9.2The Revival (Dash Wilder & Scott Dawson) (c) def. Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa — NXT Tag Team ChampionshipNXT TakeOver: Brooklyn II (2016) · Aug 20, 2016A · 9.2OPEN DASH WILDER'S WRESTLER FILE →04Rezar3 reviewed matches · VIEW MATCHES
Top 3 reviewed matches against Rezar
The Authors of Pain def. DIY — NXT Tag Team Championship Ladder MatchNXT TakeOver: Chicago (2017) · May 20, 2017A · 9.3The Authors of Pain def. #DIY and The Revival — NXT Tag Team Championship Triple Threat Elimination MatchNXT TakeOver: Orlando (2017) · Apr 1, 2017A · 9.2The Authors of Pain def. DIY — NXT Tag Team ChampionshipNXT TakeOver: San Antonio (2017) · Jan 28, 2017B+ · 8.4OPEN REZAR'S WRESTLER FILE →05Scott Dawson3 reviewed matches · VIEW MATCHES
Top 3 reviewed matches against Scott Dawson
DIY def. The Revival — NXT Tag Team Championship Two-out-of-Three Falls MatchNXT TakeOver: Toronto (2016) · Nov 19, 2016A+ · 9.6The Authors of Pain def. #DIY and The Revival — NXT Tag Team Championship Triple Threat Elimination MatchNXT TakeOver: Orlando (2017) · Apr 1, 2017A · 9.2The Revival (Dash Wilder & Scott Dawson) (c) def. Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa — NXT Tag Team ChampionshipNXT TakeOver: Brooklyn II (2016) · Aug 20, 2016A · 9.2OPEN SCOTT DAWSON'S WRESTLER FILE →06Tommaso Ciampa3 reviewed matches · VIEW MATCHES
Top 3 reviewed matches against Tommaso Ciampa
Johnny Gargano def. Tommaso Ciampa — Unsanctioned MatchNXT TakeOver: New Orleans (2018) · Apr 7, 2018A+ · 10.0Tommaso Ciampa def. Johnny Gargano — Chicago Street FightNXT TakeOver: Chicago II (2018) · Jun 16, 2018A+ · 9.5Tommaso Ciampa def. Johnny Gargano — NXT Championship, Last Man StandingNXT TakeOver: Brooklyn 4 (2018) · Aug 18, 2018A · 9.4OPEN TOMMASO CIAMPA'S WRESTLER FILE →07Aleister Black2 reviewed matches · VIEW MATCHES
Top 2 reviewed matches against Aleister Black
Aleister Black def. Johnny GarganoNXT TakeOver: WarGames (2018) · Nov 17, 2018A+ · 9.5Aleister Black, Ricochet & Velveteen Dream def. Adam Cole, Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa — Six-Man Tag Team MatchHalftime Heat 2019 · Feb 3, 2019A · 9.1OPEN ALEISTER BLACK'S WRESTLER FILE →08Andrade Cien Almas2 reviewed matches · VIEW MATCHES
09Damian Priest2 reviewed matches · VIEW MATCHES
Top 2 reviewed matches against Damian Priest
Damian Priest def. Johnny Gargano — NXT North American ChampionshipNXT TakeOver 31 (2020) · Oct 4, 2020A- · 8.7Johnny Gargano def. Leon Ruff and Damian Priest — NXT North American ChampionshipNXT TakeOver: WarGames (2020) · Dec 6, 2020B · 7.7OPEN DAMIAN PRIEST'S WRESTLER FILE →10Grayson Waller2 reviewed matches · VIEW MATCHES
11Ricochet2 reviewed matches · VIEW MATCHES
Top 2 reviewed matches against Ricochet
Johnny Gargano def. Ricochet — NXT North American ChampionshipNXT TakeOver: Phoenix (2019) · Jan 26, 2019A+ · 9.7Aleister Black, Ricochet & Velveteen Dream def. Adam Cole, Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa — Six-Man Tag Team MatchHalftime Heat 2019 · Feb 3, 2019A · 9.1OPEN RICOCHET'S WRESTLER FILE →12Alex Shelley1 reviewed match · VIEW MATCHES
Top 1 reviewed matches against Alex Shelley
#DIY (c) def. Motor City Machine Guns 2-1 - WWE Tag Team ChampionshipRoyal Rumble 2025 · Feb 1, 2025B- · 7.3OPEN ALEX SHELLEY'S WRESTLER FILE →