WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn 4 (2018): Five Matches, Two Title Changes, and Another Night NXT Refuses to Miss

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

WWE/NXTAugust 18, 2018Barclays Center
THE WRESTLEGRADEA9.1 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#50OF 1015
PROMOTION
WWE NXT
DATE
August 18, 2018
VENUE
Barclays Center
LOCATION
Brooklyn, New York
ATTENDANCE
14,676
EVENT TYPE
PPV
THE FILE

NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn 4 is the kind of wrestling show that makes consistency feel extravagant. The Undisputed ERA and Moustache Mountain open with a phenomenal tag-title match, Ricochet and Adam Cole produce a spectacular North American Championship sprint, Kairi Sane and Shayna Baszler deliver an excellent title fight, and Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano close with another exhausting piece of violence. Even the weakest match, Velveteen Dream against EC3, is perfectly respectable. Five matches arrive, five matches matter, and the entire card is finished before the main roster would have reached its midpoint.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

What keeps Brooklyn 4 just below NXT's absolute summit is familiarity. Ciampa and Gargano are tremendous again, but their third major TakeOver fight in four months no longer carries the freshness of New Orleans. Dream and EC3 never find the same gear as the title matches. Those are modest complaints on a show this strong. The final verdict lands at A, 9.1 out of 10: elite match quality, a molten crowd, two meaningful title changes, and virtually no wasted motion.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn 4 took place on August 18, 2018 at Barclays Center in Brooklyn, New York, before a reported crowd of 14,676. It was the twenty-first NXT TakeOver and the fourth and final event in the TakeOver: Brooklyn subseries, staged as the Saturday-night centerpiece of SummerSlam weekend. Seven matches were recorded in the building, but Bianca Belair versus Deonna Purrazzo and Pete Dunne versus Zack Gibson were taped for a later episode of NXT rather than presented as part of the live TakeOver broadcast. Those two matches are excluded from these grades. The five-match live card opened with the NXT Tag Team Championship and closed with the NXT Championship in a Last Man Standing match.

The central story had already become NXT's defining rivalry. Tommaso Ciampa held the NXT Championship after defeating Aleister Black with accidental help from Johnny Gargano, while Black's injury removed him from the originally planned three-way title match and left Ciampa and Gargano alone again. Elsewhere, Adam Cole's North American Championship was challenged by Ricochet, Shayna Baszler defended the Women's Championship against Kairi Sane, and Moustache Mountain sought to regain the tag titles from Kyle O'Reilly and Roderick Strong. Brooklyn 4 therefore combines a long-running blood feud with three championship matches built around wrestlers who would define the brand's next phase.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • The Undisputed ERA vs. Moustache Mountain — NXT Tag Team Championship
  • Ricochet vs. Adam Cole — NXT North American Championship
  • Kairi Sane vs. Shayna Baszler — NXT Women's Championship
  • Tommaso Ciampa vs. Johnny Gargano — NXT Championship, Last Man Standing
SKIM
  • Velveteen Dream vs. EC3
SKIP
    MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

    The Card, On the Record

    01The Undisputed ERA def. Moustache Mountain — NXT Tag Team ChampionshipA+

    The match begins at a pace most teams would save for a finishing stretch, then becomes more sophisticated as O'Reilly and Strong isolate Trent Seven and attack Tyler Bate's leg. The towel tease calls back to their previous title match without simply repeating it, because Seven refuses to surrender and throws the towel into the crowd. Bate's eventual hot tag is spectacular, combining strength, speed, and desperation while the champions keep finding new ways to interrupt him. The final minutes are relentless without becoming shapeless. Strong knocks Bate from the ring with a knee, O'Reilly and Strong hit the High-Low on Seven, and the champions retain. Every major near fall has context, every save matters, and the crowd is completely invested. It is tag-team wrestling operating at an elite level.

    VERDICT

    A near-perfect tag-team title match built on callbacks, limb work, desperation, and extraordinary chemistry.

    02Velveteen Dream def. EC3C+

    Dream and EC3 work a slower character match in the only spot on the card that never threatens greatness. The crowd is firmly behind Dream, whose entrance and presentation give every taunt more weight than the actual offense. EC3 controls long stretches with power and tries to turn Dream's theatrics against him, while Dream gradually becomes more aggressive as the match moves outside. The most memorable sequence is the finish. Dream hits the Dream Valley Driver on the apron, leaves EC3 draped across the edge, then launches the Purple Rainmaker from the top rope onto the exposed target for the pin. It is a meaningful win for Dream after several TakeOver losses. The match is solid, but fifteen minutes exposes the limited chemistry between them and creates the only real lull of the night.

    VERDICT

    A useful character win for Dream delivered through a respectable match that never reaches the surrounding card's level.

    03Ricochet def. Adam Cole — NXT North American ChampionshipA

    Cole spends the first half proving that he has studied Ricochet, repeatedly cutting off the champion's challenger whenever he tries to leave the ground. That makes Ricochet's eventual breakthrough feel earned rather than inevitable. The match explodes after Cole catches a handspring moonsault with a perfectly timed superkick, and from there both men trade strikes, counters, and near falls at an extraordinary pace. Ricochet finally stops reacting to Cole's traps and begins creating his own. When Cole rolls outside to avoid the 630, Ricochet sprints across the ring and hits a breathtaking hurricanrana from the apron to the floor. One 630 back inside ends the reign. The spectacle is obvious, but the intelligence underneath it is what makes the match special.

    VERDICT

    A spectacular title change in which Ricochet wins by finally outthinking the wrestler who had scouted every obvious move.

    04Kairi Sane def. Shayna Baszler — NXT Women's ChampionshipB

    Baszler works the match around destroying Sane's leg, twisting the knee and forcing the challenger to fight from positions where her explosiveness should be compromised. Sane sells the damage well and gradually turns desperation into aggression, slapping Baszler and throwing herself into increasingly risky offense. The Insane Elbow creates believable near falls, while Baszler's Kirifuda Clutch remains the constant threat that can end the match at any moment. The finish is excellent because it comes from Baszler's own refusal to release the hold. Sane shifts her weight, traps the champion's shoulders, and wins the title while still caught in the submission. The first half is methodical, but the closing stretch and emotional payoff elevate the entire match. Brooklyn gets a genuine underdog championship celebration.

    VERDICT

    A very good underdog title match with focused limb work and a clever finish that protects both wrestlers.

    05Tommaso Ciampa def. Johnny Gargano — NXT Championship, Last Man StandingA

    Ciampa and Gargano begin as if the previous ninety minutes of violence between them never ended, immediately turning the arena into a weapon. They revisit exposed boards, tables, chairs, barricades, crutches, and signature moves, but the match's real story is Gargano's inability to stop once victory is available. Ciampa survives increasingly impossible counts, including a table crash and the rubble of the timekeeper's area. Gargano finally handcuffs him to the stage, superkicks him repeatedly, and appears to have total control. Then obsession beats strategy. Gargano charges with one more knee, flies off the stage into equipment, and cannot stand. Ciampa rolls to his feet with the handcuff helping support him and survives the count. The finish is elaborate, but it completes the story: Johnny destroys himself trying to destroy Tommaso.

    VERDICT

    A brutal, exhausting main event whose theatrical finish turns Gargano's rage into the reason he loses again.

    BOOKING VERDICTA

    The booking is remarkably efficient. The Undisputed ERA retains the tag titles after another exhausting fight with Moustache Mountain, then immediately receives the next threat when the War Raiders destroy the champions. Ricochet beats Adam Cole cleanly for the North American Championship after proving he can adapt to Cole's scouting. Kairi Sane defeats Baszler by turning the Kirifuda Clutch into a pin, giving the challenger a clever victory without diminishing Baszler's submission game. Dream finally wins a significant TakeOver singles match, while EC3 loses without being humiliated. Every result either closes a chapter or opens a clear next one.

    The main event is more debatable but still compelling. Gargano handcuffs Ciampa, overwhelms him with superkicks, and appears to have finally conquered both his enemy and his own fear. Then his rage sends him crashing off the stage, while Ciampa survives only because the handcuff helps keep him upright. It is melodramatic, but that is the point: Gargano loses because he cannot stop punishing Ciampa. Booking earns an A because the finishes are purposeful, the title changes are earned, and nothing feels thrown away.

    CROWD & PRESENTATIONA

    Barclays Center is loud from the opening bell and rarely cools down. Moustache Mountain and Undisputed ERA receive the kind of sustained reaction usually reserved for a main event, especially during Tyler Bate's hot tag and the towel tease. Dream's entrance and attire turn him into the clear favorite against EC3. Ricochet's aerial sequences create several of the night's sharpest spikes in volume, while Sane's title victory produces genuine celebration. Ciampa remains the rare NXT heel who is consistently booed rather than admired, and Gargano's pursuit gives the main event an emotional response that survives more than thirty minutes.

    The presentation is one of NXT's strongest advantages in this era. Five live matches fit into roughly two hours and forty minutes, with almost no filler between them. Mauro Ranallo, Nigel McGuinness, and Percy Watson sell each match as distinct without drowning the action. Barclays gives the show the scale of a major WWE event while the compact card preserves the urgency of a smaller one. Crowd and Presentation earns an A because the building, pacing, commentary, and match order all reinforce the same idea: nothing on this show is disposable.

    HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB

    NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn 4 earns a B for Historical Significance because it closes one of the brand's most important event traditions while advancing several defining 2018 stories. The Brooklyn TakeOvers had become NXT's annual SummerSlam-weekend showcase, beginning with Sasha Banks and Bayley in 2015 and ending here after four consecutive years at Barclays Center. Ricochet wins his first NXT championship, Kairi Sane captures the NXT Women's Championship, and Undisputed ERA's retention immediately points toward the War Raiders. Those developments reshape multiple divisions without requiring a bloated card.

    The main event also pushes Gargano and Ciampa into the next stage of a rivalry that had dominated NXT all year. Gargano's inability to control his obsession becomes part of the story that eventually reveals him as Aleister Black's attacker, while Ciampa leaves Brooklyn still champion and still psychologically ahead. Sane's victory leads to the rematch with Baszler at Evolution, connecting NXT directly to WWE's first all-women's pay-per-view. The event does not create one singular industry-changing moment, but it captures black-and-gold NXT operating near its creative peak.

    WHAT AGED WELL
    • The Undisputed ERA versus Moustache Mountain remains an elite example of tag-team structure, selling, and escalating near falls.
    • Ricochet versus Adam Cole is concise, spectacular, and built around the challenger overcoming Cole's scouting rather than simply trading moves.
    • Kairi Sane's title victory gives the women's division a genuine emotional payoff without making Shayna Baszler look weak.
    • The five-match format gives every live match time to breathe while keeping the entire event under three hours.
    • Ciampa's presentation as a true heel remains unusually effective in an era when NXT crowds often celebrated villains.
    WHAT AGED POORLY
    • The Ciampa-Gargano rivalry is already showing signs of repetition after three major TakeOver matches in four months.
    • The main event's finish depends on an elaborate handcuff-and-stage setup that can feel more constructed on replay.
    • Dream versus EC3 runs longer than its chemistry can comfortably support.
    • Several dangerous head, neck, and stage-impact spots would likely be approached more cautiously under stricter modern safety expectations.
    • The later real-world histories of some performers can make portions of the card more complicated to revisit than they felt in 2018.
    RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

    The critical record is overwhelmingly strong. TJR Wrestling gives Brooklyn 4 a 9 out of 10, awards five stars to the tag-title opener, four-and-a-quarter to Cole-Ricochet, and calls Ciampa-Gargano outstanding. Sporting News grades the overall event A, with A grades for the opener and main event and strong marks across the rest of the card. Fightful is the notable moderate voice at B-plus, arguing that the Gargano-Ciampa formula was beginning to feel exhausted even while praising three excellent matches and the show's consistency. That dissent is useful because it identifies the only serious ceiling on the event's reputation.

    The final WrestleGrade reflects the exceptionally hot crowd, two meaningful title changes, nearly flawless pacing, the final Brooklyn TakeOver setting, and a card with no weak live match. CAGEMATCH currently sits near 8.9 overall, while its matchguide places the opener above nine and the other three title matches firmly in strong territory. The resulting A, 9.1 out of 10, reflects both the extraordinary consistency and the slight sense that NXT had visited the Ciampa-Gargano well one time too many.

    RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
    20 sources

    These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

    1. TJR WrestlingFull-event review with match ratings and a 9/10 final score
    2. Bleacher ReportContemporary results, grades, reactions, and highlights
    3. Bleacher ReportContemporary analysis of the show's highlights and weaker points
    4. Sporting NewsContemporary match grades, recap, and A-level overall assessment
    5. WhatCultureRetrospective ranking of every Brooklyn 4 live match
    6. SportskeedaContemporary best-and-worst review of the event
    7. Cageside SeatsContemporary event recap and reaction focused on the Gargano-Ciampa story
    8. Pro Wrestling Dot NetContemporary live review covering all five TakeOver matches
    9. WWEOfficial Brooklyn 4 results and championship outcomes
    10. FightfulContemporary report card offering a more moderate B-plus overall view
    11. IWNerdPublished Dave Meltzer star-rating reference for Brooklyn 4
    12. CAGEMATCHEvent identity, date, venue, attendance, card, and community ratings
    13. ProFightDBEvent results reference with match times and event-specific wrestling data
    14. Callie PetchIndependent full-event recap and review emphasizing the tag-title opener
    15. 411ManiaRetrospective ranking of the complete TakeOver: Brooklyn match history
    16. 411ManiaAlternate retrospective review of Brooklyn 4 from a less regular NXT perspective
    17. TJR WrestlingSecond full-show perspective on Brooklyn 4's matches and presentation
    18. Sporting NewsLive-results coverage focused on Ciampa-Gargano and the show's championship changes
    19. Smark Out MomentImmediate post-show recap and panel-style event review
    20. CNJ RadioEvent recap preserving venue, attendance, and match-level reactions
    WHERE TO WATCH

    Stream This Event

    Checked August 23, 20261 OPTION

    WWE NXT currently provides an official full-event replay of NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn 4 on YouTube.

    WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.