- War Raiders vs. The Undisputed ERA — NXT Tag Team Championship
- Johnny Gargano vs. Ricochet — NXT North American Championship
- Shayna Baszler vs. Bianca Belair — NXT Women's Championship
- Tommaso Ciampa vs. Aleister Black — NXT Championship
NXT TakeOver: Phoenix (2019): Gargano and Ricochet Lead Another Excellent Five-Match NXT Card
The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.
- PROMOTION
- WWE NXT
- DATE
- January 26, 2019
- VENUE
- Talking Stick Resort Arena
- LOCATION
- Phoenix, Arizona
- ATTENDANCE
- 9,000
- EVENT TYPE
- PPV
NXT TakeOver: Phoenix is another example of the five-match TakeOver format doing exactly what it was designed to do. War Raiders and The Undisputed ERA open with an excellent tag-title match, Matt Riddle and Kassius Ohno keep the card moving, and Johnny Gargano versus Ricochet delivers the night's elite centerpiece. Shayna Baszler and Bianca Belair then produce a strong championship match before Tommaso Ciampa and Aleister Black close with a methodical, increasingly violent NXT Championship main event. Nothing on the live card resembles filler, and three matches operate at A-minus level or better.
Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis
The five-match card is already excellent before broader event context is considered. The final WrestleGrade reflects the compact pacing, a successful opening title change, an A-plus centerpiece, and a strong main event without pushing Phoenix into the same tier as TakeOver: New York. The result is an A-minus at 8.9. That score rewards the cumulative quality of the card rather than the historical importance of Gargano, Ciampa, or the TakeOver brand. Phoenix is excellent wrestling first and a useful historical snapshot second.
Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting
NXT TakeOver: Phoenix took place on January 26, 2019, at Talking Stick Resort Arena during Royal Rumble weekend. Contemporary attendance estimates placed the crowd between roughly 8,000 and 10,000, with multiple historical listings settling on about 9,000. It was the twenty-third TakeOver and the first NXT TakeOver of 2019. The five-match live card featured four championship matches and one grudge match, giving nearly every bout a clear purpose before the opening bell. Two additional matches were taped in the building for a future NXT television episode and are excluded from this Event File.
The War Raiders challenged The Undisputed ERA for the NXT Tag Team Championship, Matt Riddle continued his feud with Kassius Ohno, and Ricochet defended the NXT North American Championship against Johnny Gargano. Bianca Belair challenged Shayna Baszler for the NXT Women's Championship while protecting an undefeated singles identity that had become central to her presentation. Tommaso Ciampa then defended the NXT Championship against Aleister Black. The closing image of Ciampa and Gargano standing together with championships extended their complicated relationship and immediately fed the post-show confrontation that led into Halftime Heat.
Watch, Skim or Skip?
- Matt Riddle vs. Kassius Ohno
The Card, On the Record
01War Raiders def. The Undisputed ERA — NXT Tag Team ChampionshipA
War Raiders and The Undisputed ERA open with the kind of tag match that immediately establishes a major-event standard. Kyle O'Reilly and Roderick Strong use quick tags, leg attacks, and tandem offense to isolate Rowe, while Hanson repeatedly changes the geometry of the match with power and surprising agility. The champions' control work matters because every War Raiders comeback feels earned rather than scheduled. The final stretch is excellent: Total Elimination fails, Hanson survives the knee drop, and the challengers answer with increasingly violent combinations until Fallout finally ends the reign. The crowd is fully invested by the closing minutes, and the championship change feels both surprising and deserved. It is an A-level opener with structure underneath the spectacle.
An elite tag-title opener with excellent escalation and a satisfying championship change.
02Matt Riddle def. Kassius OhnoB-
Riddle and Ohno work a compact grudge match built around Ohno trying to bully the smaller fighter out of his comfort zone. Ohno controls the middle with heavy strikes, a leg drop, and attacks around ringside, while Riddle's barefoot presentation becomes part of the violence when Ohno stomps and even bites the foot. The match is physical without needing a long runtime. Riddle's comeback is abrupt but believable because his repeated elbows turn the finish into a stoppage-style submission rather than another conventional pin. The crowd never reaches the level of the opener, and the ending arrives before the match develops another gear. Still, nine minutes is enough to resolve the feud cleanly and give Riddle a credible win.
A physical, efficient feud-ender that never threatens the card's upper tier.
03Johnny Gargano def. Ricochet — NXT North American ChampionshipA+
Gargano and Ricochet produce the night's masterpiece by combining spectacular athletic counters with Gargano's ongoing moral slide. Ricochet lands on his feet from positions that would normally end sequences, forcing Gargano to improvise rather than simply run through familiar offense. The athletic escalation is extraordinary, but the key moment comes when Gargano exposes the concrete and initially hesitates to use it. That choice gives the finishing stretch a character consequence. Once Gargano finally brainbusters Ricochet onto the floor and follows with the slingshot DDT, the title change feels like both a wrestling victory and another step toward Ciampa's worldview. The match flirts with excess through repeated counters and near falls, yet the crowd never loses the thread. It is a genuine A-plus centerpiece.
A spectacular championship classic strengthened by Gargano's character story.
04Shayna Baszler def. Bianca Belair — NXT Women's ChampionshipB
Baszler and Belair follow the card's most spectacular match by working a very different contest around Belair's shoulder and unbeaten confidence. Baszler attacks the arm early, uses the ring post and joint manipulation to create a clear target, and forces Bianca to sell through every comeback. Belair gradually wins the crowd with her strength, the hair-whip spot, and repeated attempts to escape the Kirifuda Clutch. The outside involvement from Marina Shafir and Jessamyn Duke is the main weakness because the match already has enough credibility without interference. Even so, Belair never submits; she powers up repeatedly before finally passing out. The finish protects the challenger while preserving Baszler's dominance. It is a strong championship match in a difficult card position.
A strong title defense that elevates Belair despite unnecessary outside involvement.
05Tommaso Ciampa def. Aleister Black — NXT ChampionshipA-
Ciampa and Black close with a long main event built around one simple idea: damage Black's left leg until Black Mass becomes unreliable. Ciampa repeatedly attacks the knee against the post, steps, and mat, and Black's selling gives later counters a reason to fail. The match improves substantially once the leg begins affecting Black's offense, especially when attempted suplexes and Black Mass collapse underneath him. Ciampa's repeated Fairytale Endings verge on overkill, and the twenty-six-minute runtime could lose several minutes without harming the story. The final sequence still works because Black's last attempt at Black Mass fails when the leg gives out, allowing Ciampa to finish decisively. It is a strong, coherent championship main event just below classic level.
A strong injury-driven main event whose length and finisher repetition keep it below elite.
BOOKING VERDICTA-
The booking succeeds because the major outcomes all move important stories forward. War Raiders win the NXT Tag Team Championship cleanly after surviving The Undisputed ERA's best combinations. Johnny Gargano defeats Ricochet for the North American Championship by fully embracing the more ruthless choices Ciampa had been encouraging, including the exposed-concrete brainbuster. Shayna Baszler hands Bianca Belair her first major singles defeat without making her look inferior, and Tommaso Ciampa retains decisively enough to close Aleister Black's NXT Championship chase. Every winner leaves with a clearer direction than they had entering the building.
There are still choices worth questioning. Baszler receives help from Marina Shafir and Jessamyn Duke before finally choking Belair unconscious, adding protection for Bianca but also cluttering a match that was working without it. Gargano's title victory is excellent storytelling, yet the darker character direction becomes complicated almost immediately by Ciampa's real-life injury in the weeks that follow. Those later circumstances do not erase what works here. Booking earns an A-minus because Phoenix advances titles, characters, and the central Gargano-Ciampa saga with very little wasted movement.
CROWD & PRESENTATIONA
Phoenix gives the card the responsive TakeOver atmosphere the format depends on. The audience is hot for the tag-title opener, becomes even louder as Hanson and Rowe survive Undisputed ERA combinations, and treats Gargano versus Ricochet as the anticipated showcase from the opening exchanges. Bianca Belair gradually wins the crowd during her comeback against Baszler, while Ciampa and Black receive sustained main-event attention despite following several strong matches. The crowd's investment helps the show feel larger than its two-and-a-half-hour runtime without forcing every bout to chase the same rhythm.
Presentation is similarly disciplined. The desert-themed opening material and War Raiders entrance give the show a distinct local identity, while the five-match structure keeps transitions brief and titles visually central. Mauro Ranallo, Nigel McGuinness, and Percy Watson consistently explain the body-part work and storyline stakes without stepping on the action. The main event runs longer than it needs to and Gargano-Ricochet embraces the era's escalating near-fall style, but neither problem overwhelms the broadcast. Crowd and presentation earns an A because the environment repeatedly amplifies the wrestling rather than distracting from it.
HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB-
NXT TakeOver: Phoenix earns a B-minus for Historical Significance. Johnny Gargano's North American Championship win is an important chapter in the Gargano-Ciampa story, and the final image of both men holding championships becomes one of the clearest visual markers of their temporary alignment. War Raiders begin their NXT Tag Team Championship reign, Bianca Belair suffers the first major singles defeat of her NXT rise, and Aleister Black's main-event loss effectively closes his TakeOver run before his transition toward the main roster. Those developments give the event more consequence than an ordinary monthly stop.
The ceiling remains limited because Phoenix is not where the era's largest turning points ultimately occur. Gargano's defining championship victory comes later at TakeOver: New York, Ciampa's neck injury abruptly changes the planned direction, and the War Raiders reign is comparatively short. The event also does not introduce a lasting match concept, business shift, or structural change to NXT. Its legacy is best understood as an excellent bridge between WarGames 2018 and New York rather than a landmark by itself. B-minus reflects meaningful continuity without confusing strong placement in NXT history for transformational importance.
WHAT AGED WELL
- War Raiders and The Undisputed ERA deliver a tag-title opener with excellent escalation and a clean championship change.
- Johnny Gargano versus Ricochet still feels like a major athletic showcase with a character story layered underneath the spectacle.
- Bianca Belair looks stronger in defeat because the match forces Baszler to survive repeated comeback attempts before the stoppage.
- Aleister Black's damaged-leg selling gives the NXT Championship main event a clear thread through its final stretch.
- The compact five-match format keeps the event focused and prevents a weak undercard from developing.
WHAT AGED POORLY
- Gargano and Ricochet rely heavily on escalating counters and near falls, a style that became increasingly common across late-era TakeOvers.
- Baszler's outside help is unnecessary in a match where Belair was already gaining credibility through the wrestling.
- Ciampa and Black push the main event beyond the point where its leg-injury story needs twenty-six minutes.
- The closing Gargano-Ciampa direction never receives the planned continuation because Ciampa's neck injury changes the program.
- Matt Riddle and Kassius Ohno feel more like a strong television feud conclusion than a match equal to the rest of the card.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands
Contemporary and retrospective reviews converge on Phoenix as an excellent TakeOver that sits just below the brand's very best events. TJR's later annual ranking places Phoenix at 8.5/10, while another contemporary TJR review gives War Raiders versus Undisputed ERA 4.5 stars and Gargano versus Ricochet five stars. Other published ratings generally identify Gargano-Ricochet as the clear match of the night, with the tag-title opener and Ciampa-Black forming the next tier. Reviewers are more divided on Belair-Baszler and Riddle-Ohno, but neither is commonly treated as a bad match.
That shape supports an A-minus WrestleGrade at 8.9. The five scores average 8.500, with Gargano-Ricochet at A-plus, the tag opener at A, and the NXT Championship main event at A-minus. The final WrestleGrade lands there because Phoenix has one truly elite centerpiece rather than multiple classics. Historical Significance remains separate at B-minus: the title changes and Gargano-Ciampa closing image matter, but the more enduring turning points of the story occur elsewhere.
RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology23 sources
These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.
- TJR WrestlingJohn Canton full-event review and later 2019 TakeOver ranking context
- TJR WrestlingKurt Zamora live review with detailed match ratings
- Bleacher ReportMatch-by-match results, grades, reaction, and highlights
- 411ManiaFull-event retrospective review
- Inside PulseFull-event TakeOver review
- SportskeedaFull-event written review
- WhatCultureComplete-card ranking from worst to best
- Ringside IntelTakeOver report card with match grades
- Cageside SeatsContemporary event results and reaction
- BVM SportsRetrospective recap and match-quality discussion
- IWNerdPublished match star-rating reference
- Belly Up SportsTakeOver and Royal Rumble star-rating comparison
- SportskeedaMatch ranking for all five live-card bouts
- WrestleTalk2019 TakeOver match ranking and comparative star-rating context
- 411ManiaJanuary 2019 match ranking including the tag-title opener
- Wrestling Observer Figure Four OnlineContemporary newsletter review and ratings context
- Pro Wrestling Dot NetContemporary live review of the complete TakeOver card
- CAGEMATCHExact-event identity, card, venue, and fan-rating reference
- Pro Wrestling Dot NetRoyal Rumble weekend reader-poll context including TakeOver Phoenix
- WWEOfficial post-TakeOver aftermath and storyline fallout
- WWEOfficial TakeOver Phoenix results and championship outcomes
- WWE NXTOfficial full-event replay
- Pro Wrestling HistoryEvent date, venue, card, and reported attendance cross-check
WHERE TO WATCHStream This Event
Stream This Event
YouTube - Free
WWE NXT currently provides an official full-event replay of NXT TakeOver: Phoenix on YouTube.
WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.