WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn II (2016): The Night NXT Proved Its First Brooklyn Show Was No Fluke

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

WWE/NXTAugust 20, 2016Barclays Center
THE WRESTLEGRADEB+8.4 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#237OF 1030
PROMOTION
WWE NXT
DATE
August 20, 2016
VENUE
Barclays Center
LOCATION
Brooklyn, New York
ATTENDANCE
15,671
EVENT TYPE
PLE
THE FILE

NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn II succeeds because the second trip to Barclays Center feels like confirmation rather than imitation. The Revival and Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa deliver the night's best match, Asuka and Bayley turn a title defense into an emotional farewell, and Shinsuke Nakamura closes the show by defeating Samoa Joe for the NXT Championship. Around those pillars, Bobby Roode and Ember Moon make memorable in-ring debuts while Austin Aries and No Way Jose give the card a solid opening chapter. The show rarely wastes time and almost every segment points somewhere meaningful.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

It does not quite reach the legendary level of the first Brooklyn TakeOver because the early card is more introductory than spectacular and the main event, while very good, is not the night's strongest match. Yet that is a minor limitation on an otherwise superb two-and-a-half-hour event. WrestleFile lands at B+, 8.4 out of 10: an outstanding NXT show with elite tag wrestling, major title consequences, a tremendous crowd, and enough historical importance to remain essential viewing from the brand's peak era.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn II took place on August 20, 2016, at Barclays Center in Brooklyn, New York, with 15,671 in attendance. It was the 11th NXT TakeOver event and the second annual Brooklyn edition, staged as part of WWE's SummerSlam weekend. The previous year's Brooklyn event had established that NXT could fill a major arena and produce a show with its own identity, so the sequel carried unusually high expectations. Samoa Joe entered as NXT Champion, Asuka as NXT Women's Champion, and The Revival as NXT Tag Team Champions, while Shinsuke Nakamura, Bayley, Gargano, and Ciampa challenged those titleholders.

Six matches aired live on the TakeOver broadcast and are included in the WrestleFile average. Austin Aries submitted No Way Jose; Ember Moon defeated Billie Kay in her NXT in-ring debut; Bobby Roode defeated Andrade "Cien" Almas in Roode's televised NXT in-ring debut; The Revival retained the NXT Tag Team Championship over Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa; Asuka retained the NXT Women's Championship over Bayley; and Nakamura defeated Joe to win the NXT Championship. Tye Dillinger against Wesley Blake and Authors of Pain against TM-61 were taped for future NXT television and are excluded from the live-event match average.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • The Revival (Dash Wilder & Scott Dawson) (c) def. Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa — NXT Tag Team Championship
  • Asuka (c) def. Bayley — NXT Women's Championship
  • Shinsuke Nakamura def. Samoa Joe (c) — NXT Championship
SKIM
  • Austin Aries def. No Way Jose
  • Bobby Roode def. Andrade "Cien" Almas
SKIP
  • Ember Moon def. Billie Kay
MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

The Card, On the Record

01Austin Aries def. No Way JoseC+

Aries gives No Way Jose his most substantial TakeOver test by forcing the energetic character into a more serious match than his entrance suggests. Jose uses the crowd well and finds enough athletic offense to create several believable openings, while Aries repeatedly slows him with sharper positioning and veteran aggression. The Last Chancery becomes the obvious danger throughout the closing stretch, and Aries eventually secures the submission cleanly. The match itself is good rather than remarkable, but the post-match angle adds value when Aries reapplies the hold and Hideo Itami arrives. Itami finally hitting the GTS in an NXT ring produces a huge reaction and instantly creates a new direction. As an opener, the segment succeeds by establishing stakes, giving Jose credibility, and moving Aries toward something more important.

VERDICT

A solid opener elevated by Aries' veteran control and the post-match GTS angle that immediately launches his issue with Hideo Itami.

02Ember Moon def. Billie KayC

The match exists to introduce Ember Moon, and it wisely does not pretend to be more complicated than that. Billie Kay gets enough early control to keep Moon from looking like she is simply performing a move exhibition, while Moon's speed and body language establish a different presence from the rest of the women's division. The audience is waiting for the finish from the moment Moon climbs the ropes, and the Eclipse immediately delivers the visual WWE wants. The bout is too short to develop a real competitive story, which limits the score, but it succeeds completely as a debut vehicle. Moon leaves with a signature move, a distinctive presentation, and a strong crowd reaction. That is more useful than forcing ten minutes of artificial drama into her first major appearance.

VERDICT

A brief, effective debut showcase whose entire value is introducing Ember Moon's presentation and unforgettable Eclipse finisher.

03Bobby Roode def. Andrade "Cien" AlmasB-

Roode's entrance nearly overshadows the match before the bell, which is both a blessing and the central challenge of the bout. The crowd sings along with "Glorious" and treats him like an established superstar, while Almas has to win attention back through increasingly athletic offense. Almas' springboard movement and corkscrew dive create the most dynamic sequences, and Roode responds with veteran timing, a spinebuster, and a more deliberate pace. The closing pumphandle slam gives Roode a clean victory without requiring Almas to look overwhelmed. As wrestling, it is a good midcard match rather than a TakeOver classic. As a star introduction, it is highly successful. Roode's presentation is instantly clear, while Almas shows flashes of the talent that will become much more effective after his later character change.

VERDICT

A good debut match transformed by Roode's spectacular presentation, with Almas supplying the athleticism needed to keep the wrestling from becoming secondary.

04The Revival (Dash Wilder & Scott Dawson) (c) def. Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa — NXT Tag Team ChampionshipA

The Revival, Gargano, and Ciampa build a tag match around increasingly desperate attempts to make one clean tag or one final save. Dawson and Wilder control with classic heel positioning, cutting off the ring and repeatedly punishing Gargano's leg, while the challengers use speed and explosive combinations whenever they escape. The crowd believes multiple false finishes because every near fall follows a logical breakdown rather than random move trading. A missed tag, a foot on the rope, and frantic saves keep the tension climbing without making the referee look incompetent. The finish is perfect for the champions: Wilder attacks Gargano's injured leg, Dawson traps him in the inverted figure-four, and Gargano finally submits. The Revival retain while the challengers leave feeling like inevitable future champions. It is elite tag-team wrestling.

VERDICT

The night's masterpiece, combining classic tag psychology, brilliant false finishes, and a submission ending that elevates both champions and challengers.

05Asuka (c) def. Bayley — NXT Women's ChampionshipB+

Asuka and Bayley improve on their Dallas dynamic by making Bayley far more willing to meet the champion's aggression directly. Bayley survives the Asuka Lock, answers the champion's strikes with increasingly defiant offense, and creates a believable moment when the Bayley-to-Belly nearly produces the title change. Asuka never loses her aura, however, and the final sequence turns into a striking exchange that ends with repeated kicks and a clean pin. The result is decisive without making Bayley look diminished. What follows matters almost as much as the match: Asuka leaves, and Brooklyn gives Bayley a prolonged standing ovation as she embraces familiar faces at ringside and says goodbye to NXT. The wrestling is excellent; the farewell transforms it into one of the show's defining emotional moments.

VERDICT

An excellent title match and even better farewell, allowing Asuka to retain cleanly while Bayley leaves NXT with the crowd fully behind her.

06Shinsuke Nakamura def. Samoa Joe (c) — NXT ChampionshipA-

Nakamura's violin-assisted entrance gives the main event enormous atmosphere before Joe even reaches the ring. Once the match begins, Joe tries to ground the challenger with submissions, power, and increasingly violent strikes, while Nakamura keeps returning to knees and sudden bursts of offense. The pace is deliberate early and grows more compelling as both men survive signature attacks. Joe's Muscle Buster produces the best near fall, and Nakamura's first Kinshasa fails to finish the champion, forcing another escalation. A final sequence of knees ends with Nakamura landing the decisive Kinshasa and winning the title cleanly. The match is not as intricate as the tag-title bout, but it delivers the championship moment the show needs. Nakamura's celebration feels like the arrival of NXT's next central star.

VERDICT

A great championship main event with an unforgettable entrance, a strong finishing stretch, and a clean title change that crowns Nakamura as NXT's next centerpiece.

BOOKING VERDICTA-

The Booking Verdict earns an A- because the show handles almost every major direction with confidence. Nakamura defeating Samoa Joe is the right championship change at the right moment, completing Nakamura's rapid rise without making Joe look weak. Asuka retaining over Bayley closes Bayley's NXT chapter on a loss that still feels dignified, allowing the crowd's post-match farewell to carry the emotional weight. The Revival retaining against Gargano and Ciampa is similarly smart because the champions win through elite tag-team execution while the challengers leave more over than they entered.

The debut material also works. Ember Moon is presented as an immediate attraction without asking her first match to carry too much complexity, while Bobby Roode's elaborate entrance and win over Almas establish his star presentation instantly. Aries beating No Way Jose keeps the veteran moving while Hideo Itami's post-match GTS creates a fresh issue. The only reservation is that the title-heavy back half leaves the early matches feeling like setup by comparison. Even then, the results are coherent, decisive, and directly connected to NXT's next several months.

CROWD & PRESENTATIONA

Crowd and Presentation earns an A because Brooklyn again behaves like an essential part of the show. The audience sings along with Bobby Roode's entrance before he has established himself as a weekly NXT star, reaches a fever pitch during The Revival against Gargano and Ciampa, and gives Bayley a prolonged farewell that turns a title loss into one of the event's most emotional scenes. Nakamura's violin-assisted entrance then raises the scale again before the main event, creating one of the most memorable NXT championship entrances of the era.

The broadcast is equally disciplined. Tom Phillips and Corey Graves keep the focus on competition, the video packages give each important match enough context, and the two-and-a-half-hour runtime prevents fatigue from becoming a problem. Roode's descending platform, Ember Moon's debut aura, and Nakamura's live violin entrance give the show visual variety without burying the wrestling under production. Barclays Center looks enormous compared with Full Sail University, yet the NXT presentation remains recognizable. The event feels like a true arena supercard while preserving the compact pacing that made TakeOver shows easier to watch than many main-roster events.

HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB+

Historical Significance earns a B-plus because Brooklyn II changes the direction of multiple major NXT careers in one night. Shinsuke Nakamura becomes NXT Champion by defeating Samoa Joe, establishing the "Era of Strong Style" and setting up their rematch cycle. Bayley wrestles her final NXT match before moving to Raw, receiving a farewell that closes one of the brand's defining developmental stories. Bobby Roode and Ember Moon make their TakeOver in-ring debuts, and both become champions in NXT within the following year.

The Revival's victory over Gargano and Ciampa is equally important in retrospect. Their match helps establish the rivalry and tag-team standard that soon defines NXT's division, leading directly toward later classic rematches and the eventual DIY story. Brooklyn II also reinforces Barclays Center as NXT's annual SummerSlam-weekend home, turning the Brooklyn TakeOver concept into a recurring subseries. No single historical fact is as revolutionary as the first Brooklyn show's proof of concept, but the sequel is packed with transitions that shape NXT's next era. It is a genuine crossroads event for champions, future champions, departures, and debuts.

WHAT AGED WELL
  • The Revival against Gargano and Ciampa becoming a model for NXT tag-team main-event quality.
  • Bayley's emotional farewell after losing cleanly to Asuka.
  • Shinsuke Nakamura's violin entrance and championship victory feeling like a true star coronation.
  • Bobby Roode and Ember Moon arriving with presentations that immediately communicate future importance.
WHAT AGED POORLY
  • The early undercard serving more as introductions than as essential TakeOver-level matches.
  • No Way Jose's character never developing into the sustained NXT success the opening match briefly suggests.
  • Andrade Almas still being presented before the heel transformation that eventually unlocks his best NXT work.
  • The main event being historically important while falling slightly short of the tag-title match's in-ring peak.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

The critical record is extremely positive. TJR Wrestling gave Brooklyn II 9 out of 10 and called it another outstanding TakeOver, identifying the NXT Tag Team Championship match and Nakamura-Joe as its best bouts. ESPN rated Revival-Gargano/Ciampa at 4.5 out of 5 and praised the match's storytelling, execution, and psychology. Contemporary coverage from Bleacher Report, Pro Wrestling Dot Net, 411Mania, Pro Wrestling Torch, Cageside Seats, and others consistently highlights the tag-title match, Bayley's farewell, Nakamura's title win, and the crowd as the show's defining strengths.

The final B+ / 8.4 reflects exceptional pacing, major title consequences, Brooklyn's atmosphere, Nakamura's coronation, Bayley's farewell, and the historical value of Roode and Moon arriving on the same card. The adjustment is substantial because the event functions far better as one coherent NXT supercard than the arithmetic average of two introductory matches and four stronger bouts suggests. It stops short of A- because the first half is solid rather than elite and the main event does not surpass the tag-title match.

RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
20 sources

These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

  1. Bleacher ReportBrooklyn II winners, grades, reaction, and highlights
  2. ESPNBrooklyn II live match recaps and five-point evaluations
  3. TJR WrestlingJohn Canton complete-show review and 9/10 event score
  4. IWNerdWrestling Observer star-rating reference for Brooklyn II
  5. CAGEMATCHBrooklyn II ratings and canonical event identity
  6. 411ManiaKevin Pantoja review of NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn II
  7. WhatCultureBrooklyn II match ranking from worst to best
  8. Cageside SeatsBrooklyn II match-of-the-night audience reaction
  9. IMDbBrooklyn II audience-review context
  10. Pro Wrestling TorchContemporary Brooklyn II event coverage
  11. Bleacher ReportBrooklyn II live results, reaction, and analysis
  12. WhatCultureBrooklyn II notable-moments retrospective
  13. WhatCultureHistorical ranking context among NXT TakeOver events
  14. Smark Out MomentBrooklyn II post-show recap and review
  15. CNJ RadioBrooklyn II recap and review
  16. IWNerdBayley match-rating context including Brooklyn II against Asuka
  17. Pro Wrestling Dot NetJason Powell live review of Brooklyn II
  18. Wrestling Inc.Contemporary Brooklyn II live results coverage
  19. YouTubeVideo listing associated with NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn II
  20. WWEOfficial Brooklyn II results and canonical event identity
WHERE TO WATCH

Stream This Event

Checked August 26, 2026STATUS
No confirmed full-event stream

A YouTube URL is associated with NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn II, but its exact current United States full-event availability could not be independently verified. No current exact provider is claimed.

WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.