WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

Survivor Series 2006: Big Milestones, Small Matches

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

WWENovember 26, 2006Wachovia Center
THE WRESTLEGRADED4.6 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#976OF 1015
PROMOTION
World Wrestling Entertainment
DATE
November 26, 2006
VENUE
Wachovia Center
LOCATION
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
ATTENDANCE
15,400
EVENT TYPE
PPV
THE FILE

Survivor Series 2006 is packed with moments that sound more important in a history book than they feel while watching the show. Batista completes a ten-month journey by regaining the World Heavyweight Championship, Mickie James ends Lita’s full-time career as champion, CM Punk receives a striking Philadelphia reaction, and ECW participates in Survivor Series for the first time. The problem is that almost every match is too short, too predictable, or too protective to turn those milestones into a great pay-per-view. Three elimination matches should create suspense through shifting numbers and unlikely survivors, yet all three largely serve as vehicles for obvious babyface victories. The card moves quickly, but it rarely feels consequential in the moment.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

That disconnect drives the D, 4.6 out of 10 WrestleGrade. There is little that is catastrophically bad, which separates Survivor Series from the year’s true disasters, but there is also almost nothing approaching elite wrestling. Team Cena against Team Big Show is the best complete match, Benoit and Chavo are solid within a cramped window, and Team DX’s clean sweep is entertaining as spectacle. The event becomes less satisfying as a complete experience because the booking repeatedly removes uncertainty before it can develop. Survivor Series 2006 matters for Batista, Lita, CM Punk, and the first ECW-era crossover, but its historical checklist is far stronger than its bell-to-bell resume.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

Survivor Series 2006 took place on November 26, 2006, at the Wachovia Center in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, with a reported attendance of 15,400. It was the twentieth annual Survivor Series and featured wrestlers from Raw, SmackDown, and ECW, marking the first edition after WWE revived ECW as a third brand earlier that year. Seven matches aired on pay-per-view, while Carlito defeated Charlie Haas in a non-televised match before the broadcast. Three traditional elimination matches formed the spine of the card: Team WWE Legends against the Spirit Squad, Team DX against Team Rated-RKO, and Team Cena against Team Big Show. The main event featured King Booker defending the World Heavyweight Championship against Batista in a last-chance match.

The show arrived during a transitional stretch for several major acts. Batista had surrendered the world title because of injury in January and spent much of 2006 working back toward the championship. Lita had announced that Survivor Series would be her final regular WWE match, creating a natural passing-of-the-torch opportunity against Mickie James. CM Punk was only months into his WWE television run and was still assigned to ECW, but Philadelphia reacted to him like a much larger star during Team DX’s entrance and match. Mr. Kennedy was being elevated through his program with The Undertaker, while Bobby Lashley was moving into a leading ECW role. The card therefore contains several meaningful career markers even though none of its seven matches lasted fifteen minutes.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • Team Cena vs. Team Big Show — Survivor Series Elimination Match
  • Team DX vs. Team Rated-RKO — Survivor Series Elimination Match
SKIM
  • Chris Benoit vs. Chavo Guerrero — United States Championship
  • Mickie James vs. Lita — Women's Championship
  • Mr. Kennedy vs. The Undertaker — First Blood Match
  • King Booker vs. Batista — Last Chance Match for the World Heavyweight Championship
SKIP
  • Team WWE Legends vs. The Spirit Squad — Survivor Series Elimination Match
MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

The Card, On the Record

01Team WWE Legends def. The Spirit Squad — Survivor Series Elimination MatchF

Ric Flair, Dusty Rhodes, Sgt. Slaughter, and Ron Simmons are presented as a nostalgia act, and the Philadelphia crowd is happy enough to see the veterans. The match itself has almost no rhythm because eliminations arrive quickly and the Spirit Squad spend more time feeding recognizable spots than building a competitive story. Simmons disappears by countout, Rhodes falls soon after, and Flair is left to run through the remaining opponents. The final sequence gives Flair the expected feel-good survival without making the younger team look dangerous. It functions as a crowd-pleasing attraction, but as wrestling it is thin, slow, and oddly dismissive of the team that still needed credibility.

VERDICT

A nostalgia win that pleases the crowd while sacrificing suspense and the younger team.

02Chris Benoit def. Chavo Guerrero — United States ChampionshipC-

Chris Benoit and Chavo Guerrero work a compact, technically sound title match that never receives enough time to become what their abilities suggest. Benoit controls early with suplexes and pressure, while Chavo uses Vickie Guerrero’s presence to create openings and slow the champion’s momentum. The Frog Splash near fall gives the challenger his best chance before Benoit regains control. Vickie’s distraction contributes to the finish, but Benoit ultimately forces Chavo to submit cleanly. The action is competent and occasionally sharp, yet the eight-minute runtime prevents deeper escalation, leaving a potentially excellent pairing at the level of a decent television title defense.

VERDICT

Solid technical work squeezed into a match too short to reach a higher level.

03Mickie James def. Lita — Women's ChampionshipD+

Lita’s announced final match gives the title bout an emotional hook even though the wrestling remains uneven. Mickie James bumps with energy and fights from underneath, while Lita controls with familiar offense and nearly wins after the moonsault. The closing exchanges create a few believable near falls before Mickie lands the DDT and wins the championship. As an in-ring farewell, the match does its basic job by establishing Mickie as the division’s next focal point. The atmosphere after the bell, however, turns Lita’s exit into a degrading comedy segment, which damages the event-level memory of what should have been a more respectful retirement moment.

VERDICT

A respectable title change followed by a farewell presentation that aged badly.

04Team DX def. Team Rated-RKO — Survivor Series Elimination MatchC-

Team DX’s five-on-five match is memorable more for the personalities and the clean sweep than for competitive drama. CM Punk receives a striking reaction from the Philadelphia crowd, while Shawn Michaels, Triple H, and the Hardys keep the pace lively with quick tags and familiar signature offense. Mike Knox is eliminated almost immediately, Johnny Nitro submits to Punk, and the heel team never establishes enough control to make a comeback believable. The final eliminations of Edge and Randy Orton produce a loud finish, but the shutout makes Rated-RKO feel secondary. It is entertaining as a star showcase and important for Punk’s crowd response, yet structurally it is closer to a victory lap than a suspenseful elimination match.

VERDICT

A fun star showcase whose clean sweep removes nearly all competitive tension.

05Mr. Kennedy def. The Undertaker — First Blood MatchD

The First Blood stipulation gives Mr. Kennedy a believable route to victory without asking him to pin The Undertaker, but the match never becomes a balanced contest. Kennedy spends much of the bout surviving while Undertaker controls the physical exchanges and repeatedly threatens to end things. MVP’s interference creates the decisive opening when a chair shot draws blood from Undertaker and gives Kennedy the official win. The post-match beating immediately shifts the focus back to Undertaker, who leaves Kennedy bloodied after a brutal chair shot and Tombstone. The result technically elevates Kennedy, yet the aftermath undercuts the upset so thoroughly that the victory feels more like a plot device than a breakthrough.

VERDICT

A protected upset whose violent aftermath makes the winner feel secondary.

06Team Cena def. Team Big Show — Survivor Series Elimination MatchC+

The strongest traditional elimination match on the card benefits from a broader mix of styles and a faster series of eliminations. Umaga’s early disqualification protects his unbeaten aura, Rob Van Dam and Sabu supply bursts of speed, and Big Show gives the face team a final obstacle large enough to feel meaningful. Several eliminations happen too quickly to create individual stories, but the sequence remains easy to follow and keeps the crowd involved. Bobby Lashley gains useful exposure beside John Cena, and their combined attack on Big Show produces a clear closing image. It is not a classic Survivor Series match, but it has the card’s best balance of pace, star power, and crowd satisfaction.

VERDICT

The card’s best elimination match, energetic enough to overcome several rushed exits.

07Batista def. King Booker — Last Chance Match for the World Heavyweight ChampionshipD+

Batista finally regaining the championship in the same building where he surrendered it gives the main event a strong story before the bell. The actual match is deliberate and rarely reaches the urgency that a last-chance stipulation should create. King Booker controls stretches with veteran timing, while Batista’s power offense produces the loudest reactions, including a Batista Bomb near fall saved by the bottom rope. Queen Sharmell’s involvement leads to the closing belt spot, with Batista using Booker’s own weapon and taking the title. The payoff is historically meaningful and emotionally straightforward, but the wrestling is merely adequate, and the predictable outcome keeps the match from generating sustained suspense.

VERDICT

A satisfying title payoff attached to a main event that never rises above adequate.

BOOKING VERDICTD

The booking earns a D because Survivor Series repeatedly chooses safe outcomes over dramatic elimination-match structure. Ric Flair survives three members of the Spirit Squad by himself, which gives the veteran a crowd-pleasing ending but does little for a younger act already treated as disposable. Team DX then defeats Team Rated-RKO without losing a single member, turning a potentially major rivalry into a dominant exhibition. Team Cena wins with John Cena and Bobby Lashley surviving, while Umaga is removed almost immediately by disqualification so his unbeaten record remains protected. Each decision is understandable in isolation, but together they make the elimination matches feel engineered rather than competitive.

The singles matches are similarly cautious. Mr. Kennedy technically beats The Undertaker, yet the post-match destruction immediately restores Undertaker’s dominance and weakens the upset. Benoit retains against Chavo in a short match that never has time to create genuine doubt, while Batista’s last-chance stipulation makes the main-event result easy to anticipate. Mickie James defeating Lita is the right long-term move, but the degrading comedy after Lita’s retirement match turns a major departure into a punchline. The show advances several stories and crowns the correct new champions, yet it consistently sacrifices suspense and emotional weight while doing so.

CROWD & PRESENTATIONB-

Philadelphia is one of Survivor Series 2006’s better assets. The audience responds strongly to Batista, DX, the Hardys, and especially CM Punk, whose chants stand out because he was still early in his main-roster run. The traditional Survivor Series format also creates a recognizable old-school atmosphere, and the multi-brand lineup gives the event a broader feel than many brand-exclusive pay-per-views from the period. The crowd is happy to see the legends, celebrates the clean babyface victories, and gives Batista a satisfying reaction when he regains the championship. Those responses keep the event from feeling lifeless even when the matches are short.

Presentation still falls short of a true Big Four standard. The main event never develops the sustained crowd heat expected from a world-title climax, and several elimination matches move so quickly that entrances and personalities feel more significant than the wrestling. Lita’s farewell is the largest tonal failure: instead of allowing the title change and retirement to breathe, the show follows with a humiliating comedy routine that overwhelms the emotional moment. Production sells Batista’s return to the top effectively and captures Punk’s popularity, but the overall card often resembles a collection of television segments placed on a larger stage. Crowd and Presentation earns a B- because Philadelphia contributes more energy than the match layouts deserve.

HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB

Survivor Series 2006 earns a B for Historical Significance because several developments outlast the event’s mediocre reputation. It was the first Survivor Series to include WWE’s revived ECW brand, and the mixed-brand elimination teams represented a new version of the traditional format. Team DX’s five-man clean sweep is also remembered as an unusually dominant Survivor Series result, with CM Punk receiving one of the night’s most notable crowd reactions. Batista regaining the World Heavyweight Championship in Philadelphia completed the recovery story that began when injury forced him to surrender the same title in the same arena earlier in the year. That victory restored him as SmackDown’s central champion heading toward WrestleMania 23.

The event also marks the end of Lita’s first full-time WWE run, with Mickie James winning the Women’s Championship in her retirement match. The farewell presentation has aged poorly, but the match remains a clear transition point in the division after Trish Stratus had retired two months earlier. Mr. Kennedy’s victory over The Undertaker continued an important attempt to elevate him, while Bobby Lashley’s role beside Cena foreshadowed his immediate move into the ECW title picture. The show’s lasting importance therefore comes from career transitions and brand history rather than classic matches. Few editions of Survivor Series demonstrate more clearly that historical relevance and viewing quality can travel on completely different tracks.

WHAT AGED WELL
  • CM Punk’s crowd reaction during Team DX remains a revealing early sign of how quickly he was connecting with WWE audiences.
  • Batista regaining the World Heavyweight Championship provides a clean payoff to his injury-and-return story.
  • Team Cena versus Team Big Show moves briskly and gives Bobby Lashley meaningful exposure beside the company’s top champion.
  • Mickie James winning the title is a logical transition after the retirements of Trish Stratus and Lita.
  • The Raw, SmackDown, and ECW crossover gives the traditional Survivor Series format a broad roster feel.
WHAT AGED POORLY
  • Lita’s retirement presentation becomes degrading comedy immediately after what should have been an emotional farewell.
  • Team DX’s clean sweep removes almost all suspense and makes Rated-RKO’s side look surprisingly weak.
  • The legends match uses the Spirit Squad primarily as disposable opponents rather than credible younger wrestlers.
  • Kennedy’s upset over Undertaker is undercut by the extensive beating Kennedy takes after the decision.
  • None of the seven pay-per-view matches lasts fifteen minutes, limiting the depth of a supposed Big Four event.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

The critical record settles around the same conclusion from several directions: Survivor Series 2006 is below average without being a complete disaster. TJR’s retrospective scored the show 4.5 out of 10, while a later TJR review landed at 5 out of 10 and emphasized that none of the matches rose above three stars. 411Mania’s contemporary 3R’s review was even lower at 4 out of 10, criticizing mediocre wrestling and the lack of value for a major pay-per-view. The CAGEMATCH event page sits below the midpoint as well, reinforcing that the weak reputation is not limited to one critic. Across those reactions, the common complaint is not catastrophic execution but a shortage of memorable, high-end wrestling.

The positive evidence is also consistent. Team Cena against Team Big Show is frequently identified among the stronger matches, Team DX’s clean sweep is remembered as an entertaining moment, and Benoit against Chavo receives credit for solid work within limited time. Batista’s championship victory, Lita’s retirement match, and CM Punk’s crowd response give the card more historical value than its match quality would suggest. That distinction supports a 4.6 overall score against a 5.0 match distribution. The lower WrestleGrade reflects the way repetitive babyface wins, short runtimes, protected finishes, and the mishandled farewell presentation.

RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
20 sources

These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

  1. TJR WrestlingFull-event review with a 5/10 final score and match-by-match analysis
  2. TJR WrestlingRetrospective full-event review with a 4.5/10 final score and match ratings
  3. 411ManiaContemporary complete-show assessment and 4/10 final evaluation
  4. 411Mania2006 year-end match-level context for Survivor Series
  5. Inside PulseContemporary review describing an entertaining but limited event
  6. Bleacher ReportRetrospective list of the event's leading moments
  7. Bleacher ReportRetrospective event analysis and historical framing
  8. WhatCulturePlacement of Survivor Series within WWE's 2006 pay-per-view slate
  9. WhatCultureHistorical facts and context surrounding Survivor Series 2006
  10. Retro Pro WrestlingRetrospective complete-event review
  11. CultaholicRetrospective historical takeaways from Survivor Series 2006
  12. KB Wrestling ReviewsRetrospective full-card review and match commentary
  13. CAGEMATCHEvent user-rating page for Survivor Series 2006
  14. CAGEMATCHMatch-rating page for Team DX versus Team Rated-RKO
  15. TheSportsterRetrospective placement among weaker Survivor Series events
  16. ProFightDBEvent results and match-star reference for Survivor Series 2006
  17. IMDbUser-review page for WWE Survivor Series 2006
  18. AmazonHome-video customer review perspective
  19. YardbarkerRetrospective ranking of 2000s Survivor Series events
  20. FanSidedHistorical ranking across Survivor Series editions
WHERE TO WATCH

Stream This Event

Checked August 24, 2026STATUS
No confirmed full-event stream

A public Netflix title link exists for Survivor Series 2006, but a complete current United States replay could not be verified. No current full-event provider is claimed.

WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.