- Billy Kidman vs. Vampiro
- Ric Flair vs. Terry Funk - Texas Death Match
SuperBrawl 2000: WCW Needed Seven Matches to Find One Worth Watching
The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.
- PROMOTION
- World Championship Wrestling
- DATE
- February 20, 2000
- VENUE
- Cow Palace
- LOCATION
- Daly City, California
- ATTENDANCE
- 8,569
- EVENT TYPE
- PPV
SuperBrawl 2000 is WCW producing a pay-per-view that feels defeated before the first match starts. The company has eleven bouts, a world-title triple threat, Hogan versus Luger, Flair versus Funk, a returning Sting and even James Brown in the building. On paper, there are enough recognizable names to create a major show. In practice, the card spends most of its first half proving how little those names matter without coherent wrestling around them.
Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis
The opening stretch is brutal. The cruiserweight final is sloppy and cold, the hardcore title match is a four-minute walking brawl with a distraction finish, Norman Smiley loses a handicap comedy match, the contractual KISS Demon “special main event” lasts under four minutes and Tank Abbott versus Big Al becomes one of the strangest and most dangerous spectacles WCW ever aired. Booker is then stuck losing the Harlem Heat name and the letter T in another bad match.
The show becomes merely tolerable in the second half. Kidman and Vampiro work hard enough to produce the first decent wrestling of the night, the Mamalukes and Flair-Crowbar at least try to create a chaotic stipulation match, and Flair versus Funk finally gives the card a match with structure. Even those successes are muted by a dead crowd and exhausted presentation.
SuperBrawl 2000 earns F / 3.7. The eleven reviewed matches average 3.973, but the overall experience is worse than that number because the first hour is historically poor and the world-title main event collapses into referee interference in under eight minutes. The event is memorable mostly as evidence that WCW's 2000 problems were no longer isolated mistakes; they had become the operating system.
Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting
SuperBrawl 2000 took place on February 20, 2000, at the Cow Palace in Daly City, California. The event drew a reported attendance of 8,569 and approximately 70,000 pay-per-view buys. It was the tenth SuperBrawl event produced by World Championship Wrestling.
Eleven matches aired. Sid Vicious defended the WCW World Heavyweight Championship against Scott Hall and Jeff Jarrett in a three-way match, Hulk Hogan faced The Total Package, and Ric Flair wrestled Terry Funk in a Texas Death match. The undercard included a Cruiserweight Championship tournament final, a Hardcore Championship match and a WCW World Tag Team Championship Sicilian Stretcher match.
The event also featured the contractual KISS Demon appearance against The Wall, Tank Abbott against Big Al in a Leather Jacket on a Pole match, Booker against Big T in a match over the Harlem Heat identity, and Billy Kidman against Vampiro. James Brown made a surprise appearance during Ernest Miller's segment.
SuperBrawl 2000 became Scott Hall's final WCW match. Sting also returned after an absence to save Hogan from Flair and Luger following their match, while the company's broader creative direction continued drifting toward the collapse that would precede the April Bischoff-Russo reboot.
Watch, Skim or Skip?
- The Mamalukes vs. David Flair & Crowbar - WCW World Tag Team Championship Sicilian Stretcher Match
- Sid Vicious vs. Scott Hall vs. Jeff Jarrett - WCW World Heavyweight Championship
- The Artist Formerly Known as Prince Iaukea vs. Lash LeRoux - WCW Cruiserweight Championship
- Brian Knobbs vs. Bam Bam Bigelow - WCW Hardcore Championship
- 3 Count vs. Norman Smiley
- The Wall vs. The Demon
- Tank Abbott vs. Big Al - Leather Jacket on a Pole Match
- Big T vs. Booker - Harlem Heat Name and Letter T Match
- Hulk Hogan vs. The Total Package
The Card, On the Record
01The Artist Formerly Known as Prince Iaukea vs. Lash LeRoux - WCW Cruiserweight ChampionshipD-
The cruiserweight tournament ends with two wrestlers who receive almost no reaction from the Cow Palace. LeRoux tries to create movement with a dive and corner offense, while The Artist works at a slower pace and several transitions look uncertain. The match never resembles the division's best years.
Paisley spends much of the bout on the apron and eventually helps derail LeRoux's top-rope offense, allowing The Artist to land the diving DDT and win the vacant championship. The title change gives the division a champion but no momentum. Six minutes of sloppy wrestling and a distraction finish make this a deeply underwhelming tournament final.
A cold tournament final gives the cruiserweight title to a wrestler the crowd barely acknowledges.
02Brian Knobbs vs. Bam Bam Bigelow - WCW Hardcore ChampionshipF
Bigelow and Knobbs immediately leave the ring and walk through the crowd, but the trip produces almost nothing beyond one table spot before they return. The hardcore environment feels less like escalating violence and more like two wrestlers searching for objects while the audience waits for the finish.
Fit Finlay repeatedly becomes involved, Bigelow hits Greetings From Asbury Park and then chooses not to cover. That delay allows Knobbs to recover and use a trash-can lid for the title change. Four minutes, outside interference and little meaningful offense make the championship feel like a prop in another shallow brawl.
A four-minute walking brawl ends with interference and another forgettable Hardcore Championship change.
033 Count vs. Norman SmileyD-
Norman Smiley provides the personality, dancing between bursts of offense and trying to survive a three-on-one disadvantage with injured ribs. 3 Count finally use the numbers advantage logically, cutting him off whenever he starts building momentum and forcing the match into a quick handicap structure.
The comedy keeps the segment from becoming completely lifeless, but the wrestling is still thin. After several aerial attacks, Shannon Moore applies the Boston crab and Smiley submits. The result finally gives 3 Count a victory in the program, yet four minutes of cartoonish handicap material adds little to a pay-per-view already desperate for substance.
Norman's comedy keeps a thin handicap match alive until 3 Count finally use the obvious numbers advantage.
04The Wall vs. The DemonF
WCW labels this a “special main event” because of the contractual expectations surrounding the KISS Demon character, which immediately creates a joke the match cannot overcome. The Wall attacks in the aisle, both men trade awkward power offense and the crowd begins rejecting the bout almost immediately.
The Demon briefly rallies before The Wall catches him and finishes with the chokeslam in under four minutes. Nothing about the presentation suggests a main event beyond the announcers repeating the phrase. The match is historically fascinating as contract compliance and almost worthless as wrestling.
A contractual 'special main event' lasts three minutes and exposes the gap between marketing language and reality.
05Tank Abbott vs. Big Al - Leather Jacket on a Pole MatchF
The match barely resembles professional wrestling. Abbott and Big Al tie themselves together with a belt, trade stiff-looking strikes and spend long stretches standing or repositioning around the pole. The crowd has almost no reason to understand the relationship or choose a side.
The dangerous finish makes the segment worse. Abbott carries Al toward the ropes and Al falls awkwardly to the floor before Abbott retrieves the jacket. Afterward, Abbott produces a knife and holds it near Al's throat while the broadcast cuts away. The spectacle is memorable for all the wrong reasons and belongs near the bottom of any WCW match list.
Almost no wrestling, a frightening fall and a post-match knife angle make this one of WCW's bleakest spectacles.
06Big T vs. Booker - Harlem Heat Name and Letter T MatchF
Booker moves well enough to create brief hope, landing the axe kick, Book End and missile dropkick while Big T struggles to keep pace. The match's premise is already damaging because one of WCW's most talented wrestlers is fighting over a team name and a single letter rather than moving upward on the card.
The lights go out during Booker's apparent victory, an unexplained man appears and the distraction allows Big T to hit the Pearl River Plunge. The finish gives Booker another humiliating setback without making Big T feel important. Five minutes of poor wrestling and confused storyline logic produce one of the show's clearest wastes of talent.
Booker loses his identity to a blackout and distraction while WCW keeps a future world champion trapped in nonsense.
07Billy Kidman vs. VampiroC
Kidman and Vampiro finally give the audience a match built around athletic ideas instead of a gimmick. They exchange quick counters, aerial offense and repeated attempts to use or reverse the powerbomb. The pace is substantially better than anything earlier on the card.
Execution prevents the match from becoming genuinely good. Several headscissors and top-rope sequences look mistimed, and both wrestlers have to recover visibly from awkward transitions. Kidman eventually pulls Vampiro down from the ropes and gets the pin. Seven minutes of effort earn a passing grade mainly because the match feels like actual wrestling on a show that badly needs it.
Kidman and Vampiro finally bring energy, but multiple botches keep the first decent match from becoming a good one.
08The Mamalukes vs. David Flair & Crowbar - WCW World Tag Team Championship Sicilian Stretcher MatchC-
The stipulation creates a chaotic brawl with tables, stretchers, Daffney interference and constant movement between the ring and floor. Crowbar supplies most of the athletic offense, while the Mamalukes use their size and numbers to make the elimination structure understandable.
The match becomes slower whenever the teams have to tape someone to a stretcher and physically move the body backstage. David Flair is eliminated first, leaving Crowbar alone, and Vito eventually splashes him through a ringside table before the champions finish the job. The effort is obvious, but the rules make eleven minutes feel much longer.
A willing brawl gets dragged down by the slow mechanics of taping wrestlers to stretchers and hauling them away.
09Ric Flair vs. Terry Funk - Texas Death MatchC
Flair and Funk finally give the card a match with history and escalation. They trade chops and punches, fight on the floor and build toward piledrivers and tables rather than opening with the biggest stunt. Their familiarity allows the match to remain coherent even when the death-match rules require repeated pins and ten counts.
The crowd never gives them the reaction the work deserves, and the finish is oddly flat after several more violent spots. Funk crashes through a table, Flair scores the pin and then survives the standing count while Funk cannot. The structure and commitment are enough for a C, but this is a shadow of their best work together.
Two masters create the show's most coherent fight, but a dead crowd and flat ending cap the ceiling.
10Hulk Hogan vs. The Total PackageD-
Hogan is one of the few wrestlers who still receives a recognizable reaction, but the match immediately settles into the familiar punch-and-kick formula. Luger spends much of the bout walking through offense, while Hogan repeatedly uses the cast on his injured arm as a weapon without meaningful consequence.
Elizabeth and Jimmy Hart become involved around ringside, Luger lands a low blow in front of the referee and Hogan eventually wins with the cast and legdrop. The finish is messy rather than dramatic. Eight minutes of recycled offense suggest a rivalry that has no new story to tell.
Hogan's formula still gets a reaction, but Luger sleepwalks through a recycled match with another messy finish.
11Sid Vicious vs. Scott Hall vs. Jeff Jarrett - WCW World Heavyweight ChampionshipD-
The world-title match begins with enough urgency to suggest a short sprint. Hall attacks Jarrett, Sid powers through both challengers and the three-way structure gives the champion opportunities to clean house. Then the referees become the story.
Jarrett knocks out official after official, Slick Johnson refuses to count a Hall victory and Roddy Piper eventually appears in a referee shirt to remove the crooked official. Sid chokeslams Jarrett and powerbombs Hall to retain. Scott Hall's final WCW match lasts under eight minutes and ends inside an officiating circus, leaving the championship secondary to another pile of plot devices.
Scott Hall's final WCW match becomes an eight-minute referee parade with the world title trapped underneath.
BOOKING VERDICTF
The booking earns F because the show repeatedly chooses angles over matches and then fails to make the angles matter. Paisley helps decide the cruiserweight championship, Fit Finlay helps decide the hardcore championship, the KISS Demon fulfills a contractual “main event” obligation in a three-minute loss and Booker loses his identity because the lights go out and an unexplained man appears.
Tank Abbott versus Big Al is the low point. A leather jacket is placed on a pole, the wrestlers tie themselves together with a belt, Al takes a frightening fall to the floor and Abbott produces a knife after the match. The segment is not building a championship, a star or a feud with any long-term value. It exists because WCW has decided spectacle itself is the story.
The world-title main event continues the same philosophy. Multiple referees are knocked out, Slick Johnson refuses to count Hall's fall, Roddy Piper appears in a referee shirt and Sid eventually retains after roughly eight minutes. The championship becomes background scenery for officiating chaos.
F is unavoidable because almost every major decision weakens the competitive logic of the card. Even the good choices, such as Sting's return and Flair defeating Funk, are buried inside a show where the audience is constantly asked to care about authority figures, mystery doors, contract loopholes and arbitrary stipulations instead of wrestling.
CROWD & PRESENTATIOND
Crowd and Presentation earns D because the Cow Palace audience spends much of the night sounding exhausted or indifferent. Scott Keith noted that thousands of the announced attendees were complimentary tickets, and the camera repeatedly captures a crowd that barely reacts to championship matches, major bumps and several attempted surprises.
Tony Schiavone, Mike Tenay and Mark Madden are forced to explain a show that rarely makes their jobs easy. They move between tournament history, commissioner politics, the mystery door, KISS contractual language, pole-match rules, James Brown teases and the parade of referees in the main event. The broadcast often sounds like exposition layered over wrestling nobody is watching.
There are isolated presentation successes. Sting's return finally produces a strong reaction, James Brown's surprise appearance creates a genuine celebrity moment and the Cow Palace still looks like a recognizable big-event venue. Those moments prove the audience is capable of responding when given something clear.
The larger presentation remains lifeless. Several matches are announced with exaggerated importance that the action cannot support, most entrances feel disconnected from meaningful stakes and the show repeatedly cuts backstage to authority or mystery segments. D reflects a professional national broadcast carrying a product that no longer feels nationally important.
HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEA-
Historical Significance Grade: A-. SuperBrawl 2000 is historically dense even though most of that history is uncomfortable. Scott Hall wrestles his final WCW match in the world-title three-way before disappearing from the company, ending one of the most important runs of the Monday Night War era.
The event also contains the infamous Tank Abbott-Big Al knife angle. Abbott holds a knife near Al's throat after the match while the broadcast quickly cuts away, creating one of the clearest examples of late-WCW shock television overshooting any useful wrestling purpose.
The KISS Demon match is another lasting artifact. WCW labels The Demon versus The Wall a “special main event” largely to satisfy a contractual obligation connected to the KISS character. The wording has become part of the broader story of WCW's expensive promotional partnerships and creative shortcuts.
James Brown's surprise appearance with Ernest Miller is the rare positive historical oddity, while Sting's return resumes his role in the upper-card picture. A- reflects a show remembered less for wrestling than for a collection of moments that explain why WCW 2000 remains such a heavily studied period.
WHAT AGED WELL
- Billy Kidman versus Vampiro has aged best because both wrestlers at least attempt to create a modern, athletic match. They exchange powerbomb counters, aerial offense and quick reversals, and the pace feels dramatically fresher than the slow or gimmick-heavy material before it. The execution is imperfect, but the effort is obvious.
- Flair versus Funk also holds up better than most of the card. Their history gives the Texas Death match context, and both veterans understand how to build around increasingly violent spots rather than simply rushing from weapon to weapon. The crowd is quiet, yet the structure remains understandable.
- The James Brown appearance has gained charm with distance. Unlike many celebrity cameos, the performer is genuinely famous, Ernest Miller's character is directly connected to James Brown's music and the surprise gets a real response. It is one of the few segments on the show that succeeds on its own terms.
- Sting's return also remains an effective moment. After a long night of indifference, the audience reacts immediately when Sting runs in to help Hogan. The simplicity of the return is a reminder that WCW did not always need complicated swerves to make something feel important.
WHAT AGED POORLY
- Tank Abbott versus Big Al has aged catastrophically. The wrestling is almost nonexistent, Al's fall from the ropes to the floor looks dangerously uncontrolled and the post-match knife angle creates genuine discomfort rather than dramatic tension. It is difficult to imagine a modern major promotion presenting the same sequence without immediate criticism.
- The KISS Demon match also looks worse with context. Calling a three-minute lower-card match a “special main event” to satisfy contractual language makes the promotion look more interested in technical compliance than presenting a credible product. The crowd's boredom completes the picture.
- Booker's treatment is another major problem. One of WCW's future world champions is stuck fighting over the Harlem Heat name and the letter T against Big T, then loses after a blackout and unexplained distraction. Knowing what Booker becomes later only emphasizes how badly the company is using him here.
- The world-title match is similarly dated. Four or five referees, corrupt officiating and a surprise Roddy Piper appearance are compressed into fewer than eight minutes. Modern viewing makes the overbooking even harder to defend because there is almost no actual title match underneath the plot devices.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands
Kevin Pantoja's 2016 411Mania review gives SuperBrawl 2000 a 1.0 out of 10. He rates only Kidman-Vampiro and Flair-Funk at two stars, calls the first half nearly worst-show-ever territory and argues that the second half merely keeps the event from receiving a zero.
Arnold Furious reaches almost the same verdict at 1.5 out of 10. His review criticizes the volume of filler, the short world-title main event and a card that takes seven matches before clearing one star. The repeated conclusion across both reviews is not that one match ruins the show; it is that the entire event lacks enough worthwhile material to justify pay-per-view status.
Scott Keith's 2024 rewatch is similarly severe. He gives the cruiserweight opener one-half star, the hardcore match a dud, the KISS Demon match and Tank Abbott match negative assessments, Kidman-Vampiro two stars, Flair-Funk two stars and the main event one star. He calls the event all-time terrible and emphasizes how dead the crowd is throughout.
The WrestleFile match scores average 3.973. The complete event receives F / 3.7 because the few acceptable second-half matches cannot outweigh the historically poor opening stretch and overbooked main event. Historical Significance is graded separately at A- and does not mechanically inflate the match-quality average.
RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology20 sources
These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.
- Retro Pro WrestlingFull-event retrospective and match-by-match assessment
- CagematchExact-event identity and current event rating reference
- Cagematch - ratingsCurrent event and match reception reference
- ProFightDBExact-event card and results identity cross-check
- 411Mania archiveHistorical SuperBrawl 2000 retrospective reference
- CrazyMaxHistorical video review and match assessment
- Wrestling Observer NewsletterContemporary SuperBrawl review and business context
- CultaholicComparative ranking among WCW's 2000 pay-per-views
- TheSportsterComparative event-quality context within WCW's 2000 schedule
- WhatCultureComparative worst-pay-per-view retrospective context
- The History of WWEWCW February 2000 chronology and results cross-check
- Wrestling EpicenterSuperBrawl results-history cross-check
- ProWrestlingOnlyCommunity retrospective discussion and match reception
- BrainbustrEvent and individual match reception reference
- Sean O'Maniac Wrestling ReviewsFull-event retrospective
- Inside PulseContemporary post-event commentary
- KB Wrestling ReviewsFull-event retrospective with F-minus overall assessment
- Scott's Blog of Doom - 2024Modern full-event rewatch with individual match ratings
- 411Mania - Kevin PantojaModern full-event retrospective with 1.0 overall rating
- 411Mania - Arnold FuriousHistorical full-event retrospective with 1.5 overall rating
WHERE TO WATCHStream This Event
Stream This Event
No confirmed full-event viewing provider is recorded for this pass.
WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.