- Air Boom (Evan Bourne & Kofi Kingston) (c) def. Awesome Truth (The Miz & R-Truth) by Disqualification — WWE Tag Team Championship Match
- Dolph Ziggler (c) def. Jack Swagger, Alex Riley & John Morrison — United States Championship Fatal 4-Way Match
- Mark Henry def. Randy Orton (c) — World Heavyweight Championship Match
- John Cena def. Alberto Del Rio (c) by Submission — WWE Championship Match
- Triple H def. CM Punk — No Disqualification Match (Triple H Must Resign as COO if He Loses)
Night of Champions 2011: Mark Henry Finally Reaches the Top
The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.
- PROMOTION
- World Wrestling Entertainment
- DATE
- September 18, 2011
- VENUE
- First Niagara Center
- LOCATION
- Buffalo, New York
- ATTENDANCE
- 11,000
- EVENT TYPE
- PPV
Night of Champions 2011 is an entertaining but uneven event whose lasting value comes from Mark Henry finally winning a world championship. His clean victory over Randy Orton is the night's defining moment and the strongest payoff of the Hall of Pain rise. Cena and Del Rio produce a good WWE Championship match, Ziggler's four-way is lively, and the undercard moves at a reasonable pace. The card succeeds more often than it fails, even when several finishes are designed primarily to extend television stories.
Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis
The main event keeps the show from reaching a higher tier. Triple H and Punk have a heated brawl, but repeated interference from Miz, R-Truth, Laurinaitis and Nash turns the finish into a maze of competing angles. Cena also ends Del Rio's first title reign very quickly, and the tag-title opener closes on a disqualification. Night of Champions earns a B because its historic world-title change and solid wrestling outweigh the creative clutter. It remains clearly below Money in the Bank and SummerSlam, but comfortably above a weak transitional pay-per-view.
Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting
Night of Champions 2011 took place on September 18 at First Niagara Center in Buffalo, New York, with an announced attendance of 11,000. It was the fifth annual Night of Champions and the first WWE pay-per-view after the original brand extension ended in August. Seven matches aired live after Daniel Bryan defeated Heath Slater in a dark match. The event's defining concept remained intact: all six active WWE championships were defended on the same card.
Alberto Del Rio defended the WWE Championship against John Cena after cashing in on CM Punk at SummerSlam. Randy Orton defended the World Heavyweight Championship against Mark Henry, who had won a twenty-man battle royal to become number one contender. Air Boom defended the WWE Tag Team Championship against Awesome Truth, Cody Rhodes defended the Intercontinental Championship against Ted DiBiase, Dolph Ziggler defended the United States Championship in a four-way, and Kelly Kelly defended the Divas Championship against Beth Phoenix. The non-title main event featured CM Punk against WWE COO Triple H under No Disqualification rules, with Triple H required to resign as COO if he lost. Kevin Nash, The Miz, R-Truth and John Laurinaitis were all connected to that increasingly complicated power struggle.
Watch, Skim or Skip?
- Cody Rhodes (c) def. Ted DiBiase — Intercontinental Championship Match
- Kelly Kelly (c) def. Beth Phoenix — Divas Championship Match
The Card, On the Record
01Air Boom (Evan Bourne & Kofi Kingston) (c) def. Awesome Truth (The Miz & R-Truth) by Disqualification — WWE Tag Team Championship MatchC+
Air Boom and Awesome Truth open Night of Champions with a tag-title match that has good pace but sacrifices its competitive payoff for storyline escalation. Bourne and Kingston create the faster offense through quick tags and aerial bursts, while Miz and Truth repeatedly slow the match by isolating one champion and arguing with the referee. The finish grows directly from that tension. Miz lands the Skull Crushing Finale on Bourne, but the referee is occupied with Truth and misses the immediate cover. When Bourne survives, Miz loses control and shoves the referee, drawing the disqualification. Air Boom retain the titles, while Miz and Truth attack the official afterward. The angle advances Awesome Truth's conspiracy story, but the disqualification keeps a lively opener from producing a satisfying wrestling conclusion.
A lively opener with useful storyline heat, weakened by a disqualification that replaces the competitive finish.
02Cody Rhodes (c) def. Ted DiBiase — Intercontinental Championship MatchC+
Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase turn their former partnership into a compact Intercontinental Championship match built around familiarity rather than elaborate offense. DiBiase knows Rhodes well enough to counter several early attempts at control, while Rhodes keeps redirecting the match toward his masked heel character and opportunistic shortcuts. The bout never receives enough time to develop into a major grudge match, but the rivalry gives the exchanges more purpose than a random title defense would have. Late in the match, DiBiase removes Rhodes' protective face mask and tries to use it as a weapon. Rhodes avoids the shot, catches DiBiase in a roll-up and holds the tights to secure the pin. The champion retains through cheating, preserving his momentum while leaving DiBiase with a credible complaint.
A decent rivalry match with a character-consistent cheating finish, though it never grows into a major title defense.
03Dolph Ziggler (c) def. Jack Swagger, Alex Riley & John Morrison — United States Championship Fatal 4-Way MatchB-
The United States Championship Fatal 4-Way gives the middle of the card needed speed and lets four wrestlers create constant threats without requiring a long control segment. Morrison provides the most dynamic movement, Riley brings straightforward offense, and Swagger's power gives Ziggler opportunities to steal advantages rather than dominate directly. Vickie Guerrero's presence adds tension around Ziggler and Swagger without determining the final exchange. The decisive sequence fits the champion perfectly. Swagger hits Morrison with the Gutwrench Powerbomb and appears ready to capitalize, but Ziggler throws Swagger out of the ring and immediately covers Morrison. The pin allows Ziggler to retain by taking advantage of someone else's work. It is efficient four-way booking and gives the title match a clean official result without making the champion look overpowering.
A good four-way title match with a sharp opportunistic finish that suits Ziggler's character.
04Mark Henry def. Randy Orton (c) — World Heavyweight Championship MatchA-
Mark Henry's victory over Randy Orton is the emotional and historical centerpiece of Night of Champions because the match finally converts the Hall of Pain push into a world championship. Henry attacks Orton's knee and uses his size to prevent the champion from building the explosive counter rhythm that normally creates the RKO. Orton still produces credible comeback bursts, which makes Henry's control feel earned rather than inevitable. The closing sequence is direct and powerful. Henry counters an RKO attempt, plants Orton with the World's Strongest Slam and scores the clean pin. There is no interference, fluke or technicality attached to the title change. After fifteen years in WWE, Henry leaves Buffalo as World Heavyweight Champion, and the decisive win validates the entire Hall of Pain transformation.
A career-defining clean title win that turns the Hall of Pain into a fully realized main-event act.
05Kelly Kelly (c) def. Beth Phoenix — Divas Championship MatchC+
Kelly Kelly and Beth Phoenix improve the physical credibility of their SummerSlam rivalry by giving Phoenix more control in front of her hometown Buffalo crowd. Beth repeatedly uses her strength to force Kelly into defensive positions, while Kelly relies on movement and counters rather than trying to match the challenger power for power. The crowd wants the hometown title change and reacts strongly whenever Phoenix appears close to finishing the match. A superplex creates her best late opening. Kelly survives, catches Phoenix in a sudden roll-up and scores the pin to retain the championship. The clean official result keeps Kelly's reign intact, but the upset-style finish prolongs the program rather than closing it. The match is competent and energetic, though still limited by a short runtime.
A competent title defense helped by the hometown dynamic, but still too short to become a major championship match.
06John Cena def. Alberto Del Rio (c) by Submission — WWE Championship MatchB
John Cena and Alberto Del Rio work a solid WWE Championship match that restores Cena to the title only five weeks after Del Rio's SummerSlam cash-in. Del Rio targets Cena's arm and repeatedly looks for the Cross Armbreaker, while Cena builds toward the familiar power comeback without allowing Ricardo Rodriguez to dictate the match. Rodriguez eventually tries to interfere from the apron, but Cena knocks him away and keeps the finish centered on the wrestlers. Cena lands the Attitude Adjustment and then traps Del Rio in the STF. The champion submits, giving Cena a decisive title victory. The wrestling is good and the finish is clean, but the booking makes Del Rio's first reign feel transitional because it ends before the character has fully settled into championship status.
A good title match with a clean submission finish, held back by how quickly Del Rio's first reign ends.
07Triple H def. CM Punk — No Disqualification Match (Triple H Must Resign as COO if He Loses)B-
Triple H and CM Punk begin with the intensity their personal rivalry needs, but the No Disqualification main event gradually becomes overwhelmed by interference and competing story threads. They brawl through the arena, use chairs and the set, and Punk delivers an elbow drop through the broadcast table before the match begins to fracture. Miz and R-Truth attack both men, John Laurinaitis disrupts officiating, and Kevin Nash eventually arrives to attack Punk and confront Triple H. Punk survives multiple Pedigrees before Nash's Jackknife Powerbomb leaves him vulnerable. Triple H removes Nash with a sledgehammer, returns to the ring and lands a third Pedigree for the pin. The result keeps Triple H as COO, but the excessive outside involvement prevents the match from delivering a clean resolution to Punk's central grievance.
A compelling brawl buried beneath too much interference, leaving Punk's story more complicated than resolved.
BOOKING VERDICTB-
The best booking decision is unequivocal: Henry defeats Orton cleanly for the World Heavyweight Championship. After months of destruction, WWE does not dilute the payoff with interference or a fluke, and Henry immediately feels like a credible champion. Ziggler retains by stealing Swagger's work in the four-way, Rhodes cheats to retain against DiBiase, and Kelly survives Phoenix through a sudden roll-up. Those finishes all fit the characters even when they extend the feuds.
The weaker decisions are concentrated around the WWE title and the main event. Cena submits Del Rio only five weeks after Del Rio's first championship win, making that reign feel transitional. The tag-title match ends in disqualification to advance Awesome Truth's referee grievance. Punk versus Triple H then absorbs four outside parties and multiple referee disruptions before Triple H wins with a third Pedigree. The booking earns a B- because Henry's coronation is excellent, but too many other stories prioritize future complications over satisfying conclusions.
CROWD & PRESENTATIONB+
Buffalo gives Henry's championship victory the event's most important reaction. The crowd understands that a long career has reached a genuine breakthrough, and the clean World's Strongest Slam finish feels bigger because the match is not buried under outside interference. Phoenix also benefits from a hometown reaction against Kelly, while Cena and Del Rio receive the expected major-title atmosphere. The undercard crowd is steady rather than exceptional.
Presentation is strongest when WWE keeps the focus simple. Henry's post-match celebration, the championship imagery and the Night of Champions theme all reinforce the idea that titles matter. The Triple H-Punk main event moves in the opposite direction, with run-ins, referee confusion, Laurinaitis at ringside and Nash's return pulling attention away from the central rivalry. The event still looks like a polished major show, and all six championships being represented gives the broadcast a clear visual identity. The presentation grade settles at B+ because the title-focused concept works better than the closing chaos.
HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB+
Night of Champions 2011 matters most because Mark Henry wins the World Heavyweight Championship for the first time in his fifteen-year WWE career. The victory validates the Hall of Pain character and begins the strongest sustained main-event run of Henry's career. It is also WWE's first pay-per-view after the original brand extension ends, making the event an early example of the combined roster structure that follows.
The show also produces another WWE Championship change when Cena submits Del Rio, though Del Rio regains the title at Hell in a Cell two weeks later. The Punk-Triple H main event extends the power-struggle story into programs involving Kevin Nash, John Laurinaitis, Miz and R-Truth. Beth Phoenix's loss leads to her finally taking the Divas Championship at Hell in a Cell. As a complete event, Night of Champions is not a landmark on the level of Money in the Bank, but Henry's coronation gives it a permanent place in 2011 WWE history. That legacy remains unmistakable today.
WHAT AGED WELL
- Mark Henry's clean world-title victory remains one of the best championship payoffs of 2011.
- The Hall of Pain story feels fully validated by Henry pinning Orton without interference.
- The United States Championship four-way is compact and character-consistent.
- All six active championships being defended gives the event a clear identity.
- The first post-brand-extension pay-per-view has meaningful structural context.
WHAT AGED POORLY
- Triple H versus Punk becomes overwhelmed by run-ins and authority-story complications.
- Del Rio's first WWE Championship reign ends after only five weeks.
- The tag-title opener uses a disqualification instead of a decisive finish.
- Kelly Kelly versus Beth Phoenix remains too short for a major hometown title match.
- Several finishes function more as setup for television than as pay-per-view conclusions.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands
The event-focused review spread is mixed to positive and consistently places Henry's world-title victory among the night's strongest outcomes. Bleacher Report, 411Mania, TJR Wrestling, Cageside Seats, WrestleZone, Sportskeeda, WrestleView, DVD Talk and later rankings provide broad calibration. The recurring criticism concerns the overbooked Triple H-Punk main event, the short Del Rio reign and several finishes that exist mainly to continue television stories.
Henry-Orton provides the strongest peak, with Cena-Del Rio and the United States Championship four-way adding solid support. The final WrestleGrade reflects Henry's historic first world championship, the all-titles-defended concept and the first post-brand-extension setting. The final B recognizes an entertaining event whose historical centerpiece is stronger than its uneven creative structure.
RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology20 sources
These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.
- Bleacher Report - Top star gradesContemporary performer grading and event-level reaction.
- Bleacher Report - Cody Rhodes lessonsContemporary result analysis and title-match context.
- Bleacher Report - Thirteen things learnedComplete-event takeaways and booking analysis.
- Bleacher Report - Cena victory analysisWWE Championship result and aftermath context.
- 411Mania - Night of Champions Instant AccessContemporary complete-event grading and match analysis.
- 411Mania - The X Review Night of ChampionsIndependent complete-show review and match ratings.
- TJR Wrestling - Night of Champions recapComplete-show retrospective and match-quality calibration.
- Cageside Seats - Night of Champions live blogContemporary event-night reactions and result context.
- WrestleZone - Pay-per-reviewEvent review and booking assessment.
- WrestleZone - Night of Champions reviewIndependent complete-show review and match evaluation.
- Sportskeeda - Night of Champions reviewResults, review and storyline analysis.
- WrestleView - Night of Champions resultsContemporary results and event identity cross-checking.
- WWE.com - Night of Champions 2011 resultsPrimary results, title changes and stipulation cross-checking.
- ProFightDB - Night of Champions 2011Event identity, results and match-rating cross-checking.
- CAGEMATCH - Night of Champions 2011Event identity, card order and result cross-checking.
- Online World of Wrestling - Night of Champions 2011Detailed card and result cross-checking.
- DVD Talk - Night of Champions 2011 reviewHome-video retrospective and complete-event quality context.
- IWNerd - Meltzer ratingsHistorical match-rating context for the event.
- TheSportster - Night of Champions matches rankedRetrospective match ranking and card calibration.
- Daily DDT - Night of Champions 2011 reviewContemporary complete-show review and booking analysis.
WHERE TO WATCHStream This Event
Stream This Event
Netflix title 81929937 is associated with WWE Night of Champions, but the public title page does not expose enough detail to certify that the exact 2011 full-event replay is currently playable in the United States. No current exact provider is claimed.
WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.