WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

Night of Champions 2010: A Stronger Card Built on Actual Payoffs

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

WWESeptember 19, 2010Allstate Arena
THE WRESTLEGRADEB7.9 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#441OF 1015
PROMOTION
World Wrestling Entertainment
DATE
September 19, 2010
VENUE
Allstate Arena
LOCATION
Rosemont, Illinois
ATTENDANCE
13,851
EVENT TYPE
PPV
THE FILE

Night of Champions 2010 works because several championship stories finally produce the decisive results that SummerSlam withheld. Daniel Bryan submits The Miz to win the United States Championship, Kane pins The Undertaker cleanly, Dolph Ziggler beats Kofi Kingston without hiding behind a technicality, and Randy Orton closes the show by winning the WWE Championship in a strong elimination match. Even the tag-title turmoil creates a clear new direction. The card is not uniformly great, but it repeatedly rewards the audience with actual movement rather than another month of protected stalemates.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

The weaknesses are concentrated in the middle. Big Show versus CM Punk is brief, the women's unification match carries more historical weight than in-ring depth, and the tag turmoil is functional rather than exceptional. The event also lacks one transcendent match that would push it into the upper tier. Still, the two world-title matches, Bryan-Miz and the opener give the card a dependable backbone. Night of Champions earns a B because the match quality is consistently respectable and the booking has purpose. It feels like a major improvement over the previous month's frustration.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

Night of Champions 2010 took place on September 19 at Allstate Arena in Rosemont, Illinois, with a sellout attendance of 13,851. It was the fourth annual event under the Night of Champions name and centered on the theme that every active WWE championship would be defended. Seven pay-per-view matches took place after John Morrison defeated Ted DiBiase in a dark match. The card arrived one month after SummerSlam and placed the WWE Championship and World Heavyweight Championship into prominent rematches while also resolving several midcard title programs.

Sheamus defended the WWE Championship against Randy Orton, Wade Barrett, John Cena, Edge and Chris Jericho in a six-pack elimination challenge. Kane defended the World Heavyweight Championship against The Undertaker in a No Holds Barred match after attacking his brother at SummerSlam. The Miz defended the United States Championship against Daniel Bryan, Dolph Ziggler defended the Intercontinental Championship against Kofi Kingston, and the Hart Dynasty entered Tag Team Turmoil as champions. Michelle McCool represented the Women's Championship against Divas Champion Melina in a winner-takes-all unification match. Big Show versus CM Punk was the only non-title bout.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • Dolph Ziggler (c) def. Kofi Kingston — Intercontinental Championship Match
  • Daniel Bryan def. The Miz (c) — United States Championship Match
  • Kane (c) def. The Undertaker — World Heavyweight Championship No Holds Barred Match
  • Randy Orton def. Sheamus (c), Wade Barrett, John Cena, Edge & Chris Jericho — WWE Championship Six-Pack Elimination Challenge
SKIM
  • Michelle McCool def. Melina — Women's & Divas Championship Unification Lumberjill Match
  • Cody Rhodes & Drew McIntyre won the Tag Team Turmoil Match — WWE Tag Team Championship
SKIP
  • Big Show def. CM Punk — Singles Match
MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

The Card, On the Record

01Dolph Ziggler (c) def. Kofi Kingston — Intercontinental Championship MatchB

Dolph Ziggler and Kofi Kingston finally receive the straightforward championship match their SummerSlam interruption had denied them. The stipulation that Ziggler can lose the title by count-out or disqualification gives the champion a reason to wrestle carefully rather than rely on Vickie Guerrero to create an escape. Kingston pushes the pace with quick counters and repeated attempts to land Trouble in Paradise, while Ziggler keeps finding ways to survive long enough to reset. The finish is clean when Kingston gets tangled in the ropes and Ziggler immediately hits the Zig Zag for the pin. That result gives the rivalry an actual pay-per-view conclusion and helps the champion more than another protected finish would have. It is a solid opener with useful stakes.

VERDICT

A strong, clean opener that finally gives Ziggler and Kingston the decisive championship match SummerSlam did not.

02Big Show def. CM Punk — Singles MatchC-

Big Show versus CM Punk is the only non-title match on a card built around every active WWE championship, and it feels like the least essential bout as a result. Punk's character work keeps the segment from becoming completely flat, but the match is brief and structurally simple. Big Show absorbs most of Punk's offense, catches a springboard clothesline with a spear, then finishes with the knockout punch. The decisive win pays off Show's summer conflict with the Straight Edge Society, yet it also leaves Punk with little competitive credibility in the moment. The crowd gets a clean result and the feud receives closure. The wrestling never develops enough depth or suspense to feel worthy of the event's championship-heavy setting.

VERDICT

A short, decisive feud-ender that gives Big Show closure but never grows into a substantial pay-per-view match.

03Daniel Bryan def. The Miz (c) — United States Championship MatchA-

Daniel Bryan and The Miz turn their NXT history into the undercard's clearest wrestling success. Miz works from the position of a champion who believes Bryan does not belong at his level, while Bryan's technical offense gives the match a sharper identity than the surrounding card. Alex Riley creates the expected ringside threat without determining the outcome, allowing the championship change to feel earned. Bryan survives Miz's counters, repeatedly returns to the arm and finally forces the champion to submit to the LeBell Lock. The finish is decisive and emotionally satisfying because Bryan had returned only one month earlier at SummerSlam. Winning the United States Championship immediately validates that comeback and gives the feud a meaningful payoff rather than another continuation.

VERDICT

An excellent championship match with a clean submission finish that turns Bryan's return into a tangible main-roster breakthrough.

04Michelle McCool def. Melina — Women's & Divas Championship Unification Lumberjill MatchC

Michelle McCool and Melina are carrying more historical weight than the six-minute runtime can comfortably support. The match is supposed to unify WWE's two women's championships, yet the Lumberjill stipulation adds bodies around ringside without giving the wrestlers more room to build drama. Melina gets a few credible bursts, but Layla's interference starts a wider brawl among the lumberjills and shifts attention away from the champions. McCool capitalizes with a big boot and wins the unification match. The finish accomplishes the administrative goal of ending the original Women's Championship lineage, but it feels rushed for such a consequential change. The segment matters historically much more than it succeeds as a standalone match.

VERDICT

A historically important unification match compressed into too little time and weakened by ringside chaos.

05Kane (c) def. The Undertaker — World Heavyweight Championship No Holds Barred MatchB+

Kane and The Undertaker finally turn the summer mystery into a full championship fight, and the No Holds Barred stipulation gives their familiar rivalry more physical freedom. The match begins on the entrance ramp and moves through the ringside area before settling into a slower heavyweight structure. Undertaker's offense still carries the expectation that he will eventually regain control, which makes the finish more effective. He attempts the Tombstone, Kane reverses it and hits his own Tombstone for the clean pin. That result matters because Kane defeats Undertaker decisively rather than surviving through interference or a technicality. The pace is deliberate and not every exchange is sharp, but the championship story receives a rare clear victory for Kane.

VERDICT

A physical, story-driven title match elevated by the rare clean image of Kane pinning Undertaker with a Tombstone.

06Cody Rhodes & Drew McIntyre won the Tag Team Turmoil Match — WWE Tag Team ChampionshipB-

The Tag Team Turmoil match turns a thin championship division into a fast sequence of short pairings rather than asking one matchup to carry eleven minutes. The Hart Dynasty begin as champions and are eliminated by The Usos, immediately guaranteeing a title change. Santino Marella and Vladimir Kozlov provide the lightest section, while Evan Bourne and Mark Henry give the match a different athletic-power combination. Cody Rhodes and Drew McIntyre enter last and capitalize on the accumulated damage, with Rhodes pinning Bourne after Cross Rhodes to win the championship. The structure is more functional than dramatic, but it refreshes the titles and keeps several teams involved. The new champions feel opportunistic without needing a cheap finish.

VERDICT

A useful, brisk title-change vehicle that refreshes the tag division without becoming a major match in its own right.

07Randy Orton def. Sheamus (c), Wade Barrett, John Cena, Edge & Chris Jericho — WWE Championship Six-Pack Elimination ChallengeA-

The six-pack elimination main event gives Night of Champions the scale and unpredictability the card needs after several smaller title matches. Chris Jericho is eliminated almost immediately, creating a surprising tone before the match settles into a longer sequence involving Cena, Edge, Barrett, Sheamus and Orton. The Nexus helps Barrett eliminate Cena, but Cena later returns with a chair to prevent the faction from controlling the finish. Orton then eliminates Barrett and survives Sheamus's Brogue Kick before countering the High Cross into an RKO for the championship. The elimination format keeps the match moving and allows several rivalries to coexist without becoming chaotic. Orton's final victory feels decisive, and contemporary reviews correctly identify this as the strongest match on the event.

VERDICT

A strong elimination main event with good pacing, meaningful eliminations and a decisive Orton championship victory.

BOOKING VERDICTB+

Most of the major decisions land. Bryan submitting Miz is the clean payoff their NXT history needed and immediately validates Bryan's SummerSlam return. Kane pinning Undertaker with a Tombstone gives the champion a rare decisive victory over his brother. Orton winning the six-pack challenge creates a credible top champion without requiring another disqualification or count-out. Ziggler beating Kingston cleanly also repairs the lack of a finish at SummerSlam. Even Rhodes and McIntyre winning the tag titles gives the division a fresh combination.

The women's unification is more complicated. Retiring the original Women's Championship in favor of the Divas title creates a clear administrative direction, but the match is too short and too crowded to make the moment feel as important as the history warrants. Big Show defeating Punk provides closure without helping Punk much, and the tag turmoil feels transitional. Those are smaller concerns on a card where the central championship outcomes are logical and decisive. Compared with SummerSlam, the booking is much more willing to finish what it starts.

CROWD & PRESENTATIONB

The sold-out Allstate Arena crowd gives Night of Champions a stronger baseline of energy than several nearby 2010 events. Bryan's championship victory benefits especially from the audience recognizing the payoff to his feud with Miz, while Kane and Undertaker carry the aura of a major SmackDown rivalry. The six-pack main event also has enough star power to keep the building engaged through multiple eliminations. Orton's final RKO on Sheamus creates a simple, clear closing image with a new WWE Champion standing tall.

The event theme helps presentation because championship belts provide an immediate visual throughline across the card. The drawback is repetition: nearly every bout is introduced through title stakes, so the non-title Big Show-Punk match feels oddly detached. The unification match should feel historic but is presented in only a few minutes with a ring crowded by lumberjills. Production remains polished, and the Allstate Arena setting fits a major event. The show feels more consequential than spectacular, which is enough for the concept.

HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB

Night of Champions 2010 has unusually broad championship significance. Randy Orton begins another WWE Championship reign, Daniel Bryan wins his first main-roster WWE title by submitting The Miz, and Cody Rhodes and Drew McIntyre capture the tag championship. Kane's clean victory over Undertaker strengthens the World Heavyweight Championship story heading into Hell in a Cell. Those results make the event a meaningful transition point in several divisions rather than a card remembered for only one angle.

The biggest historical marker is the women's title unification. Michelle McCool wins the match, the original Women's Championship is retired, and the Divas Championship becomes the surviving title available across brands. Layla is recognized as the final holder of the original Women's Championship. The event is also the final Night of Champions during the first brand split before the split ends in 2011. That combination gives the show lasting structural importance even though none of the individual matches is usually treated as an all-time classic.

WHAT AGED WELL
  • Daniel Bryan submitting The Miz remains an excellent early main-roster championship payoff.
  • Kane pinning Undertaker cleanly gives their rivalry a rare decisive result for Kane.
  • The six-pack elimination main event is paced well and produces a clear Orton title win.
  • Ziggler and Kingston finally receive the decisive Intercontinental Championship finish SummerSlam denied them.
  • The card delivers multiple meaningful title changes without relying on constant interference.
WHAT AGED POORLY
  • The women's championship unification receives too little time for such a major historical transition.
  • Big Show versus CM Punk feels minor on a card otherwise built around championships.
  • Tag Team Turmoil is more functional than memorable.
  • The event lacks one truly elite match that defines the show on its own.
  • The retired Women's Championship lineage gives the unification match more historical weight than the presentation suggests.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

The available review material is generally more favorable than the reaction to SummerSlam 2010. TJR Wrestling specifically identifies the six-pack elimination challenge as the best match, while the packet includes both positive and more critical contemporary reviews from 411Mania, Bleacher Report and other outlets. The strongest recurring positives are the main event, Bryan's championship win and the number of meaningful title changes. The weaker matches are short enough that they do not overwhelm the card.

Orton's six-pack victory, Bryan-Miz and Kane-Undertaker carry the event, with Ziggler-Kingston providing solid support. Big Show-Punk and the short unification match lower the middle of the card. The final WrestleGrade reflects the historical significance of the women's title unification, Bryan's first main-roster championship, Orton's title win and a booking pattern that resolves more stories than it postpones. The final B fits a good, consequential event without overstating its match ceiling.

RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
20 sources

These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

  1. TJR Wrestling - Night of Champions 2010 reviewComplete-show retrospective and match-quality calibration.
  2. 411Mania - Night of Champions instant accessContemporary complete-card reaction and match-level analysis.
  3. 411Mania - Ring Crew Reviews Night of Champions 2010Retrospective complete-event review and match calibration.
  4. Pro Wrestling Dot Net - Night of Champions flashbackHistorical review of the two world-title matches and complete card.
  5. PWTorch - Night of Champions reader feedbackAudience-level retrospective reaction.
  6. Bleacher Report - Night of Champions reviewComplete-show reaction and match-quality context.
  7. Bleacher Report - Night of Champions reactionContemporary reaction to event results and booking.
  8. Bleacher Report - Night of Champions results reviewFull-card result analysis and event grading.
  9. Bleacher Report - Best PPV of the year argumentHigh-end positive calibration for the complete event.
  10. Bleacher Report - Night of Champions lessonsPost-event consequence and storyline analysis.
  11. WWE.com - Night of Champions resultsPrimary results and championship-change cross-checking.
  12. WWE.com - Night of Champions 2010Primary event identity and event-theme cross-checking.
  13. WrestleView - Night of Champions opening momentsContemporary event reporting and opening-match context.
  14. WrestleZone - Night of Champions resultsContemporary result sequencing and event identity context.
  15. WhatCulture - September pay-per-views rankedRetrospective series placement.
  16. TheSportster - Worst Night of Champions matches rankedHistorical comparison of weaker matches from the event series.
  17. Wrestling Epicenter - Night of Champions 2010 resultsResult and card-order cross-checking.
  18. ProFightDB - Night of Champions 2010Event identity, results and match-rating cross-checking.
  19. Cageside Seats - Night of Champions live coverageContemporary live-event reaction and match sequencing.
  20. Wrestling Epicenter - Night of Champions reportDetailed event report and match-result cross-checking.
WHERE TO WATCH

Stream This Event

Checked August 27, 2026STATUS
No confirmed full-event stream

Netflix title 81929937 is associated with WWE Night of Champions, but the public title page does not expose enough event-specific detail to certify that the exact 2010 full-event replay is currently playable in the United States. No current exact provider is claimed.

WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.