- The Varsity Club vs. The Fantastics — NWA United States Tag Team Championship
- Ricky Steamboat vs. Bob Bradley — continue through the Flair-Steamboat confrontation
Clash of the Champions V: St. Valentine's Massacre — A Two-Hour Commercial with One Great Fight
The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.
- PROMOTION
- World Championship Wrestling / National Wrestling Alliance
- DATE
- February 15, 1989
- VENUE
- Cleveland Convention Center
- LOCATION
- Cleveland, Ohio
- ATTENDANCE
- 5,000
- EVENT TYPE
- TV Special
Clash of the Champions V: St. Valentine's Massacre is what happens when a prime-time wrestling special realizes it has a pay-per-view to sell in five days and starts behaving like a two-hour commercial. The roster is loaded, the Flair-Steamboat story is on fire, and the Cleveland crowd is willing to cooperate.
Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis
Almost none of that turns into a great card. Instead, WCW stretches enhancement matches, hides its scheduled main-event challengers backstage, and saves its best material for interviews and brawls. As wrestling, it is one of the weakest early Clashes. As advertising for Chi-Town Rumble, it is annoyingly effective.
Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting
The fifth Clash aired live on TBS from the Cleveland Convention Center on February 15, 1989, drawing about 5,000 fans and a 4.6 television rating. WCW was now several months into the Turner era, but the company still operated under the NWA umbrella and still used the Clash as a national free-television supercard. The timing shaped everything. Chi-Town Rumble was only five days away, with Ric Flair defending the NWA World Heavyweight Championship against Ricky Steamboat and several other programs needing one last push. That meant the card had to entertain without giving away too much, a balance this show rarely finds.
The result is a seven-match special where the most memorable wrestling story happens outside the advertised matches. Flair and Steamboat's interview confrontation explodes into a wild brawl, with Steamboat attacking the champion so furiously that Flair ends up stripped down to his trunks and socks. Elsewhere, Sting, Michael Hayes and Junkyard Dog are locked behind a backstage gate so the Varsity Club can replace them in the six-man title main event. Those angles create urgency for the pay-per-view, but they also reveal the show's central weakness: the television special is more interested in pointing forward than in making its own matches feel essential.
Watch, Skim or Skip?
- The Midnight Express vs. The Russian Assassins
- The Road Warriors & Genichiro Tenryu vs. The Varsity Club — NWA World Six-Man Tag Team Championship
- Butch Reed vs. Steven Casey
- Lex Luger vs. The Blackmailer
- Rick Steiner vs. Rip Morgan
The Card, On the Record
01The Midnight Express vs. The Russian AssassinsD-
The Midnight Express are popular enough to drag this beyond its ingredients. Bobby Eaton and Stan Lane work crisp babyface offense, Jim Cornette gives the crowd someone to rally behind, and the Russian Assassins provide size without much imagination. The problem is repetition. Bearhugs and slow isolation stretches eat up too much of thirteen minutes, and the dark arena presentation makes the match feel flatter than the crowd reaction suggests. Eaton's athletic bursts help, but this is the sort of matchup that should have been a brisk momentum builder rather than a prolonged opening statement.
The Midnight Express supply the personality, but the structure is too slow and repetitive.
02Butch Reed vs. Steven CaseyF
Seventeen minutes is an extraordinary amount of television for a match whose central purpose is establishing Butch Reed as a serious heel. Steven Casey sells and moves well enough, but every comeback extends a contest that should be growing more one-sided. Reed's offense has weight and the finish is clean, yet the route there is filled with holding patterns, cautious pacing and little escalation. The audience never receives a convincing reason to believe Casey is about to win, so the length works against the premise. A seven-minute version could have made Reed look dangerous; this version makes him look busy.
A squash-match idea stretched until it stops functioning as a squash.
03Lex Luger vs. The BlackmailerF
The Blackmailer is Jack Victory under a mask, and the disguise does not magically create a compelling twelve-minute opponent for Lex Luger. Luger gets the expected power spots and carries himself like a star, but the match has no meaningful mystery once the bell rings. Hiro Matsuda's presence adds some storyline texture, while the masked gimmick gives commentary something to discuss, yet the wrestling itself settles into generic heel control and predictable babyface recovery. The superplex finish is decisive, but nearly thirteen minutes of television have passed without materially changing Luger's position or the audience's understanding of him.
Luger looks like Luger; almost nothing else about the match justifies the runtime.
04The Varsity Club vs. The Fantastics — NWA United States Tag Team ChampionshipD+
This is the closest the card comes to a satisfying standalone wrestling match. The Fantastics provide speed and sympathetic selling, while Mike Rotunda and Steve Williams finally have opponents who can make the Varsity Club's strength and control feel purposeful. The champions cut off the ring, force Bobby Fulton and Tommy Rogers to chase openings, and give the audience a clear tactical story. It never reaches the level suggested by the talent involved, but it has structure, stakes and enough urgency to distinguish itself from the surrounding filler. On this show, basic competence with a championship attached feels almost luxurious.
The night's best actual match because it has stakes, structure and opponents who fit.
05Ricky Steamboat vs. Bob BradleyF
The match is mostly a platform, and everyone involved seems to know it. Ricky Steamboat works with his usual speed and polish, Bob Bradley gives him a straightforward body to beat, and the result is never in doubt. That would be perfectly acceptable for six minutes if the segment ended at the bell. Instead, the reason to remember it is the larger Ric Flair program surrounding the show. Steamboat's presence matters because Chi-Town Rumble is days away, not because Bradley offers a meaningful obstacle. The wrestling is clean enough, but WrestleFile grades the match rather than the historical aura around the wrestler.
Functional enhancement work whose importance comes from the surrounding Flair program.
06Rick Steiner vs. Rip MorganF
At under five minutes, this at least understands its assignment. Rick Steiner is rising, Rip Morgan is there to give him a physical opponent, and the match moves directly toward a decisive result without pretending to be more important than it is. Steiner's explosiveness and awkward charisma come through, but there is not enough time or narrative depth to produce much beyond a compact television win. On a card overloaded with matches that run too long, brevity becomes one of this bout's best qualities. That is faint praise, but it is also a relief.
Short, direct and harmless — which makes it better paced than much of the card.
07The Road Warriors & Genichiro Tenryu vs. The Varsity Club — NWA World Six-Man Tag Team ChampionshipF
The advertised challengers have been locked backstage, so the Varsity Club steps into the main event and the match immediately feels like an angle waiting for its cue. The Road Warriors and Tenryu bring enough physical credibility to make the opening exchanges energetic, and the Varsity Club's targeting of Animal gives the six minutes a simple story. Then Sting, Michael Hayes and Junkyard Dog finally escape, rush the ring and trigger the double disqualification. As television promotion, the chaos creates movement toward Chi-Town Rumble. As a championship main event, it is a bait-and-switch with no real payoff between the ropes.
A decent angle attached to an unsatisfying championship main event.
BOOKING VERDICTD
Booking Grade: D. The goal is obvious and, in the narrowest sense, successful: make viewers care about Chi-Town Rumble without burning through the pay-per-view attractions. The Flair-Steamboat confrontation accomplishes that brilliantly, and the Varsity Club's backstage sabotage gives the final segment a clear storyline. The problem is what fills the rest of the two hours. Butch Reed and Steven Casey receive more than seventeen minutes, Lex Luger spends nearly thirteen with a masked Blackmailer, and even Ricky Steamboat's showcase is mostly a delivery system for the angle surrounding him. The show protects future matches, but it does so by making too many present-tense matches feel disposable.
CROWD & PRESENTATIONC+
Crowd & Presentation Grade: C+. Cleveland deserves credit for staying engaged through a card that repeatedly asks for patience. The audience gives the Midnight Express a strong babyface reaction, responds to Lex Luger, and comes alive whenever the real stars collide. Jim Ross and Magnum T.A. also keep the broadcast moving by framing the night around the coming pay-per-view rather than pretending every extended undercard bout is a classic. Production is less flattering. Scott Keith's retrospective famously notices the arena lighting changing during the opener, and the dim presentation makes several matches feel smaller than a national prime-time special should. The broadcast works as urgency-driven promotion, but not as a polished showcase.
HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB+
Historical Significance Grade: B+. Clash V matters less for a title change than for the bridge it builds into one of 1989's defining programs. The Ric Flair-Ricky Steamboat confrontation is the real centerpiece, coming five days before Steamboat wins the NWA World Heavyweight Championship at Chi-Town Rumble and begins the celebrated trilogy with Flair. The special also shows WCW settling into the Clash formula under Turner ownership: free TBS television as a place to advance major angles, showcase recognizable talent, and create demand for the next paid event.
That formula would become one of the series' defining strengths, even when the individual card was weak. Clash V is therefore useful as a case study in television wrestling's promotional function. It proves a show can be poor on a match-by-match basis and still succeed at making the next event feel important. That does not rescue the viewing experience, but it explains why this otherwise infamous installment remains historically relevant.
WHAT AGED WELL
- The Flair-Steamboat confrontation has urgency, physicality and star power that instantly makes Chi-Town Rumble feel necessary.
- The Midnight Express remain charismatic enough to give an otherwise ordinary opener genuine crowd energy.
- Jim Ross and Magnum T.A. keep the broadcast focused on stakes and upcoming programs when the in-ring pace drags.
- The show demonstrates how free national television could be used to make a pay-per-view feel hotter without giving away the marquee match.
WHAT AGED POORLY
- Several obvious showcase matches run far longer than their competitive credibility can sustain.
- The dim and inconsistent arena lighting makes a national prime-time special look cheaper than the roster deserves.
- Locking the scheduled challengers backstage to manufacture a replacement main event is convoluted even by late-1980s wrestling standards.
- The double-disqualification main event pays off an angle rather than the advertised championship match, leaving the card without a satisfying wrestling climax.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands
The retrospective consensus is unusually harsh even by early-Clash standards. CAGEMATCH currently rates the complete event near 3.1, with only the Varsity Club-Fantastics match clearing the middle of its matchguide scale. Scott Keith calls the show a legendary stinker, while Robert Leighty Jr. scores it 2.0 and describes a dimly lit card full of boring matches. Joel Thomas is the notable dissenter at 7.0, largely because he values how effectively the show promotes Chi-Town Rumble and the Flair-Steamboat angle. That split is useful: the wrestling is poor, but the television storytelling around the next event is considerably better than the matches themselves.
RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology20 sources
These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.
- The SmarK Rant for Clash of the Champions VRetrospective evaluation of the complete special, match pacing, presentation, and the Flair-Steamboat angle.
- Rock Star Gary Reflects on Clash of the Champions VSecond retrospective perspective on the card, atmosphere, and historical reputation.
- 411Mania Clash of the Champions V ReviewModern complete-show review used to compare match quality, pacing, and overall event value.
- The Chrononaut Chronicles: Clash of the Champions VRetrospective complete-show review emphasizing the Chi-Town Rumble build and Flair-Steamboat confrontation.
- Inside Pulse Clash of Champions V Retro RepostHistorical review perspective on the card and the early Clash series.
- Arnold Furious Clash of the Champions 5 ReviewIndependent retrospective assessment of the complete television special.
- KB Wrestling Reviews: Clash of the Champions VComplete-card review and comparison with earlier Clash installments.
- CAGEMATCH: NWA Clash Of The Champions #5 - St. Valentine's MassacreExact-event identity, date, promotions, venue, attendance, television rating, results, current event rating, and matchguide scores.
- CAGEMATCH: Clash V CardExact-event card view used to cross-check the seven-match lineup and match ordering.
- ProFightDB: NWA Clash of the Champions VExact-event cross-check for date, card identity, and venue naming.
- The History of WWE: NWA Clash of the Champions V ResultsChronology, production notes, match results, and storyline context for the live TBS special.
- Bleacher Report: Best Clash of the Champions ShowsSeries-wide comparison used to place Clash V within the larger Clash reputation.
- Cageside Seats: On This Date - Clash VHistorical recap of the February 1989 special and its relationship to Chi-Town Rumble.
- Wrestling Reaction: Blake's Clash V ReviewIndependent retrospective review of match quality and overall show construction.
- Pro Wrestling Only: Lex Luger vs. The BlackmailerMatch-specific discussion of Luger's masked-opponent showcase.
- Pro Wrestling Only: Butch Reed vs. Steve CaseyMatch-specific discussion of the extended Reed-Casey television bout.
- TheSportster: Every Clash of the Champions RankedSeries-wide retrospective ranking and reputation comparison.
- Legacy of Wrestling: Clash of the Champions HistorySeries chronology and historical framing across the JCP and WCW eras.
- PWInsider: This Day in History - Clash VHistorical anniversary recap and event context.
- WCW YouTube: Full Event - Clash of the Champions VVerified WCW full-event replay used for current free availability.
WHERE TO WATCHStream This Event
Stream This Event
YouTube - Free
A complete replay is currently available free on WCW's verified YouTube channel at v57sO4t2HXo; availability varies by country.
WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.