- Juventud Guerrera vs. Billy Kidman — WCW Cruiserweight Championship
World War 3 1998: Sixty Men, Three Rings, and One Missing World Champion
The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.
- PROMOTION
- World Championship Wrestling
- DATE
- November 22, 1998
- VENUE
- The Palace of Auburn Hills
- LOCATION
- Auburn Hills, Michigan
- ATTENDANCE
- 17,670
- EVENT TYPE
- PPV
World War 3 1998 is the kind of WCW show that explains the decline without needing hindsight to do the work. The company has Goldberg at the peak of his popularity, a sixty-man battle royal built to create his Starrcade challenger, and enough roster depth to fill several excellent cards, yet much of the evening feels undercooked or actively evasive. One strong cruiserweight match and a respectable DDP-Bret Hart main event cannot overcome the bait-and-switch booking around the Steiners, Hall and Nash, and the absent world-title defense.
Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting
World War 3 1998 came to The Palace of Auburn Hills with 17,670 fans in the building and a reported 250,000 pay-per-view buys. WCW still had enormous star power, Goldberg was the reigning World Heavyweight Champion, and the entire premise of the event was designed to determine who would challenge him at Starrcade. The company also had personal issues involving Rick and Scott Steiner, Kevin Nash and Scott Hall, and a United States title program between Diamond Dallas Page and Bret Hart.
That should have created a straightforward night of escalating stakes. Instead, WCW repeatedly withholds the matches viewers were told to expect. Rick Steiner and Scott Steiner never become a real match before Goldberg enters the angle, while Hall and Nash is effectively cancelled in favor of an nWo beatdown and rescue segment. Booker T against Scott Norton had also been promoted earlier in the build and disappears from the card. Goldberg, the most important champion in the company, is present but does not defend the title.
The result is a show that feels simultaneously crowded and incomplete. Kidman and Juventud Guerrera deliver the clear highlight, Jericho and Bobby Duncum Jr. provide a serviceable television-title match, and Page-Hart closes with decent wrestling. Kevin Nash wins the final World War 3 battle royal and earns the Starrcade title shot, which makes the event historically consequential. But the path there is littered with non-payoffs, substitutions, and booking that asks viewers to accept angles instead of the matches they paid to see.
Watch, Skim or Skip?
- Chris Jericho vs. Bobby Duncum Jr. — WCW World Television Championship
- World War 3 — 60-Man Three-Ring Battle Royal
- Diamond Dallas Page vs. Bret Hart — WCW United States Heavyweight Championship
- Wrath vs. Glacier
- Stevie Ray vs. Konnan
- Ernest Miller & Sonny Onoo vs. Perry Saturn & Kaz Hayashi
The Card, On the Record
01Wrath vs. GlacierD-
Wrath enters with momentum, and the audience is willing to react to his power offense. That gives the opener more life than its reputation sometimes suggests, because the basic story is easy to understand: Glacier has to survive a larger opponent who is being positioned for bigger things. Wrath throws him around convincingly, and the Meltdown gives the finish a definitive visual.
The problem is that the match never develops beyond that simple idea. Glacier's comeback is brief, the pacing is closer to an extended television squash, and the eight-minute runtime feels long for the amount of escalation involved. It is not disastrous wrestling, but World War 3 needs an opener that creates urgency. Instead, the show begins by telling the audience to wait for something more important.
Wrath's push gives the opener a purpose, but the match is too one-sided and too ordinary to justify opening a pay-per-view built around spectacle.
02Stevie Ray vs. KonnanF
Konnan has crowd connection and Stevie Ray has physical presence, but those strengths never combine into a coherent match. Much of the bout is built around slow control segments, basic strikes, and Vincent's interference, leaving Konnan to manufacture energy in short bursts rather than building a sustained comeback. The audience reacts to familiar personalities more than to the wrestling itself.
Then the finish makes everything worse. Vincent accidentally catches Stevie Ray with the slapjack, Konnan attacks, and the referee disqualifies him for putting his hands on the official. Nothing is resolved, nobody looks meaningfully stronger, and the match feels like an angle that wandered onto pay-per-view. On a show already facing questions about delivering advertised attractions, this kind of non-payoff is especially damaging.
A flat singles match between poorly matched styles ends with an unnecessary disqualification and drains momentum almost immediately.
03Ernest Miller & Sonny Onoo vs. Perry Saturn & Kaz HayashiF
Perry Saturn and Kaz Hayashi should give this match a strong athletic base, yet the structure never allows them to establish one. Ernest Miller's kicks and Sonny Onoo's comedy dominate the tone, so the bout keeps slipping away from the wrestlers most capable of creating momentum. There are scattered useful exchanges, but they rarely connect into anything that feels like a pay-per-view story.
The finish is particularly deflating, with Onoo ending up on top for the pin after Miller's involvement. Saturn's position on the card feels diminished rather than advanced, and Hayashi receives little chance to make an impression. The match is short enough to avoid becoming exhausting, but that is faint praise. Three matches into World War 3, the show still has not produced anything that feels essential.
Saturn and Hayashi provide enough ability to keep the match functional, but comedy, weak structure, and a poor finish make it another disposable undercard segment.
04Juventud Guerrera vs. Billy Kidman — WCW Cruiserweight ChampionshipB+
Juventud Guerrera and Billy Kidman rescue the card by doing what WCW's cruiserweights routinely did in this era: treat limited narrative support as an invitation to create their own stakes. They use the three-ring setup for movement and counters rather than letting it become a distraction, and the match builds through increasingly ambitious offense without losing sight of the championship.
Rey Mysterio Jr.'s involvement adds storyline texture without overwhelming the wrestling. Kidman's Shooting Star Press delivers a decisive finish and another title change, while the LWO material after the bell keeps the division moving forward. The bout is not flawless, and a few spots take time to assemble, but it is easily the best match on the show. For fifteen minutes, World War 3 finally resembles a major event.
The cruiserweights finally give the show a real pay-per-view match, using all three rings creatively and delivering the only bout that clearly exceeds expectations.
05Chris Jericho vs. Bobby Duncum Jr. — WCW World Television ChampionshipD+
Chris Jericho gives this match structure through character work, selling, and his ability to make small transitions matter. Bobby Duncum Jr. is still being introduced to the audience, so the central challenge is not technical competence but emotional investment. Jericho can create heat for himself, yet Duncum's offense rarely produces the kind of response that makes a challenger feel dangerous.
The match improves as it goes and contains enough solid wrestling to separate it from the first three bouts. Still, the finish relies on Duncum becoming distracted by Ralphus before Jericho uses the television title belt, which is another shortcut on a card already full of them. Jericho retaining makes sense. The path to that result feels needlessly ordinary for a pay-per-view.
Jericho works hard enough to make an awkward challenger credible, but the crowd never invests deeply and the belt-shot finish keeps the match in television territory.
06World War 3 — 60-Man Three-Ring Battle RoyalF
The concept is still the concept: sixty wrestlers spread across three rings, with too much action happening at once for television to communicate clearly. WCW improves the presentation somewhat once the field shrinks, but the early stages remain more spectacle than readable wrestling. Kevin Nash dominates one ring so aggressively that the booking direction becomes obvious, while many talented wrestlers disappear before viewers can follow what happened.
The final stretch at least produces recognizable stakes. The Giant is eliminated to a major reaction, Chris Benoit and Dean Malenko survive deep into the field, and Scott Hall, Lex Luger, and Nash give the closing minutes star power. Nash ultimately eliminates Hall and Luger to earn the Starrcade title shot. The outcome matters historically, but the match itself remains a cumbersome vehicle for reaching it.
The final World War 3 match remains visually chaotic, and Kevin Nash's dominance makes the result feel predetermined long before the field becomes manageable.
07Diamond Dallas Page vs. Bret Hart — WCW United States Heavyweight ChampionshipC
Diamond Dallas Page and Bret Hart have enough history and enough technical understanding to give the main event a respectable foundation. Hart targets the leg, Page works from underneath, and the United States title gives the match a clear reason to exist. The pacing is deliberate, but both men are experienced enough to make the slower sections feel connected to the eventual finish.
Then WCW adds another officiating complication. A referee bump, an nWo referee, and a reversed submission decision turn what could have been a clean championship match into another argument about procedure. Page eventually lands the Diamond Cutter and retains, so the correct result survives the clutter. The wrestling is solid. The booking refuses to let solid wrestling be enough.
DDP and Bret Hart provide the show's second-best conventional match, but another referee mess keeps a solid main event from delivering a clean closing statement.
BOOKING VERDICTF
The booking grade is an F because World War 3 repeatedly substitutes angles for advertised wrestling. Rick and Scott Steiner never deliver their promised match, Hall and Nash turns into an nWo segment, and Goldberg is used as supporting material despite being the world champion and hottest act in the company. That is not merely underwhelming matchmaking. It is a pattern of refusing the payoff.
Even the matches that happen are often given unnecessarily messy finishes. Konnan-Stevie Ray ends in disqualification, Jericho-Duncum uses a belt shot, and Page-Hart requires multiple referee complications before the correct champion finally leaves with the title. Nash winning the battle royal is logical because it creates Starrcade, but the match is booked so heavily around his dominance that the suspense drains early. WCW knows where it wants to go and keeps making the road there harder than necessary.
CROWD & PRESENTATIONC-
The Palace crowd gives the show more energy than the card sometimes deserves. Wrath gets a useful reaction, the cruiserweight title match wakes the building up, and the final stages of the battle royal produce genuine noise when major names begin disappearing. Nash's victory also lands because the audience understands that it creates the Starrcade championship match.
The presentation problem is readability. Three rings and sixty wrestlers remain difficult to translate to television, and the early battle-royal stages are visual overload rather than drama. The canceled or aborted matches create another problem because the audience can feel when a promised attraction has turned into an angle. By the main event, DDP and Bret Hart are wrestling after the event's signature match, and the crowd is noticeably less invested than the placement should demand.
HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEA-
World War 3 1998 matters because Kevin Nash wins the final edition of WCW's sixty-man battle royal and secures the title match that ends Goldberg's undefeated streak at Starrcade. That alone gives the event a permanent place in the timeline. It is the bridge between Goldberg's dominant championship run and one of the most debated booking decisions in company history.
The show also captures WCW's creative problems before 1999 fully begins. The company is still drawing major crowds, still has an extraordinary roster, and still possesses television stories people care about. Yet the event demonstrates an increasing willingness to advertise matches and replace them with angles, leave the world champion without a defense, and overcomplicate otherwise simple finishes. The decline is not theoretical here. The warning signs are already on the screen.
WHAT AGED WELL
- Kidman against Juventud Guerrera remains the obvious success. Their athleticism, timing, and use of the three-ring setup feel inventive rather than dated, and the title change gives the match a meaningful conclusion. DDP and Bret Hart also produce enough sound wrestling to remain watchable despite the finish, while Jericho's character work gives his television-title defense more personality than the matchup naturally provides.
- The historical framing has also aged well because Nash's battle-royal victory clearly points toward Starrcade. Viewers watching the period in sequence can see the next major story taking shape in real time. The live crowd's response to Nash, Goldberg, and the cruiserweights also demonstrates that WCW still had acts capable of generating major reactions. The raw ingredients for a better show are visible everywhere.
WHAT AGED POORLY
- The bait-and-switch elements have aged terribly because modern viewers can see exactly how many promised attractions become angles instead of matches. The Steiners issue does not resolve, Hall-Nash does not happen, and Goldberg appears without defending the world championship. On a pay-per-view, that kind of substitution feels more damaging than it would on weekly television.
- The World War 3 format itself also remains difficult to watch. Sixty wrestlers across three rings is an impressive live spectacle but a poor television mechanism until the field shrinks dramatically. Nash clearing a ring by himself makes the winner feel obvious, and the camera cannot possibly give every elimination meaning. The show often confuses volume with importance, a problem that became increasingly familiar in late-era WCW.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands
The critical consensus is unusually harsh. Cagematch currently places the event at 3.72, with Kidman-Guerrera standing far above the rest of the card at 7.38. Scott Keith's retrospective calls it one of WCW's worst pay-per-views, while later Cagematch comments repeatedly criticize the missing advertised matches and the promotion's refusal to deliver straightforward payoffs.
TJR is somewhat kinder at 5.75 out of 10, identifying Kidman-Guerrera and Page-Hart as standouts while still describing the show as underwhelming and questioning why Goldberg does not defend the world championship. The common thread is clear: isolated wrestling quality cannot overcome structural problems. World War 3 1998 is historically useful because it creates Nash-Goldberg, but its booking makes the event feel more like a warning than a destination.
RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology20 sources
These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.
- TJR WrestlingFull-event retrospective, match assessments, and overall verdict
- Retro Pro WrestlingFull-event retrospective and match-by-match assessment
- Scott's Blog of DoomCurrent exact-event retrospective and historical assessment
- 411Mania - SmarK RetroHistorical full-event review and booking criticism
- 411Mania - Kevin's Random ReviewsFull-event retrospective and match-by-match perspective
- Cagematch - EventExact-event identity, attendance, card, and event rating
- Cagematch - CardExact-event card and match structure
- Cagematch - RatingsExact-event ratings and historical reception
- ProFightDBExact-event chronology and card cross-check
- TheSportsterWorld War 3 series comparative ranking and retrospective context
- The OvertimerFull-event retrospective and historical perspective
- The SmackDown HotelEvent identity, results, and card cross-check
- Online World of WrestlingResults chronology and event recap
- KB's Wrestling ReviewsFull-event retrospective and booking assessment
- WrestleZone ForumsLong-form retrospective discussion and reception
- GerweckEvent results and historical card reference
- WhatCultureWorld War 3 series comparative ranking
- Cageside SeatsRetro live blog and event reaction
- Bleacher ReportWorld War 3 series comparative ranking
- Pro Wrestling FandomEvent chronology, results, and historical background
WHERE TO WATCHStream This Event
Stream This Event
No confirmed full-event viewing provider is recorded for this pass.
WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.