- Sabu defeated Abyss (with James Mitchell)
- Christian Cage defeated Monty Brown
- Team 3D (Brother Devon and Brother Ray) defeated America's Most Wanted (Chris Harris and James Storm)
- Samoa Joe defeated A.J. Styles (c) by technical submission
- Jeff Jarrett (c) defeated Rhino
Turning Point 2005: Samoa Joe's Title Win Gives TNA One of Its Strongest Closing Stretches
The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.
- PROMOTION
- TNA Wrestling
- DATE
- December 11, 2005
- VENUE
- TNA Impact! Zone
- LOCATION
- Orlando, Florida
- ATTENDANCE
- 900
- EVENT TYPE
- PPV
Turning Point 2005 builds patiently and then lands one of the strongest closing stretches in this run of TNA pay-per-views. The early card is mixed, but Christian Cage versus Monty Brown, Team 3D versus America's Most Wanted, Samoa Joe versus A. J.
Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis
Styles, and Jeff Jarrett versus Rhino give the final four matches clear stakes and distinct identities. Joe's X Division Championship victory is the event's defining moment, while Sabu and Abyss provide a memorable Barbed Wire Massacre much earlier. The show is not uniformly excellent, yet its peaks are broad enough that the event feels substantial rather than dependent on one match.
Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting
Turning Point 2005 took place at the TNA Impact! Zone in Orlando with an attendance of 900. The ten-match card includes one pre-show six-man tag and then opens the main card with Sabu defeating Abyss in a 10:58 Barbed Wire Massacre. The middle portion is lighter: an X Division tag, a short Raven singles match, two multi-man tags and other roster-driven material carry the show toward its final hour. The stakes rise sharply from there. Christian Cage defeats Monty Brown in 12:38 to become the number-one contender to the NWA World Heavyweight Championship. Team 3D defeats America's Most Wanted in a 10:20 Tables match. Samoa Joe then defeats A.J.
Styles by technical submission in 18:54 to win the TNA X Division Championship, giving the card its clearest competitive peak and only title change. Jeff Jarrett closes by retaining the NWA World Heavyweight Championship against Rhino in 17:29. That sequence gives the event a coherent escalation from contender stakes to tag-team rivalry to a major championship change and finally the world-title defense. The card's shape becomes clearer as it moves toward the final matches, where the most recognizable programs receive the most time and consequence. Earlier bouts establish variety, but the closing stretch supplies the strongest reasons to watch the event as a complete show. That progression gives Turning Point a more deliberate event-level rhythm than a card built from equally weighted matches.
Watch, Skim or Skip?
- Austin Aries and Matt Bentley (with Traci) defeated Alex Shelley and Roderick Strong
- Team Canada (A-1, Bobby Roode, Eric Young, and Petey Williams) (with Coach Scott D'Amore) defeated 4Live Kru (B.G. James, Kip James, Konnan, and Ron Killings)
- Chris Sabin, Dale Torborg, and Sonjay Dutt (with A. J. Pierzynski) defeated The Diamonds in the Rough (David Young, Elix Skipper, and Simon Diamond)
- The Naturals (Andy Douglas and Chase Stevens) and Lance Hoyt defeated Buck Quartermain, Jon Bolen, and Joe Doering
- Raven defeated Chris K
The Card, On the Record
01The Naturals (Andy Douglas and Chase Stevens) and Lance Hoyt defeated Buck Quartermain, Jon Bolen, and Joe DoeringC-
The Naturals (Andy Douglas and Chase Stevens) and Lance Hoyt defeated Buck Quartermain, Jon Bolen, and Joe Doering. The match is presented as six-man tag team match and runs 7:11. On the pre-show, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match is acceptable but slight, with too little time or consequence to create much lasting value beyond filling its position on the card. The 5.8 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Turning Point 2005, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.
Skimmable material with limited replay value.
02Sabu defeated Abyss (with James Mitchell)A-
Sabu defeated Abyss (with James Mitchell). The match is presented as barbed wire massacre and runs 10:58. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. Barbed Wire Massacre gives Sabu and Abyss a match identity that is impossible to confuse with the rest of the card, and its controlled length helps the violence feel concentrated rather than repetitive. The match is an excellent piece of the card, combining meaningful placement with enough time and consequence to remain one of the event's strongest reasons to revisit the show. The 8.7 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Turning Point 2005, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.
An excellent match and one of the event's strongest attractions.
03Austin Aries and Matt Bentley (with Traci) defeated Alex Shelley and Roderick StrongB-
Austin Aries and Matt Bentley (with Traci) defeated Alex Shelley and Roderick Strong. The match is presented as x division tag team match and runs 8:03. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match is solid and purposeful, offering a clear role within the card without developing the urgency or consequence of the stronger attractions around it. The 7.2 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Turning Point 2005, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.
A worthwhile supporting match with a clear purpose.
04Raven defeated Chris KC-
Raven defeated Chris K. The match is presented as singles match and runs 5:49. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match is acceptable but slight, with too little time or consequence to create much lasting value beyond filling its position on the card. The 5.8 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Turning Point 2005, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.
Skimmable material with limited replay value.
05Team Canada (A-1, Bobby Roode, Eric Young, and Petey Williams) (with Coach Scott D'Amore) defeated 4Live Kru (B.G. James, Kip James, Konnan, and Ron Killings)C+
Team Canada (A-1, Bobby Roode, Eric Young, and Petey Williams) (with Coach Scott D'Amore) defeated 4Live Kru (B.G. James, Kip James, Konnan, and Ron Killings). The match is presented as eight-man tag team match and runs 7:16. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match is useful supporting material: competent, easy to follow and appropriately placed, but more functional than memorable when measured against the rest of the event. The 6.8 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Turning Point 2005, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.
Solid supporting material, better for a full watch than a selective rewatch.
06Chris Sabin, Dale Torborg, and Sonjay Dutt (with A. J. Pierzynski) defeated The Diamonds in the Rough (David Young, Elix Skipper, and Simon Diamond)C+
Chris Sabin, Dale Torborg, and Sonjay Dutt (with A. J. Pierzynski) defeated The Diamonds in the Rough (David Young, Elix Skipper, and Simon Diamond). The match is presented as six-man tag team match and runs 7:58. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match is useful supporting material: competent, easy to follow and appropriately placed, but more functional than memorable when measured against the rest of the event. The 6.8 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Turning Point 2005, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.
Solid supporting material, better for a full watch than a selective rewatch.
07Christian Cage defeated Monty BrownB+
Christian Cage defeated Monty Brown. The match is presented as singles match to determine the #1 contender to the nwa world heavyweight championship and runs 12:38. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The number-one-contender stipulation gives Christian Cage's win immediate purpose and positions the singles match as a bridge from the mid-card toward the world-title picture. The match is a strong feature that materially improves the event, with enough time, stakes or stylistic distinction to stand clearly above routine supporting material. The 8.2 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Turning Point 2005, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.
A strong match that is comfortably worth watching.
08Team 3D (Brother Devon and Brother Ray) defeated America's Most Wanted (Chris Harris and James Storm)B+
Team 3D (Brother Devon and Brother Ray) defeated America's Most Wanted (Chris Harris and James Storm). The match is presented as tables match and runs 10:20. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The Tables match lets Team 3D defeat the tag champions without a conventional title match, creating a clear rivalry result while keeping the stipulation central to the presentation. The match is a strong feature that materially improves the event, with enough time, stakes or stylistic distinction to stand clearly above routine supporting material. The 8.3 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Turning Point 2005, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.
A strong match that is comfortably worth watching.
09Samoa Joe defeated A.J. Styles (c) by technical submissionA
Samoa Joe defeated A.J. Styles (c) by technical submission. The match is presented as singles match for the tna x division championship and runs 18:54. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. Joe taking the X Division title from Styles by technical submission is the night's defining competitive result, and the 18:54 duration gives the championship change enough room to feel fully earned. The match reaches elite territory because its stakes and structure are clear, the featured time is justified, and the result feels worthy of a major pay-per-view attraction. The 9.4 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Turning Point 2005, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.
A major match that belongs on any focused rewatch of the event.
10Jeff Jarrett (c) defeated RhinoB+
Jeff Jarrett (c) defeated Rhino. The match is presented as singles match for the nwa world heavyweight championship and runs 17:29. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. Jarrett's world-title retention over Rhino closes the card with a conventional championship result after the more distinctive Joe-Styles title change immediately before it. The match is a strong feature that materially improves the event, with enough time, stakes or stylistic distinction to stand clearly above routine supporting material. The 8.1 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Turning Point 2005, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.
A strong match that is comfortably worth watching.
BOOKING VERDICTA-
The strongest booking choice is Joe defeating Styles decisively for the X Division Championship. The technical-submission finish gives the title change force without relying on a fluke, and the placement immediately before the world-title main event makes the division feel central to the pay-per-view. Christian Cage's contender win also gives his singles match immediate follow-through, while Team 3D beating America's Most Wanted advances the tag rivalry in a stipulation match. Jarrett retaining over Rhino is less fresh than the Joe result, but it keeps the top title stable while several challengers and rivals continue to move around him. That balance gives the show a cleaner sense of purpose and makes the decisive upper-card results feel earned rather than merely scheduled.
CROWD & PRESENTATIONB+
The 900-person Impact! Zone crowd gives Turning Point a compact presentation, so the show creates scale through stipulations and match placement rather than arena size. Barbed Wire Massacre supplies an early visual hook, the Tables match changes the rhythm late, and Joe-Styles provides a long athletic championship match before the more traditional world-title close. That variety is the event's greatest presentation strength. The middle of the card can feel television-sized because several bouts are short and lightly consequential, but the final hour restores a pay-per-view sense of importance by stacking matches with clear stakes.
HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEA
Turning Point 2005 is historically important within this sequence because Samoa Joe leaves with the TNA X Division Championship after defeating A.J. Styles by technical submission. The result turns Joe's rise from tournament winner and featured singles threat into an actual championship reign, while Styles remains positioned as one of the division's defining opponents. Christian Cage's number-one-contender victory also clarifies his movement toward the world-title picture, and Team 3D's Tables victory keeps the tag-title rivalry active even though America's Most Wanted remain champions in the locked card record. Sabu-Abyss adds another example of TNA using a distinctive stipulation as a major attraction. Taken together, the show captures multiple roster directions becoming more defined at once rather than relying on a single isolated headline result alone.
WHAT AGED WELL
- Joe's technical-submission title win over Styles gives the event a decisive signature result.
- The final four matches escalate cleanly from contender stakes to two major championship programs.
- Barbed Wire Massacre provides a memorable stipulation attraction without taking over the whole show.
WHAT AGED POORLY
- The middle of the card contains several short, lightly consequential matches.
- The compact studio setting still limits the visual scale of the pay-per-view.
- Jarrett-Rhino is solid but has difficulty following the fresher Joe-Styles championship change.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands
The factual structure supports an A- event score. The first six matches are uneven and several are short, but the final four combine contender stakes, a major tag rivalry, an X Division title change and a world-title defense. Joe-Styles is the best and most consequential match, yet the show also has enough depth around it that the overall grade does not depend entirely on one centerpiece. The key deduction is pacing through the middle, where the card temporarily loses urgency before the closing sequence takes over.
RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology9 sources
These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.
- WikipediaEvent identity, card results, match context, and historical corroboration.
- PWTorchContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
- PWTorchContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
- PWTorchContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
- PWTorchContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
- PWTorchContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
- PWTorchContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
- PWTorchContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
- WrestleViewContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
WHERE TO WATCHStream This Event
Stream This Event
Locked factual research established no current provider that can be asserted safely here; no territory-safe direct viewing destination is included.
WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.