WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

Starrcade '90: Collision Course — The Black Scorpion Finally Came Off

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

NWA / WCWDecember 16, 1990Kiel Auditorium
THE WRESTLEGRADEC6.1 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#887OF 1030
PROMOTION
World Championship Wrestling / National Wrestling Alliance
DATE
December 16, 1990
VENUE
Kiel Auditorium
LOCATION
St. Louis, Missouri
ATTENDANCE
7,200
EVENT TYPE
PPV
THE FILE

Starrcade '90: Collision Course is a show fighting against its own best instincts. WCW has Bobby Eaton, the Steiner Brothers, Great Muta, Stan Hansen, Lex Luger, Doom, Arn Anderson, Barry Windham, Sting and Ric Flair in one building, yet much of the card is consumed by a seven-match international tag tournament built around teams the audience barely knows.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

The tournament is not completely worthless. The Japanese and Soviet teams bring unfamiliar styles, the Steiners are explosive whenever they appear, and the final against Muta and Saito finally resembles the kind of match Starrcade should showcase. The problem is repetition: four quarterfinals and two semifinals arrive before the tournament earns enough emotional investment to justify the time.

The non-tournament material is better. Eaton and Z-Man have a strong opener, Luger and Hansen deliver a rough Texas Lariat fight, and Doom against Arn Anderson and Barry Windham becomes a bloody sprint years ahead of the brawling style WCW would embrace later. Then the main event arrives and almost erases that momentum, forcing Ric Flair to hide every recognizable part of himself beneath the Black Scorpion mask.

Starrcade '90: Collision Course earns C / 6.1. The fourteen reviewed matches average 5.314, reflecting a card with one excellent street fight, several respectable matches and too much tournament filler. The show is historically important and occasionally fascinating, but WCW's biggest event of the year should not peak in a seven-minute tag brawl before ending with one of Sting and Flair's least satisfying matches.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

Starrcade '90: Collision Course took place on December 16, 1990, at the Kiel Auditorium in St. Louis, Missouri. The event drew a reported 7,200 fans and approximately 165,000 pay-per-view buys. It was the eighth Starrcade and the final edition presented during WCW's transition away from the National Wrestling Alliance banner.

Fourteen matches aired. Seven belonged to the Pat O'Connor Memorial International Cup Tag Team Tournament, an eight-team bracket featuring representatives from the United States, Mexico, Great Britain, Japan, New Zealand, Canada, South Africa and the Soviet Union. The Steiner Brothers ultimately defeated Great Muta and Mr. Saito in the final.

The major championship matches were Lex Luger against Stan Hansen in a Texas Lariat match for the United States Championship, Doom against Arn Anderson and Barry Windham in a street fight for the World Tag Team Championship, and Sting against the Black Scorpion inside a steel cage for the World Heavyweight Championship. Bobby Eaton versus Z-Man, Michael Wallstreet versus Terry Taylor and several additional tag matches filled out the card.

The Black Scorpion storyline had dominated Sting's first world-title reign after the Great American Bash. Starrcade was designed to reveal the masked challenger's identity, and Ric Flair ultimately emerged under the mask. That reveal closed one of WCW's most notorious 1990 angles while immediately returning Sting and Flair to the rivalry the company had spent months disguising.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • Doom vs. Arn Anderson & Barry Windham - Street Fight - NWA World Tag Team Championship
  • Bobby Eaton vs. Z-Man
  • The Steiner Brothers vs. Great Muta & Mr. Saito - Tournament Final
SKIM
  • Lex Luger vs. Stan Hansen - Texas Lariat Match - NWA United States Heavyweight Championship
  • Michael Wallstreet vs. Terry Taylor
  • Sting vs. The Black Scorpion - Steel Cage Match - NWA World Heavyweight Championship
SKIP
  • The Steiner Brothers vs. Sgt. Krueger & Col. DeKlerk - Tournament Quarterfinal
  • Konnan & Rey Misterio vs. Chris Adams & Norman Smiley - Tournament Quarterfinal
  • Great Muta & Mr. Saito vs. The Royal Family - Tournament Quarterfinal
  • Victor Zangiev & Salman Hashimikov vs. Troy Montour & Danny Johnson - Tournament Quarterfinal
  • The Skyscrapers vs. Big Cat & The Motor City Madman
  • Ricky Morton & Tommy Rich vs. The Fabulous Freebirds
  • The Steiner Brothers vs. Konnan & Rey Misterio - Tournament Semifinal
  • Great Muta & Mr. Saito vs. Victor Zangiev & Salman Hashimikov - Tournament Semifinal
MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

The Card, On the Record

01Bobby Eaton vs. Z-ManC+

Eaton and Z-Man open with a conventional wrestling match, which already gives them an advantage over much of the card. Zenk uses dropkicks, arm work and a dive to keep the pace active, while Eaton counters with sharper transitions and the kind of bumping that makes ordinary offense look meaningful.

The final stretch improves after a slow opening. Eaton survives the superkick, avoids the missile dropkick and immediately converts the mistake into an inside cradle for the pin. C+ reflects a solid opener that becomes better as it progresses and reminds the audience how effective simple wrestling can be.

VERDICT

Eaton's timing and Zenk's athletic movement produce a solid opener before the card disappears into tournament machinery.

02The Steiner Brothers vs. Sgt. Krueger & Col. DeKlerk - Tournament QuarterfinalD

The South African team gets just enough offense to establish that this is technically a match before the Steiners overwhelm them. Rick absorbs a brief flurry, Scott enters and the power difference immediately becomes the only story that matters.

DeKlerk's attempted dive is memorable mostly because Rick catches or avoids the danger without treating it seriously. Scott finishes the match with the Frankensteiner in barely two minutes. D gives credit for the Steiners looking explosive, but the quarterfinal is essentially a squash attached to a tournament bracket.

VERDICT

The Steiners advance in two minutes, making the South African entry feel more like a demonstration than a tournament threat.

03Konnan & Rey Misterio vs. Chris Adams & Norman Smiley - Tournament QuarterfinalD

The match is interesting because all four wrestlers bring visibly different styles. Adams supplies sharp strikes, Smiley works smooth mat exchanges, and the Mexican team introduces quicker headscissors and springboard movement that is unusual for a 1990 WCW crowd.

The problem is that five minutes do not give the styles time to blend. The audience reacts to individual high spots but never fully invests in either team before Konnan gets the pin. D reflects a historically curious match whose novelty is stronger than its construction.

VERDICT

Four very different wrestlers flash interesting ideas, but five minutes are not enough to turn those ideas into a coherent match.

04Great Muta & Mr. Saito vs. The Royal Family - Tournament QuarterfinalD

Muta is the only wrestler who consistently wakes the audience, and his kicks and handspring elbow immediately change the energy whenever he enters. Saito provides compact suplexes and strikes, while Morgan and Victory rely on basic control work and interference.

The match ends after the New Zealand team miscommunicates and Muta uses a bridging German suplex. There is enough competence to avoid disaster, but the crowd spends long stretches waiting for Muta's next spot. D reflects a functional quarterfinal without enough heat or time to become memorable.

VERDICT

Muta's bursts of athleticism rescue a quiet quarterfinal that otherwise struggles to connect with the St. Louis crowd.

05Victor Zangiev & Salman Hashimikov vs. Troy Montour & Danny Johnson - Tournament QuarterfinalF

The Soviet wrestlers approach the match with legitimate amateur intensity, throwing suplexes and holds that the Canadian team does not always appear prepared to receive. One belly-to-belly drops Johnson dangerously, and several exchanges look more like an uncomfortable style clash than cooperative pro wrestling.

The finish is even worse, with Hashimikov scoring a count that appears disputed immediately by the participants. Four minutes feel longer because the teams never establish a common rhythm. F reflects the tournament's clearest failure and the match contemporary readers later identified most often as the night's worst.

VERDICT

The Soviet team's hard amateur style collides with an overmatched Canadian pair and produces the tournament's roughest four minutes.

06Michael Wallstreet vs. Terry TaylorC

The computerized time prediction gives the match a simple hook: Wallstreet is supposed to win before the countdown expires. Taylor attacks quickly to challenge that premise, while Wallstreet slows the match with arm work, an abdominal stretch and deliberate control.

Taylor's comeback creates several credible near falls before Wallstreet catches him with the Stock Market Crash inside the predicted window. C reflects a professionally worked television-style match that looks better after four uneven tournament bouts. Neither wrestler creates a major Starrcade moment, but both understand how to build six minutes around a clear idea.

VERDICT

Two experienced pros turn a computer-prediction gimmick into a competent six-minute match with a clean payoff.

07The Skyscrapers vs. Big Cat & The Motor City MadmanD+

Sid Vicious and Danny Spivey reunite for a one-minute destruction designed entirely to remind the audience how imposing the Skyscrapers can look. Big Cat and the Motor City Madman offer almost no meaningful resistance before the power offense begins.

The double powerbomb ends the match as soon as it has established its purpose. There is no competitive drama, but the crowd responds to Sid and the squash communicates exactly what WCW intends. D+ rewards effectiveness rather than depth; as a wrestling match it barely exists, but as a showcase it works.

VERDICT

One minute and a double powerbomb are enough for the Skyscrapers to accomplish the only job the match was given.

08Ricky Morton & Tommy Rich vs. The Fabulous FreebirdsD

Morton and Rich work with enough pace to prevent the Freebirds from settling into a long control segment. Gibson's presence on crutches and Little Richard Marley at ringside eventually become more important than the wrestling, turning the match toward the angle WCW actually wants to advance.

Marley accidentally falls onto Garvin after Gibson uses the crutch, and Morton takes the pin while the Freebirds' frustration explodes afterward. D reflects a short, lively enough tag match whose real purpose is storyline cleanup. The action is acceptable but never feels important to Starrcade.

VERDICT

The wrestling stays brisk, but the match ultimately exists to trigger the Freebirds' post-match breakup with Little Richard Marley.

09The Steiner Brothers vs. Konnan & Rey Misterio - Tournament SemifinalD

Konnan and Rick attempt some mat wrestling before the Steiners begin imposing their size. The Mexican team tries to create movement with quick tags and takedowns, but the match repeatedly looks awkward because the teams never settle into a common pace.

Rick eventually catches Misterio's aerial attempt and turns it into a powerbomb for the pin in under three minutes. D reflects another tournament match that functions as a bracket result more than a complete contest. The Steiners look dominant, but the audience receives little reason to believe the outcome could change.

VERDICT

The Steiners overpower another international team in a semifinal too short to develop beyond the obvious result.

10Great Muta & Mr. Saito vs. Victor Zangiev & Salman Hashimikov - Tournament SemifinalD-

The Japanese team handles the Soviet wrestlers' physical style more comfortably than Canada did. Muta and Zangiev exchange quick mat counters, while Saito is willing to meet the heavier suplexes with his own compact offense.

The three-minute runtime still prevents the match from becoming more than a collection of interesting exchanges. Saito eventually finishes Zangiev with the Saito suplex and sends Japan to the final. D- gives credit for a smoother style clash while recognizing that another abbreviated tournament match cannot create meaningful drama.

VERDICT

Japan handles the Soviet team's hard style better than Canada did, but three minutes still turns the semifinal into a highlight reel.

11Lex Luger vs. Stan Hansen - Texas Lariat Match - NWA United States Heavyweight ChampionshipB-

Luger and Hansen are better here than at Halloween Havoc because the rope gives their brawling a clear structure. Hansen uses it to whip and choke Luger, both men fight around ringside, and the crowd becomes increasingly invested as Luger begins touching the corners.

The finish damages an otherwise effective fight. Luger reaches the fourth corner while the original referee is down, replacement referee Nick Patrick declares Hansen the winner after his own circuit, and Randy Anderson revives to award Luger the championship. B- credits the physicality and strong crowd response while docking the match for another needlessly complicated title change.

VERDICT

Luger and Hansen finally click as a brawling pair before competing referees make a simple title change unnecessarily confusing.

12Doom vs. Arn Anderson & Barry Windham - Street Fight - NWA World Tag Team ChampionshipA-

The match explodes immediately because the street-fight rules remove every reason to slow down. Belts, chairs and the ramp become weapons within moments, and all four wrestlers bleed while trading heavy shots that feel startlingly modern for a 1990 WCW pay-per-view.

The action keeps escalating through spinebusters, piledrivers, a superplex and constant saves. Nobody waits for a formal tag rhythm because the match is built around simultaneous fights and sudden near falls. The crowd reacts to the chaos more intensely than almost anything else on the card.

A double-pin draw protects Doom but denies the brawl a satisfying conclusion. A- still reflects the clear match of the night and one of WCW's most influential early street fights. The finish is disappointing, yet the seven-minute sprint demonstrates a style the promotion would explore much more aggressively in the years ahead.

VERDICT

Doom and the Horsemen produce a bloody seven-minute sprint that feels years ahead of its time despite another frustrating draw.

13The Steiner Brothers vs. Great Muta & Mr. Saito - Tournament FinalB-

The final finally gives the tournament enough time for personalities to emerge. Muta's speed and strikes contrast with the Steiners' power, Saito brings compact suplexes, and the Japanese team takes advantage whenever Scott's impatience distracts the referee.

Rick absorbs the extended control segment before Scott's hot tag accelerates the match. Muta and Saito use the ring bell and double-team offense to create believable danger, while the Steiners keep surviving through strength and explosive counters.

Rick ultimately makes an unseen tag and catches Saito with a top-rope sunset flip to win the tournament. B- reflects the bracket's best complete match and a satisfying victory for the Steiners. It is not good enough to justify all six earlier tournament bouts, but it gives the concept a respectable ending.

VERDICT

The tournament finally finds a real match in the final as the Steiners survive Muta and Saito's clever control to win the trophy.

14Sting vs. The Black Scorpion - Steel Cage Match - NWA World Heavyweight ChampionshipF

The entrance is more memorable than the match. Multiple Black Scorpions appear, the real challenger descends in an elaborate pod and the production tries to turn months of mystery into a major spectacle. Once the bell rings, the energy disappears.

Flair's problem is impossible: he must wrestle an eighteen-minute cage match without moving, bumping or reacting like Ric Flair. That forces him into generic headlocks, clubbing offense and deliberately unfamiliar transitions, while Sting struggles to create heat against an opponent the audience already suspects.

The match finally improves when Sting begins using the cage and exposing pieces of blond hair beneath the mask. Sting wins with a top-rope crossbody, fights off the additional Scorpions and eventually unmasks Flair during a rushed post-match scene.

F reflects a historically famous reveal attached to a painfully dull championship match. Sting and Flair are capable of greatness together, which makes the deliberate suppression of their chemistry even more frustrating. The Black Scorpion angle ends, but the payoff validates almost none of the months spent reaching it.

VERDICT

WCW finally reveals Ric Flair under the Black Scorpion mask after forcing two elite rivals to spend eighteen minutes hiding their chemistry.

BOOKING VERDICTD+

The booking earns D+ because the event repeatedly makes simple ideas harder than they need to be. The Pat O'Connor tournament honors an important wrestling figure and brings different international styles onto a major stage, but seven matches on one pay-per-view make the concept feel like an obligation instead of a special attraction.

Luger versus Hansen suffers from another unnecessary referee dispute. Luger reaches all four corners while the original referee is down, Hansen is briefly declared the winner by a replacement official, and the first referee returns to reverse the call. The desired title change happens, but the process makes both officials look confused.

Doom versus Anderson and Windham is the best-booked match until the finish. The street-fight rules unleash all four wrestlers and produce a frantic double-pin ending that protects Doom, yet the draw denies the crowd the decisive payoff the violence seems to promise.

The Black Scorpion payoff is the largest failure. Flair has to conceal his identity by wrestling unlike Ric Flair, which damages both him and Sting for eighteen minutes before the reveal. D+ gives credit for the tournament winners and Luger's title recovery while recognizing that the show's most important creative decision turns two elite wrestlers into supporting pieces for a gimmick that had already run too long.

CROWD & PRESENTATIONC+

Crowd and Presentation earns C+ because the Kiel Auditorium supplies history and atmosphere even when the audience struggles with the card. St. Louis reacts strongly to Bobby Eaton, Lex Luger, Sid Vicious, the Steiners and the most violent moments of the tag-title street fight, proving the building is ready to reward recognizable stars.

The tournament exposes the opposite problem. Several unfamiliar international teams receive near silence, and the short match lengths make it difficult for the crowd to learn who matters before another pairing replaces them. Muta can wake the audience with individual spots, but the bracket rarely develops sustained heat.

Jim Ross and Paul E. Dangerously are a major strength. Ross gives the international teams sporting context, while Dangerously can criticize the heroes without making the championships feel silly. Their verbal exchanges during the street fight are better than much of the booking surrounding them.

The Black Scorpion entrance provides memorable spectacle with multiple masked men, a descending pod and elaborate lighting. Unfortunately, the production cannot manufacture heat once the bell rings, and the final unmasking is rushed badly enough that commentary has to make the identity clear. C+ reflects a distinctive broadcast whose atmosphere is strongest whenever the wrestling is allowed to speak for itself.

HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEA

Historical Significance Grade: A. Starrcade 1990 is the final Starrcade of the NWA-banner transition and one of the clearest markers between the old Crockett lineage and the WCW identity that would fully emerge in 1991. The event closes a major chapter of the promotion's presentation.

The Black Scorpion is finally revealed as Ric Flair. The storyline had occupied much of Sting's first world-title reign, and ending it restores Flair as Sting's central rival just weeks before Flair regains the championship.

The Pat O'Connor Memorial tournament also creates an unusual historical snapshot. Great Muta, Mr. Saito, Konnan, Rey Misterio Sr., Norman Smiley, Victor Zangiev and Salman Hashimikov all appear on the same WCW pay-per-view, producing combinations that would otherwise be difficult to imagine in the promotion.

The show also features Lex Luger regaining the United States Championship and an influential street fight between Doom and the Horsemen. A reflects an event with substantial transitional and roster-history value even though its creative execution is far less impressive than its place in WCW history.

WHAT AGED WELL
  • Doom versus Arn Anderson and Barry Windham has aged extremely well. The jeans, belts, chairs, blood and rapid near falls make the match feel like a prototype for the violent WCW and ECW brawls that would become common later in the decade. The double-pin finish is frustrating, but the seven minutes before it are ferocious.
  • Bobby Eaton versus Z-Man also remains an easy watch. Eaton's timing, bumps and transitions give the opener a professional polish that many tournament matches lack, while Zenk supplies enough athletic movement to keep the crowd active.
  • The international tournament is more interesting historically than it was dramatically. Seeing Great Muta and Saito interact with the Soviet wrestlers, or the Steiners work with Konnan and Rey Misterio Sr., gives modern viewers a cross-promotional curiosity that was not fully appreciated by the live crowd.
  • Ross and Dangerously have aged especially well. Their commentary treats the event as important, provides context for unfamiliar wrestlers and creates chemistry without drowning out the matches. The booth often sounds more modern than the booking.
WHAT AGED POORLY
  • The tournament's repetition has aged badly. Seven tag matches consume a large portion of Starrcade, and several quarterfinal or semifinal bouts are so short that they never become more than demonstrations of one or two signature moves. The concept makes the biggest show of the year feel like an exhibition bracket.
  • The handling of the international teams is also dated. National stereotypes, awkward pronunciations and simplistic Cold War framing are woven through the presentation. Some of the wrestlers are treated more as representatives of countries than as performers with individual identities.
  • The Texas Lariat finish is another relic of WCW's tendency to overbook straightforward matches. Luger and Hansen already have a physical fight and an audience ready for the title change, yet the company adds a referee bump and competing decisions before reaching the obvious result.
  • The Black Scorpion has aged worst. The entrance spectacle is campy enough to be entertaining, but forcing Flair to hide his normal mannerisms produces a slow and heatless cage match. Months of mystery conclude with a reveal most viewers had already guessed, making the entire angle feel like a long detour back to Sting versus Flair.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

Robert Leighty Jr.'s 2025 rewatch gives Starrcade 1990 a 4.0 out of 10. He rates Doom versus Arn Anderson and Barry Windham at four stars, Luger versus Hansen at three, the tournament final at two and three-quarter, and calls Sting versus the Black Scorpion a dud. His conclusion says the street fight is worth seeing but the tournament and main event drag the event down.

Matt Adamson's older 411Mania review is much more favorable at 7.5 out of 10, illustrating the unusually wide range of opinions surrounding this show. His assessment values the commentary, historical setting and broader card more highly than reviewers who judge the tournament and main event harshly.

Contemporary reader polling was also mixed rather than disastrous: the Wrestling Observer poll reported 234 thumbs up, 176 thumbs down and 37 in the middle. Doom versus the Horsemen overwhelmingly won best-match voting, while the Soviet Union versus Canada quarterfinal received the most worst-match votes.

ITR Wrestling ranks Starrcade last among WCW's five 1990 pay-per-views, criticizing the fourteen-match overload and the tournament's dominance of the card. The WrestleFile match scores average 5.314, and the complete event receives C / 6.1: historically interesting, intermittently good and too inconsistent to call a successful Starrcade. Historical Significance is graded separately at A and does not mechanically inflate the match-quality average.

RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
20 sources

These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

  1. Retro Pro WrestlingFull-event retrospective and match-by-match assessment
  2. CagematchExact-event identity and current event reception reference
  3. Cagematch - cardExact-event card and participant cross-check
  4. Cagematch - ratingsExact-event ratings and reception cross-check
  5. ProFightDBExact-event card and results identity cross-check
  6. 411Mania - Random Network ReviewsModern full-event retrospective and overall assessment
  7. 411Mania - Dark PegasusHistorical full-event retrospective and match assessment
  8. 411Mania - Going Old SchoolHistorical full-event review with 7.5 out of 10 overall assessment
  9. Scott's Blog of DoomHistorical Starrcade 1990 retrospective and match assessment
  10. Arn's Wrestling ReviewsModern complete-event rewatch and match assessment
  11. The SmackDown HotelEvent card, results and championship-change cross-check
  12. Online World of WrestlingHistorical card and results cross-check
  13. ITR WrestlingComparative ranking within WCW's 1990 pay-per-view schedule
  14. KB Wrestling ReviewsHistorical full-event retrospective and Black Scorpion assessment
  15. WrestleZone forumCommunity full-event retrospective discussion
  16. WhatCultureComparative ranking across Starrcade events
  17. The Wrestling InsomniacHistorical full-event review and match assessment
  18. Wrestling RecapsHistorical full-event review and storyline context
  19. PWPonderingsFull-event review and tournament assessment
  20. The History of WWEStarrcade results-history and chronology cross-check
WHERE TO WATCH

Stream This Event

Checked August 31, 20261 OPTION
Global

Internet Archive - Free

Watch on Internet ArchiveA full-event replay is currently referenced for this Event File. Availability and rights can change.

A full-event Internet Archive replay is currently referenced. Availability can change by region or rights status.

WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.