- Seth Rollins & Bron Breakker vs. CM Punk & Sami Zayn
- Damian Priest vs. Drew McIntyre - Steel Cage Match
Saturday Night's Main Event XXXIX: Everybody Returns, Nobody Gets Enough Time
The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.
- PROMOTION
- World Wrestling Entertainment
- DATE
- May 24, 2025
- VENUE
- Yuengling Center
- LOCATION
- Tampa, Florida
- ATTENDANCE
- 10,762
- EVENT TYPE
- TV Special
Saturday Night's Main Event XXXIX is two hours of WWE discovering that a television special can have too much plot and not enough television.
Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis
The names are enormous. CM Punk. Seth Rollins. John Cena. Cody Rhodes. Drew McIntyre. Jey Uso. Logan Paul. Sami Zayn. Bron Breakker. Bronson Reed comes back. Cody comes back. Two championships are defended. A steel cage hangs over the ring. Jesse Ventura is there to become personally offended by the existence of a cage door.
And somehow the show still feels small. The opening tag is good until Bronson Reed's return properly becomes the point. Zelina Vega and Chelsea Green get five rushed minutes and a badly broken rhythm. Cena and R-Truth get four minutes to turn an emotional relationship into a heel vignette. Priest and McIntyre produce the best sustained violence of the night, but commercials carve out part of the match. Then Jey Uso and Logan Paul are handed a world-title main event with a hard clock, a commercial break, John Cena interference, Cody Rhodes' return and a Money in the Bank challenge all fighting for the same oxygen.
The result is not a disaster. The show advances plenty. Reed joining Rollins, Breakker and Heyman is useful. Cody's return matters. Priest gets a decisive visual over McIntyre. Cena's treatment of Truth advances his heel character. But Saturday Night's Main Event is supposed to feel like an occasion, not a two-hour hallway connecting one premium event to another.
The final verdict is C / 6.2. There is enough talent and enough storyline movement to keep the show from sinking. There is not enough uninterrupted wrestling, satisfying payoff or breathing room to push it higher.
Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting
Saturday Night's Main Event XXXIX took place May 24, 2025, at the Yuengling Center in Tampa, Florida. WWE listed the event as a Raw and SmackDown special, airing on NBC and Peacock in the United States and on YouTube in many international markets.
Five matches aired on the broadcast. American Made defeated the Latino World Order in a dark match before the show and that bout is not graded here.
The card arrived between Backlash and Money in the Bank, which explains much of its structure. Jey Uso defended the World Heavyweight Championship against Logan Paul. John Cena faced R-Truth in a non-title match during Cena's heel championship run. Damian Priest and Drew McIntyre continued their feud inside a steel cage. CM Punk and Sami Zayn opposed Seth Rollins and Bron Breakker, while Zelina Vega defended the Women's United States Championship against Chelsea Green.
The show also featured Jesse Ventura on commentary, Bronson Reed's return from injury and Cody Rhodes' first WWE appearance since WrestleMania 41. That much star power made the one-hour format feel especially compressed.
Watch, Skim or Skip?
- John Cena vs. R-Truth
- Jey Uso vs. Logan Paul - World Heavyweight Championship
- Zelina Vega vs. Chelsea Green - Women's United States Championship
The Card, On the Record
01Seth Rollins & Bron Breakker def. CM Punk & Sami ZaynB-
Four good wrestlers are asked to make thirteen minutes feel like twenty, then the commercials take a tax anyway.
Sami Zayn supplies the early urgency, Bron Breakker supplies the violence, and CM Punk versus Seth Rollins carries enough unresolved electricity that even a routine exchange feels like a preview of something larger. Breakker's clothesline on the announce table is the first moment that gives the match some teeth. Punk's hot tag wakes the building up again after the first break.
The finish is really an introduction. Paul Heyman distracts the referee, Bronson Reed returns, and Punk disappears through the barricade. Breakker spears Zayn for the pin. Reed then stands beside Rollins, Breakker and Heyman, which turns a good television tag into the night's most consequential segment.
The match never becomes great because it is chopped apart and because the ending belongs to the angle. It is still comfortably the most complete wrestling on the show.
A good TV tag with enough star power to survive the ad breaks and a return that matters more than the finish.
02Zelina Vega def. Chelsea Green - Women's United States ChampionshipD-
Five minutes is not much room for error. Unfortunately, this match finds some anyway.
Chelsea Green gets the first meaningful opening with the powerbomb from the apron, and the match briefly settles into a sensible champion-versus-former-champion rhythm. Then Vega's 619 goes badly, Green is bloodied, and the entire thing loses whatever smoothness it had been building.
The avalanche Code Red is a strong visual finish and Vega retains cleanly despite the Secret Hervice at ringside. That is about all the match has time to rescue. The title defense feels less like a special-event attraction than a hurried obligation squeezed between larger stories.
A short, rough title defense with one excellent finishing image and very little else to recommend.
03John Cena def. R-TruthD
R-Truth comes out dressed as John Cena, to John Cena's music, to fight the John Cena who now insists the audience ruined John Cena. Wrestling occasionally writes sentences that sound like a fever.
The match is barely a match. Cena mauls Truth, Truth gets one affectionate burst using Cena's own shoulder tackles, Five Knuckle Shuffle, Attitude Adjustment and STF, and the crowd reacts because the relationship between these two men is the entire attraction.
Cena appears to reconsider using the championship belt. He hands it to the referee. Then, because this version of Cena has discovered subtlety and immediately misplaced it, he kicks Truth low and wins with the AA. The post-match belt shot completes the cruelty.
As wrestling, there is almost nothing here. As a four-minute character scene, it has a purpose.
More angle than match, but Truth's devotion gives Cena's cheap win a little emotional bite.
04Damian Priest def. Drew McIntyre - Steel Cage MatchB-
Damian Priest and Drew McIntyre finally get a cage, which should mean the feud is ending. WWE also gives them a door, which means Jesse Ventura gets a new feud of his own.
The physical material is good. McIntyre launches Priest into the cage, Priest survives the Claymore, McIntyre steals South of Heaven, and the chair becomes increasingly central as the match moves toward the finish. The problem is television architecture: the early commercial removes the middle of the climb, so the match keeps asking the audience to reconnect after momentum has already been sold to an advertiser.
Priest eventually crushes McIntyre with a Con-Chair-To and simply walks through the door. It is decisive in one sense and strangely bloodless in another. Ventura's disgust with the escape rule is almost as memorable as the match.
Still, this is sturdy, physical work between two wrestlers who know exactly how to make one another look dangerous.
A strong enough cage match weakened by commercial pacing and an escape finish that feels smaller than the violence before it.
05Jey Uso def. Logan Paul - World Heavyweight ChampionshipC-
The World Heavyweight Championship main event begins with the clock already glaring at everyone.
Jey Uso and Logan Paul have less than ten minutes to establish a title match, survive a commercial, hit the required athletic beats and leave room for two larger stars to run in. They do not really solve that equation. Paul has a few sharp moments, including the dive and the big right hand. Uso answers with the Samoan drop, superkick and splash. Nothing has enough time to accumulate weight.
Then John Cena pulls the referee out during Uso's apparent winning sequence. Cody Rhodes returns for his first appearance since WrestleMania 41, clears Cena away, and Uso finishes Paul. Cody immediately challenges Cena and Paul to face him and Uso at Money in the Bank.
The title match becomes scenery for the next card. Cody's return gets the reaction. Jey's championship gets the closing graphic.
A rushed world-title match overtaken by run-ins, returns and the need to advertise the next show.
BOOKING VERDICTC+
Booking Verdict Grade: C+. WWE moves a lot of pieces, and most of those pieces move in understandable directions.
Bronson Reed returning to join Seth Rollins, Bron Breakker and Paul Heyman gives the opening match a reason to exist beyond four popular names sharing a ring. John Cena cheating R-Truth continues the idea that Cena will choose cruelty even when given a visible chance to stop. Priest beating McIntyre inside the cage gives the feud a violent punctuation mark. Cody Rhodes returning to stop Cena creates the Money in the Bank tag match before the broadcast ends.
The weakness is that almost every match becomes subordinate to what happens next. The world-title main event is the clearest example: Jey Uso versus Logan Paul stops being about Jey Uso versus Logan Paul the instant Cena arrives. Saturday Night's Main Event advances the calendar efficiently. It rarely lets the current match be the most important thing on screen.
CROWD & PRESENTATIONC-
Crowd & Presentation Grade: C-. The old-school Saturday Night's Main Event look remains one of the revival's strongest assets. The bright ring, throwback graphics, NBC setting and Jesse Ventura give the show an identity that ordinary Raw and SmackDown episodes do not have.
The broadcast structure works against that identity. Multiple reviewers independently complained that commercial breaks arrived early and often, sometimes cutting directly through the rising action of matches that were already short. The main event is especially cramped, with barely enough time for the match before Cena's interference, Cody's return and the closing challenge.
The Tampa audience reacts when the show gives it something substantial: Punk's entrance, Reed's return, Cena and Truth's character beats, and Cody's return all land. The problem is not that the building is dead. The problem is that the broadcast keeps interrupting its own momentum.
HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEC
Historical Significance Grade: C. The event's lasting value is mostly connective.
Bronson Reed returns from the broken ankle that had kept him out since Survivor Series: WarGames 2024 and aligns with Seth Rollins, Bron Breakker and Paul Heyman, strengthening the group that would later be known as The Vision. Cody Rhodes returns for his first appearance since WrestleMania 41 and immediately enters the John Cena story on the road to Money in the Bank. Priest's cage victory closes an important chapter of his long rivalry with Drew McIntyre, and Cena's treatment of R-Truth becomes part of the strange middle stretch of Cena's final full year.
None of those developments make the show historically essential on its own. They make it a useful junction. It is connective tissue, not a landmark.
WHAT AGED WELL
- Bronson Reed's return gives the opening tag a genuine consequence beyond the result.
- The retro Saturday Night's Main Event visual package still looks distinctive.
- Damian Priest and Drew McIntyre bring enough physicality to make the cage stipulation feel earned.
- R-Truth using Cena's own offense gives a four-minute match an immediately readable emotional hook.
- Cody Rhodes' return creates a strong closing reaction even though it overwhelms the title match around it.
WHAT AGED POORLY
- Commercial interruptions repeatedly cut through matches that were already operating on compressed television time.
- The Women's United States Championship match never recovers from its rough execution.
- John Cena's rare 2025 date is spent on a match too short to become more than an angle.
- The World Heavyweight Championship main event becomes setup for Money in the Bank rather than a satisfying championship match.
- The show contains enough major names to promise a premium atmosphere but is paced like an especially crowded weekly episode.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands
The critical record is unusually split. Cagematch currently lists the complete event at 3.67 from 233 valid votes, with repeated criticism of the commercial load, rushed pacing and the main event. Its current matchguide values put the opening tag at 6.69, Vega-Green at 2.65, Cena-Truth at 4.49, Priest-McIntyre at 6.13 and Uso-Paul at 4.00.
Thomas Hall is substantially warmer, scoring the complete show 7/10 while still calling it underwhelming and rushed. His match grades are B- for the opener, C+ for Vega-Green, C for Cena-Truth, B- for the cage match and C+ for the main event. Bleacher Report is warmer again, grading the show B overall and giving B, B-, C+, B+ and B to the five matches.
The reported Wrestling Observer ratings land closer to the middle: 3.5 stars for the opening tag, no rating for Vega-Green, 1.25 for Cena-Truth, 3.75 for Priest-McIntyre and 3.25 for Uso-Paul. Scott Keith similarly sees a fun but aggressively compressed show, rating the opener three stars, Vega-Green a dud, Cena-Truth two stars, the cage match 3.25 and the main event three.
The fairest synthesis is that the event is better than its harshest crowd score but weaker than its most generous live grades. The opener and cage match are good television wrestling. The other three bouts are too short, too rough or too consumed by angles to make the complete show feel special.
RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology20 sources
These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.
- The SmackDown Hotel - Saturday Night's Main Event XXXIXEvent identity, card, venue, brands, network and results.
- Cagematch - WWE Saturday Night's Main Event #39Current event rating, matchguide values, attendance record, official video and results.
- Cagematch - WWE Saturday Night's Main Event #39 ratingsCurrent retrospective vote distribution and comments.
- 411Mania - Hall's Saturday Night's Main Event #39 Review7/10 complete-show verdict and individual match grades.
- Bleacher Report - Saturday Night's Main Event results and gradesB overall verdict and individual match grades.
- ProFightDB - Saturday Night's Main EventIndependent card and result cross-check.
- TJR Wrestling - Dave Meltzer ratingsReported Wrestling Observer match ratings.
- Smark Out Moment - Saturday Night's Main Event #39 resultsContemporary results and storyline chronology.
- APP - Saturday Night's Main Event coverageContemporary event coverage and national-TV context.
- Scott's Blog of Doom - SmarK RantIndependent retrospective and match-by-match ratings.
- Last Word on Pro Wrestling - Saturday Night's Main Event resultsBroadcast details, results and storyline developments.
- Voices of Wrestling - May 24 results and reviewCritical counterpoint, match ratings and pacing analysis.
- Forbes - Saturday Night's Main Event results and gradesContemporary grades and ticket-distribution context.
- Pro Wrestling Dot Net - Saturday Night's Main Event live reviewDetailed same-night match and angle chronology.
- PWTorch - Saturday Night's Main Event reportAttendance-reporting context and broadcast review.
- POST Wrestling - Saturday Night's Main Event reviewIndependent complete-show discussion.
- Wrestling Headlines - Saturday Night's Main Event resultsDetailed move-by-move results cross-check.
- WrestleZone - Saturday Night's Main Event results and gradesAdditional contemporary match grading and recap.
- WWE YouTube - Saturday Night's Main Event May 24 2025Official WWE video for the May 24, 2025 broadcast.
- WWEOfficial promotion context and event chronology.
WHERE TO WATCHStream This Event
Stream This Event
YouTube - Official WWE video
WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.