- Eric Young and Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed and Jay Lethal) defeated The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin) and Sheik Abdul Bashir
- Suicide (c) vs. Daniels ended in a draw
- Beer Money, Inc. (James Storm and Robert Roode) defeated The British Invasion (Brutus Magnus and Doug Williams) (with Rob Terry)
- A.J. Styles (c) defeated Booker T
- Sting defeated Jeff Jarrett, Kurt Angle and Mick Foley
Sacrifice 2009: Strong Stakes Carry an Uneven Card
The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.
- PROMOTION
- TNA Wrestling
- DATE
- May 24, 2009
- VENUE
- TNA Impact! Zone
- LOCATION
- Orlando, Florida
- ATTENDANCE
- 1,100
- EVENT TYPE
- PPV
Sacrifice 2009 is built around consequences more than sustained match quality. A. J.
Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis
Styles and Booker T receive an "I Quit" match for the Legends Championship, Suicide and Daniels go long over the X Division title, Beer Money and the British Invasion settle the Team 3D Invitational tournament, and the four-way main event attaches a different sacrifice to each participant. Those ideas give the show direction, but the card repeatedly changes tone, from a short Monster's Ball to a technical title draw to Samoa Joe versus Kevin Nash. The best matches are spread across the middle and closing stretch rather than forming one dominant run. The result is a worthwhile but selective pay-per-view: enough consequence to reward viewers following the period, yet not enough consistency to make every match essential.
Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting
Sacrifice 2009 was held at the TNA Impact! Zone in Orlando before 1,100 people and contained nine matches, beginning with Amazing Red defeating Kiyoshi on the pre-show. The main card opens with Eric Young and Lethal Consequences defeating the Motor City Machine Guns and Sheik Abdul Bashir in a six-man X Division tag. Taylor Wilde then beats Daffney in a 3:33 Monster's Ball match before Suicide and Daniels wrestle to a 17:06 draw for the X Division Championship. Angelina Love retains the Knockouts Championship against Awesome Kong, and Samoa Joe submits Kevin Nash. Beer Money defeat the British Invasion in the final of the Team 3D Invitational tournament, A.J. Styles retains the Legends Championship against Booker T in an "I Quit" match, and Sting wins the four-way Ultimate Sacrifice main event over Jeff Jarrett, Kurt Angle and Mick Foley. The card therefore moves from fast division matches toward increasingly explicit personal and career-style stakes. The running order makes the event feel like a ladder of consequences: division action opens the show, championships dominate the middle, and the final two matches attach explicit personal stakes to victories and defeats.
Watch, Skim or Skip?
- Amazing Red defeated Kiyoshi
- Angelina Love (c) defeated Awesome Kong (with Raisha Saeed)
- Samoa Joe defeated Kevin Nash by submission
- Taylor Wilde defeated Daffney (with Abyss)
The Card, On the Record
01Amazing Red defeated KiyoshiC+
Amazing Red faced Kiyoshi in a Sacrifice 2009 pre-show singles match, with neither an X Division championship nor a tournament placement at stake. Red began by knocking Kiyoshi to ringside and hitting a twisting corkscrew plancha over the ropes. Kiyoshi slowed the pace with harder strikes and a torture-rack variation, earning several near falls. Red answered with a leg lariat, but Kiyoshi cut him off on the top rope and tried forcing an aerial finish. The shorter undercard slot kept the match focused on the wrestlers' differing speeds rather than a long rivalry or elaborate stipulation.
Kiyoshi climbed for a moonsault but missed when Red moved. Red countered with a second-rope-assisted DDT and followed with a standing shooting-star press. Amazing Red pinned Kiyoshi at the independently archived 7:02. The winner and decisive finish agree across contemporary reports, while no title changed hands. The original C+ / 6.8 score stays intact because the brief opener showed agile counters without adding to the pay-per-view's principal stakes. SKIM for the closing aerial sequence and Kiyoshi's missed moonsault.
SKIM (pre-show): Amazing Red dodges Kiyoshi's moonsault and wins with a standing shooting-star press after a rope-assisted DDT.
02Eric Young and Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed and Jay Lethal) defeated The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin) and Sheik Abdul BashirB-
The main Sacrifice 2009 card opened with Jay Lethal and Consequences Creed of Lethal Consequences partnering Eric Young against the Motor City Machine Guns, Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin, and Sheik Abdul Bashir. Six wrestlers were legal participants on two three-man teams, and no junior tag championship was on the line even though Shelley and Sabin entered as IWGP Junior Heavyweight Tag Team Champions. Sabin and Lethal traded rapid counters before Young and Shelley entered, while Creed rotated through their offense with springboards and quick combinations. Young also displayed unusual power by lifting both Machine Guns at once for a double Death Valley Driver.
In the finish, Bashir forced Young out of the ring and tried resisting a sunset flip from Jay Lethal by gripping the ropes. The referee kicked Bashir's hands off the ropes, allowing the roll-up to complete. Jay Lethal pinned Sheik Abdul Bashir for his team at the recorded 13:54. Consequences Creed and Young were winners but did not score the deciding cover; Eric Young appeared unhappy with the referee's intervention after the match. The original B- / 7.4 grades a lively opener while acknowledging the officiating wrinkle. WATCH the changing six-man combinations and disputed pin.
WATCH: The referee kicks Bashir's hands off the ropes during a sunset-flip escape, and Jay Lethal pins Bashir to win the six-man tag with Creed and Young.
03Taylor Wilde defeated Daffney (with Abyss)C-
Taylor Wilde faced Daffney in TNA's first women's Monster's Ball match, an abbreviated hardcore contest that took place amid their feud involving Abyss and Dr. Stevie. Daffney and Wilde brought trash cans, a stop sign and a hockey stick into the ring. Wilde placed a trash can over Daffney's head and struck it with the stick, then landed a dropkick. Daffney answered with a kick and attempted to escape the surrounding weapons, but the match's short duration prevented the stipulation from developing into the long brawl its billing suggested. Abyss and Dr. Stevie were outside seconds in the original singles match, not two additional legal competitors.
Wilde caught Daffney and delivered a Death Valley Driver onto a trash can. Taylor Wilde pinned Daffney at the archived 3:33. The more elaborate confrontation took place after the bell: Stevie scattered thumbtacks, ordered Abyss to hurt Wilde, and struck Abyss until the wrestler turned on his own adviser and chokeslammed Stevie onto the tacks. That aftermath belongs to the event's angle, not to the original winner's pin or Monster's Ball scoring. The inherited C- / 5.6 reflects a short bout with a memorable post-match scene. SKIP for match quality unless following the characters.
SKIP: Wilde defeats Daffney in the brief Monster's Ball match with a Death Valley Driver onto a trash can; Abyss attacks Dr. Stevie only after the result.
04Suicide (c) vs. Daniels ended in a drawB+
Suicide defended the TNA X Division Championship against Daniels after a controversial challenge to the masked champion's identity. Daniels countered Suicide's aerial offense with a series of holds and slams, while Suicide survived several near falls. The Motor City Machine Guns then interfered: Chris Sabin distracted the referee and Alex Shelley attacked Suicide. Daniels covered Suicide and was initially announced as the new champion, but an arena replay revealed the illegal involvement. Daniels refused to accept a title won through somebody else's interference and requested that the referee restart the match for five minutes. Suicide agreed, so the preliminary three-count was not the final recognized decision.
The overtime resumed with desperate counters, and Daniels almost finished Suicide with a late offensive sequence. Suicide survived and answered with a near fall of his own, but the allotted five minutes expired without a decisive cover or submission. Suicide retained the X Division Championship in a draw. The important distinction is between the first tainted apparent result and the official outcome after Daniels' sporting decision to restart. The inherited B+ / 8.0 captures the wrestling and the unusually consequential sportsmanship angle; it does not turn the first announced Daniels victory into the historical final result.
DRAW: Daniels voluntarily restarts the match after his interference-assisted pin, but neither man earns a fall in the added five minutes.
05Angelina Love (c) defeated Awesome Kong (with Raisha Saeed)C
Angelina Love defended the TNA Knockouts Championship against Awesome Kong, with Raisha Saeed accompanying the challenger. Kong used her size to dominate the early contest, knocking Love down with heavy strikes and preventing the champion from sustaining offense. Love tried to keep moving, but Kong repeatedly dragged her back and threatened a finishing power move. Saeed's presence became relevant only when Love reached for a spray bottle at ringside. Kong accidentally knocked Saeed from the apron while trying to stop the attempted interference, leaving the champion with a momentary opening. This was still a singles title defense, not a handicap match involving Saeed.
Love sprayed Kong in the eyes and quickly caught the blinded challenger in a roll-up. Angelina Love pinned Awesome Kong to retain the Knockouts Championship at the recorded finish. Kong answered after the bell with repeated Implant Busters, but those attacks were outside the official contest and did not reverse the result. The decisive pin was therefore a tainted escape by the champion rather than a decisive power reversal. The original C / 6.3 reflects a brief title defense dependent on ringside distraction; SKIM the finish and separate Kong's post-match retaliation.
SKIM: Love sprays Kong in the eyes and rolls her up to retain the Knockouts championship; Kong retaliates after the bell.
06Samoa Joe defeated Kevin Nash by submissionC+
Samoa Joe fought Kevin Nash in a singles match that grew out of their bitter personal split. Joe attacked without delay and focused on Nash's injured body, while Nash used his size to halt the younger wrestler's rush. A bloodied Nash managed hard strikes and near falls despite Joe's aggressive offense. Joe repeatedly pursued a rear-naked choke, but Nash reached the ropes on earlier attempts and the referee required a break. Those interruptions explain why the final submission was different from an ordinary choke applied in mid-ring. Neither wrestler entered as a defending champion on this card.
Joe secured another choke and pulled Nash's arm away from the ropes so that the veteran could not escape by grabbing them again. Samoa Joe forced Kevin Nash to submit to the rear-naked choke, ending the match without a pinfall. Joe then continued attacking after the bell until officials and Scott Steiner became involved; the post-match violence did not convert the official submission into a disqualification. The inherited C+ / 6.7 reflects a direct physical encounter with a clearly established final hold. SKIM the repeated rope-break attempts and the final trapped-arm adjustment.
SKIM: Nash survives two rope breaks, but Joe traps the arm on the final choke and forces Nash to tap instead of scoring a pin.
07Beer Money, Inc. (James Storm and Robert Roode) defeated The British Invasion (Brutus Magnus and Doug Williams) (with Rob Terry)B
Beer Money's James Storm and Robert Roode met the British Invasion's Doug Williams and Brutus Magnus in the finals of Team 3D's tag-team tournament. Winning the tournament, not immediately capturing the TNA World Tag Team Championship, was the prize. Rob Terry accompanied the British team and repeatedly attempted to alter the referee's decisions. Beer Money built offense through fast tags and coordinated holds, while Magnus and Williams sought to isolate one opponent and use their ringside numerical advantage. When Terry pulled the referee away from a Beer Money cover, the official ejected him from ringside, leaving the four actual wrestlers to contest the finish.
Williams still had access to the Feast or Fired briefcase and attempted to use it as a weapon. Roode wrestled the case away, and Storm delivered a superkick that drove Williams back into it. Robert Roode pinned Doug Williams to win the tag tournament final for Beer Money. Magnus was a losing legal partner but did not receive the deciding fall. The case involvement and Terry's attempted interference should not be misrepresented as a routine clean pin or a tag-title transfer on this particular night. The inherited B / 7.7 recognizes the lively team exchanges and consequential tournament outcome. WATCH the late sequence.
WATCH: After Rob Terry is ejected for interfering, Storm superkicks Williams into a briefcase and Roode pins him to win the tag tournament final.
08A.J. Styles (c) defeated Booker TB+
A.J. Styles defended the TNA Legends Championship against Booker T in an I Quit match, a stipulation under which a three-count pin could not determine the title. Styles attacked aggressively and tried to force Booker to give up through sustained holds. Booker answered with veteran counterwrestling and repeatedly declined to speak the required words. Sharmell supported Booker at ringside while Jenna also took part in the wider feud's interference. The spectators and referee had to judge whether a surrender was actually communicated, making the difference between the wrestler's own words and a ringside towel important to the record.
Styles eventually caught Booker in a punishing flying armbar. Booker refused to say 'I Quit,' but Jenna threw a towel into the ring as he suffered in the hold. The referee ended the bout and A.J. Styles retained the Legends Championship after Jenna threw in the towel. The result was a stoppage caused by a third party rather than an audible submission or pinfall by Booker. The inherited B+ / 8.3 reflects an emotionally convincing final hold and the controversial ringside decision. WATCH the final armbar and distinguish the ruling from Booker's actual refusal.
WATCH: Booker refuses to say 'I Quit' in Styles' armbar, but Jenna throws in the towel, leading to a referee stoppage and Styles retaining the Legends title.
09Sting defeated Jeff Jarrett, Kurt Angle and Mick FoleyB+
Ultimate Sacrifice paired Sting, Jeff Jarrett, Kurt Angle and reigning TNA World Heavyweight Champion Mick Foley in a four-way where each wrestler risked a different possession. Foley put up his championship, Sting his career, Jarrett his company shares and Angle his leadership of the Main Event Mafia. A wrestler's stake was on the line if he lost the decisive fall, so there was no guarantee that Foley's belt would change hands simply because the match had a winner. All four wrestlers competed legally rather than in tag teams. They exchanged alliances and interruptions as each attempted to ensure somebody else's stake would be lost.
Jarrett ultimately caught Angle and delivered the Stroke from an elevated position onto a steel chair. As Jarrett tried to capitalize, Sting reached Angle first and covered him. Sting pinned Kurt Angle, taking over leadership of the Main Event Mafia under the stipulation. Foley had not been pinned and therefore kept the World Heavyweight Championship; Sting did not retire and Jarrett did not lose his shares. The individual who took the fall, not merely who won a four-way, determined the particular reward. The inherited B+ / 8.2 credits the unusual high-stakes structure while recording the precise outcome. WATCH the final Jarrett-to-Sting reversal.
WATCH: After Jarrett drives Angle onto a chair with the Stroke, Sting steals the fall on Angle and gains leadership of the Main Event Mafia; Foley retains the world title.
BOOKING VERDICTB-
The card has a clear appetite for stipulations and consequences, but the execution is uneven. Styles-Booker benefits from a simple "I Quit" premise and a championship attached to it, while the tournament final gives Beer Money a straightforward competitive objective. The X Division title draw protects both Suicide and Daniels but leaves a long match without a decisive payoff. The main event's Ultimate Sacrifice format gives all four wrestlers different risks and makes Sting's victory significant within the night's structure. Shorter bouts such as Wilde-Daffney and Love-Kong feel compressed beside those larger ideas, so the booking is stronger at creating stakes than at distributing time evenly across them.
CROWD & PRESENTATIONB-
The Impact Zone gives Sacrifice a familiar, compact presentation, which makes the unusual stipulations responsible for most of the show's visual variety. Monster's Ball arrives early and briefly, the X Division title match changes the pace by running more than seventeen minutes, and the "I Quit" match provides a direct late-card confrontation. The four-way main event then relies on its layered sacrifice rules rather than arena scale to create importance. That structure keeps the show from looking monotonous, although the studio setting limits the grandeur of the biggest ideas. The event feels most effective when the rules are simple enough to understand immediately and the match receives enough time to let the stakes register.
HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB
Sacrifice 2009 preserves a period when TNA's title picture and factional hierarchy were constantly crossing paths. A.J. Styles retains the Legends Championship against Booker T, placing a prominent homegrown name directly against a Main Event Mafia member. Samoa Joe submits Kevin Nash, while Sting, Jeff Jarrett, Kurt Angle and Mick Foley share the main event with individual sacrifices attached to the result. The X Division remains central through a six-man opener and a long Suicide-Daniels championship draw, and Beer Money's tournament victory keeps the tag division tied to Team 3D's broader championship orbit. The show is therefore less important for one singular match than for how many active programs it collects in one place. It documents a company using stipulations, tournaments and multi-person consequences to keep several divisions moving simultaneously.
WHAT AGED WELL
- Styles and Booker T get a simple, high-stakes stipulation that is easy to understand and substantial enough to anchor the late card.
- Beer Money versus the British Invasion gives the tag division a tournament payoff rather than a stand-alone exhibition.
- The main event's different sacrifices create a clear reason for all four wrestlers to care about the same result.
WHAT AGED POORLY
- Monster's Ball lasts only 3:33, leaving a violent stipulation with little room to develop.
- The long X Division title draw asks viewers to accept seventeen minutes without a decisive championship resolution.
- Several consecutive matches rely on added rules or story devices, making the card feel busier than the wrestling requires.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands
Sacrifice 2009 presents a card with nine matches and multiple distinct stakes, but its strongest material is concentrated in four bouts. Suicide-Daniels receives the most time, Styles-Booker has the clearest one-on-one stipulation, Beer Money-British Invasion resolves a tournament, and the four-way main event carries the event's defining concept. The shorter Monster's Ball and Knockouts title matches create abrupt changes in rhythm, while Joe-Nash works more as a consequential result than as the night's central wrestling attraction. The evidence supports a good-but-selective verdict: the event advances several divisions and stories in visible ways, yet the uneven time allocation and repeated reliance on special rules keep it from becoming a consistently strong complete show.
RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology6 sources
These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.
- WikipediaEvent identity, card results, venue/date context, and historical corroboration.
- Pro Wrestling HistoryCard results, match durations, stipulations, title context, and historical corroboration.
- PWTorchContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
- Internet ArchiveArchived event context, promotion context, and historical corroboration.
- Internet ArchiveArchived event context, promotion context, and historical corroboration.
- Internet ArchiveArchived event context, promotion context, and historical corroboration.
WHERE TO WATCHStream This Event
Stream This Event
Locked factual research established no current provider that can be asserted safely here; no territory-safe direct viewing destination is included.
WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.