WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

No Way Out 2005: Cena Breaks Through While a Thin SmackDown Card Struggles Around Him

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

WWEFebruary 20, 2005Mellon Arena
THE WRESTLEGRADED+5.1 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#972OF 1030
PROMOTION
World Wrestling Entertainment
DATE
February 20, 2005
VENUE
Mellon Arena
LOCATION
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
ATTENDANCE
9,500
EVENT TYPE
PPV
THE FILE

No Way Out 2005 is the kind of pay-per-view whose most important moments are much better than the show surrounding them. Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio open with a strong tag-title win, John Cena finally defeats Kurt Angle in an excellent number-one-contender final, and JBL escapes Big Show with one of the strangest cage-match finishes WWE ever attempted. Those three matches give the card legitimate value. The problem is everything between them. Booker T versus Heidenreich is a six-minute dead end, the Cruiserweight Open is rushed, and The Undertaker versus Luther Reigns never convinces the crowd that the upset is remotely possible.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

The event also keeps interrupting itself with the Rookie Diva of the Year competition, which ages poorly and drains momentum from an already thin SmackDown-only card. Still, the WrestleMania direction is unmistakable by the finish. Cena earns JBL, Batista appears to tease his choice of champion, and the show ends with both future WrestleMania 21 headliners standing tall. WrestleFile lands at D+, 5.1 out of 10. It is not a good complete event, but Cena-Angle, the tag-title opener, and the creative cage escape prevent it from becoming disposable.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

No Way Out 2005 took place on February 20 at Pittsburgh's Mellon Arena before a reported crowd of 9,500. It was the seventh No Way Out event and the final WWE pay-per-view before WrestleMania 21. Six matches aired on the pay-per-view, while Charlie Haas and Hardcore Holly defeated Kenzo Suzuki and Rene Dupree in a Sunday Night Heat match before the broadcast; that match is excluded from these grades. The card was exclusive to SmackDown and centered on JBL defending the WWE Championship against Big Show inside a steel cage topped with barbed wire. The other major attraction was the final of a tournament to determine JBL's WrestleMania challenger, with John Cena facing Kurt Angle.

The event came at a decisive point in WWE's 2005 transition. Cena was moving from United States Champion to first-time world-title challenger, Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio were beginning a tag-team partnership that would eventually become a major rivalry, and Batista's Royal Rumble victory still allowed WWE to tease whether he might leave Raw to challenge JBL. The card also included a Cruiserweight Championship change to Chavo Guerrero and an Undertaker victory over Luther Reigns. The show drew roughly 240,000 pay-per-view buys, one of WWE's weaker numbers of the year, reinforcing how much the February brand-exclusive events depended on WrestleMania setup rather than standalone attraction.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • Eddie Guerrero & Rey Mysterio vs. The Basham Brothers — WWE Tag Team Championship
  • John Cena vs. Kurt Angle — WWE Championship No. 1 Contender Tournament Final
SKIM
  • Cruiserweight Open — WWE Cruiserweight Championship
  • JBL vs. Big Show — WWE Championship Barbed Wire Steel Cage Match
SKIP
  • Booker T vs. Heidenreich
  • The Undertaker vs. Luther Reigns
MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

The Card, On the Record

01Eddie Guerrero & Rey Mysterio def. The Basham Brothers — WWE Tag Team ChampionshipB-

The opener gives the card exactly what it needs: recognizable stars, clear tag structure, and enough time for the match to develop. The Bashams isolate Mysterio with quick switches and grounded control while Guerrero waits for the hot tag, creating an easy rhythm for the crowd to follow. Eddie's eventual comeback adds the personality the champions lack, especially when he begins looking for shortcuts. Mysterio initially objects to using the title belt, then helps create the distraction once the Bashams try cheating first. Eddie blasts Doug with the belt while Rey lands the 619, and the challengers win the titles. The finish fits Guerrero perfectly and begins an important partnership without sacrificing the match's solid wrestling base.

VERDICT

A strong opener that combines traditional tag structure with Eddie Guerrero's character and a meaningful title change.

02Booker T def. HeidenreichF

Heidenreich controls too much of a short match without having the offense or pacing to make that control interesting. Booker supplies the recognizable movements, including the side kick, spinebuster, and Spinaroonie, but several exchanges look mistimed and the crowd never settles into the idea that this is building somewhere useful. The finish makes the whole segment worse. Heidenreich takes the fight outside, grabs a chair, and strikes Booker in the throat directly in front of the referee for an obvious disqualification. He then rolls Booker back inside and tries to pin him as though he does not understand the match is over. That is consistent with the character, but it turns an already weak contest into a joke rather than a meaningful feud chapter.

VERDICT

A sloppy, low-energy match capped by a disqualification that makes both the wrestling and feud feel disposable.

03Chavo Guerrero won the Cruiserweight Open — WWE Cruiserweight ChampionshipD+

Paul London is the reason the Cruiserweight Open has any sustained energy. He eliminates Funaki, Spike Dudley, Shannon Moore, and Akio while introducing the match's best athletic sequences, including the 450 Splash and a top-rope neckbreaker. The problem is the format. Several eliminations occur after very little punishment, the entrants arrive too quickly for individual stories to form, and Akio's countdown elimination feels especially anticlimactic. Chavo Guerrero enters last with a structural advantage, survives London's late comeback, and steals the title by reversing a roll-up while using the ropes. The result makes sense for Chavo's heel character, but the match never lets its talented field build momentum. It functions as a title change more than a showcase.

VERDICT

Paul London provides the highlights, but the rushed elimination format keeps the cruiserweights from producing a memorable title match.

04The Undertaker def. Luther ReignsF

The central problem is credibility: almost nobody in the building believes Luther Reigns is beating The Undertaker. Reigns gets enough control to fill eleven minutes, using the exposed turnbuckle, a low blow, basic power offense, and a leg submission while commentary works aggressively to portray him as dangerous. The crowd remains mostly quiet because the match never offers a convincing reason to change expectations. Undertaker's comeback follows the familiar sequence of corner clotheslines, Snake Eyes, the big boot, chokeslam, and eventually the Tombstone. Reigns briefly interrupts the finish with a reverse DDT, but even that near fall generates little suspense. The work is less chaotic than Booker-Heidenreich, yet the length makes the boredom more damaging. This feels like television filler occupying pay-per-view time.

VERDICT

An overlong and completely predictable Undertaker showcase against an opponent the audience never accepts as a threat.

05John Cena def. Kurt Angle — WWE Championship No. 1 Contender Tournament FinalA-

Angle gives Cena the ideal opponent for a breakthrough match because every exchange tests whether the younger star can survive a superior technician. Angle controls the opening mat work, launches Cena into the turnbuckle with a German suplex, and repeatedly returns to the ankle once Cena's power comeback begins. Cena survives the Angle Slam, escapes multiple Ankle Locks, and even kicks out of sequences that would have finished him earlier in his career. The match wisely avoids the expected Shawn Michaels interference, allowing Cena's victory to stand on its own. After Angle accidentally strikes the referee and reaches for Cena's chain, Cena tackles him and lands a final FU for the pin. The win feels earned, consequential, and perfectly timed for WrestleMania.

VERDICT

An excellent star-making victory that gives Cena credibility by forcing him to survive Kurt Angle at his most relentless.

06JBL def. Big Show — WWE Championship Barbed Wire Steel Cage MatchC+

The cage match is methodical for long stretches, but the violence and finish give it a distinct identity. JBL tries to avoid the barbed wire while Big Show uses his size to control the champion, eventually bleeding after being driven into the cage. The Cabinet's interference introduces bolt cutters, and JBL uses them as a weapon before trying to cut his way out. The match peaks when Big Show catches JBL on the ropes and chokeslams him through the ring. Show then breaks the door chain and steps toward the floor, apparently winning, only for JBL to be declared the victor because he crawled underneath the ring and escaped first. It is ridiculous and clever at the same time, perfectly matching JBL's championship character.

VERDICT

A slow but memorable brawl whose spectacular chokeslam and ingenious escape finish save an otherwise ordinary cage match.

BOOKING VERDICTB-

The top of the card is booked with a clear destination. Cena beating Angle gives the rising star a major victory over an established former champion and sends him to WrestleMania without interference deciding the result. JBL retaining is predictable, but his escape through the hole left by Big Show's super chokeslam fits the champion's entire run as a survivor who keeps finding improbable ways to leave with the title. The post-match involvement of Cena and Batista then makes the WrestleMania stakes visible without changing either brand's final direction. Eddie and Rey winning the tag titles is another useful result because it starts a partnership that becomes central to SmackDown after WrestleMania.

The undercard is far less convincing. Heidenreich intentionally getting disqualified against Booker T protects nobody and advances little. Chavo's cruiserweight win is sensible, but the compressed elimination format makes most of the field feel disposable. Undertaker beating Reigns is so inevitable that eleven minutes become an exercise in waiting for the Tombstone. The repeated beauty-contest segments consume time that could have strengthened the wrestling card. Booking earns a B-minus because the matches that matter point toward excellent future programs, even though much of the actual event feels like filler.

CROWD & PRESENTATIONC

Pittsburgh responds strongly to the wrestlers who matter most. Eddie and Rey receive a warm reaction when they win the tag titles, Angle gets the expected hometown recognition mixed with his usual chants, Cena is clearly treated like a rising main-event star, and Undertaker remains over even when his opponent gives the audience little reason to invest. The crowd becomes most engaged during Cena-Angle, especially once Angle begins trapping the ankle and Cena survives increasingly serious finishing attempts. The cage main event also benefits from the visual shock of blood, bolt cutters, and the super chokeslam through the ring.

Presentation is more damaging than the audience. The Rookie Diva of the Year segments repeatedly interrupt the wrestling with evening gowns, a talent contest, and a swimsuit round, giving the show an especially dated tone. The barbed-wire cage looks dangerous, but the rule allowing escape sits awkwardly beside a structure designed to prevent climbing. Commentary works hard to maintain the Batista uncertainty even though the WrestleMania direction feels obvious. Crowd and Presentation earns a C because the important matches have atmosphere, while the surrounding show frequently feels cheap and unfocused.

HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB

No Way Out 2005 earns a B for Historical Significance primarily because John Cena's victory over Kurt Angle is one of the last major steps before his first WWE Championship reign. Cena had debuted against Angle in 2002 and lost to him again on pay-per-view in 2003, so defeating him here gives the WrestleMania push a useful sense of progression. Cena goes on to beat JBL at WrestleMania 21 and becomes the central WWE star of the next decade. The event also positions Batista and Cena simultaneously as the company's next two world-title centerpieces, echoing the final pairing from the Royal Rumble three weeks earlier.

The rest of the card has meaningful consequences too. Guerrero and Mysterio winning the tag titles begins the partnership that leads to their WrestleMania match and one of SmackDown's defining 2005 rivalries. Chavo Guerrero's title win redirects the cruiserweight division toward Paul London. JBL's escape preserves his long reign for the Cena payoff, while the unusual finish remains one of the most memorable examples of creative cage-match booking. The show itself is not historically beloved, but several of WWE's major 2005 stories pass directly through Pittsburgh.

WHAT AGED WELL
  • John Cena defeating Kurt Angle still feels like a meaningful graduation from upper-midcard star to WrestleMania world-title challenger.
  • Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio winning the tag titles begins one of SmackDown's most important storylines of 2005.
  • The super chokeslam through the ring remains an excellent visual and gives JBL's escape a memorable physical setup.
  • JBL's bizarre route to victory perfectly matches the escape-artist identity of his championship reign.
  • The show is relatively short, which keeps its worst undercard stretches from becoming even more exhausting.
WHAT AGED POORLY
  • The Rookie Diva of the Year competitions repeatedly reduce women to presentation segments rather than wrestling and badly date the broadcast.
  • Booker T versus Heidenreich is sloppy, brief, and ends with an unproductive disqualification.
  • Undertaker versus Luther Reigns is far too long for a matchup with virtually no believable upset possibility.
  • The Cruiserweight Open rushes several talented wrestlers through eliminations before the crowd can invest in them.
  • The barbed-wire cage rules are conceptually messy because a match designed to prevent escape is still officially won by escaping.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

The critical record consistently identifies three useful matches and a weak middle. TJR Wrestling rates the complete show 4 out of 10, gives Cena-Angle four stars, the tag-title opener three stars, and JBL-Big Show two-and-a-half, while calling the remaining wrestling and recurring women's segments poor. J.D. Dunn's 411Mania breakdown is similarly negative overall, giving the show a mild thumbs down. Dunn rates Eddie and Rey against the Bashams three-and-a-half stars and Cena-Angle three-and-three-quarter stars, but only two stars to the cage main event and less to the weakest undercard bouts.

CAGEMATCH's current event rating sits close to the middle of the scale, with Cena-Angle clearly the highest-rated match on the card and Booker-Heidenreich at the bottom. That supports a complete-event score below average rather than outright catastrophe. A controlled -0.100 adjustment recognizes the strong WrestleMania setup, Cena's breakthrough, the Eddie-Rey title change, and the memorable cage finish without ignoring how much of the event is poor. The resulting 5.4 remains close to the broader historical consensus.

RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
20 sources

These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

  1. TJR WrestlingFull-event retrospective with match ratings, final score, and WrestleMania setup analysis
  2. 411ManiaContemporary breakdown with match ratings and overall recommendation
  3. 411ManiaThrowback video review of the complete event
  4. WhatCulture2005 pay-per-view ranking highlighting the strongest matches on No Way Out
  5. Bleacher ReportRetrospective list of major moments from No Way Out 2005
  6. Bleacher ReportRetrospective match grades and event assessment
  7. WWEOfficial No Way Out 2005 results and championship outcomes
  8. CAGEMATCHExact-event identity, date, venue, card, and current community ratings
  9. ProFightDBExact-event results reference with match times and event-specific wrestling data
  10. IWNerdPublished Dave Meltzer star-rating reference for No Way Out 2005
  11. Slam WrestlingContemporary event report covering the cage match and WrestleMania direction
  12. 411ManiaBig Show retrospective grading the Barbed Wire Steel Cage main event
  13. 411ManiaEddie Guerrero retrospective evaluating the tag-title match with Rey Mysterio
  14. 411ManiaRetrospective discussion of No Way Out's placement and Cena's contender victory
  15. PWTorchContemporary detailed pay-per-view report from Pittsburgh
  16. WrestleViewContemporary No Way Out 2005 results report
  17. TheSportsterSeries retrospective ranking No Way Out events and discussing the 2005 card
  18. Scott's Blog of DoomFull-event retrospective covering match quality and historical reputation
  19. KB's Wrestling ReviewsFull-event retrospective emphasizing the weak middle and stronger marquee matches
  20. WrestleZoneContemporary reader reactions illustrating the sharply divided reception
WHERE TO WATCH

Stream This Event

Checked August 23, 2026STATUS
No confirmed full-event stream

Netflix's public No Way Out page currently identifies the visible title as the 2012 event and reports it unavailable in the current country. A complete United States replay of No Way Out 2005 could not be verified.

WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.