WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

The Great American Bash 2007: Cena and Lashley Dragged a Messy Card Across the Finish Line

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

WWEJuly 22, 2007HP Pavilion
THE WRESTLEGRADEC+6.7 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#763OF 1015
PROMOTION
World Wrestling Entertainment
DATE
July 22, 2007
VENUE
HP Pavilion
LOCATION
San Jose, California
ATTENDANCE
13,034
EVENT TYPE
PPV
THE FILE

The Great American Bash 2007 is a strange pay-per-view because the best wrestling sits at opposite ends of the quality spectrum from the worst. MVP and Matt Hardy open with a strong title match, Umaga and Jeff Hardy turn a simple size mismatch into one of the night's best bouts, and John Cena against Bobby Lashley closes with the kind of serious main-event presentation WWE had promised. In between, the show wanders through Hornswoggle winning the Cruiserweight Championship, a lifeless Singapore Cane on a Pole match, a short women's title defense, and a World Heavyweight Championship match built around minimizing The Great Khali's limitations. The highs are real, but so are the valleys.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

What saves the event is placement. Cena-Lashley is the advertised main event and delivers, giving the show a final act that feels larger than everything before it. Umaga-Jeff Hardy provides a second genuine peak, while MVP-Matt Hardy gives the card a useful early anchor. WrestleFile lands at C+, 6.7 out of 10. The final WrestleGrade lands there because the strongest bout closes the show, the crowd is hot for the important matches, and the main-event promise is fulfilled. It stops well short of B territory because three undercard matches are poor and several championship programs feel transitional.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

The Great American Bash 2007 took place on July 22, 2007, at HP Pavilion in San Jose, California, with an attendance of 13,034. It was WWE's fourth annual Great American Bash and the 18th event under the broader Great American Bash lineage. After WWE ended brand-exclusive monthly pay-per-views following WrestleMania 23, this became the first WWE Great American Bash to feature Raw, SmackDown, and ECW together. The card arrived during an injury-heavy period: Edge had been forced to vacate the World Heavyweight Championship only days earlier after tearing his pectoral muscle, which led to The Great Khali becoming champion and the planned SmackDown title picture being rebuilt at the last moment.

Chuck Palumbo defeated Chris Masters before the broadcast, and that dark match is excluded from the WrestleFile average. The nine televised matches were MVP against Matt Hardy for the United States Championship; a Cruiserweight Open won by Hornswoggle; Carlito against The Sandman in a Singapore Cane on a Pole match; Candice Michelle against Melina for the Women's Championship; Umaga against Jeff Hardy for the Intercontinental Championship; John Morrison against CM Punk for the ECW World Championship; Randy Orton against Dusty Rhodes in a Texas Bullrope match; The Great Khali against Batista and Kane for the World Heavyweight Championship; and John Cena against Bobby Lashley for the WWE Championship.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • MVP vs. Matt Hardy — United States Championship
  • Umaga vs. Jeff Hardy — Intercontinental Championship
  • John Cena vs. Bobby Lashley — WWE Championship
SKIM
  • Chavo Guerrero vs. Jimmy Wang Yang vs. Shannon Moore vs. Funaki vs. Jamie Noble vs. Hornswoggle — Cruiserweight Championship Open
  • Candice Michelle vs. Melina — Women's Championship
  • John Morrison vs. CM Punk — ECW World Championship
  • Randy Orton vs. Dusty Rhodes — Texas Bullrope Match
SKIP
  • Carlito vs. The Sandman — Singapore Cane on a Pole Match
  • The Great Khali vs. Batista vs. Kane — World Heavyweight Championship
MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

The Card, On the Record

01MVP def. Matt Hardy — United States ChampionshipB

MVP and Matt Hardy open with the kind of straightforward championship match that immediately gives the card credibility. Hardy controls enough early exchanges to make the title feel vulnerable, while MVP gradually redirects the match toward sharper counters and targeted offense. The running boot is the nastiest strike of the bout, and Hardy sells it like a genuine knockout attempt rather than just another transition. Both men receive believable near falls without rushing into a finishing sequence. MVP eventually lands the Playmaker and retains cleanly, which matters because the rivalry still has room to grow. The match is not spectacular, but it is balanced, competitive, and professionally paced from bell to bell.

VERDICT

A strong opener that makes MVP look credible without diminishing Matt Hardy as the chase continues.

02Hornswoggle def. Chavo Guerrero, Jimmy Wang Yang, Shannon Moore, Funaki and Jamie Noble — Cruiserweight Championship OpenC

The Cruiserweight Open has enough fast movement to stay watchable, but the match is ultimately remembered for a comedy surprise rather than the division's wrestling. Chavo Guerrero, Jimmy Wang Yang, Shannon Moore, Funaki, and Jamie Noble all cycle through quick offense while Hornswoggle hides underneath the ring after entering unexpectedly. The crowd is quiet through much of the early action and responds more strongly once the finish becomes clear. Hornswoggle appears, hits the Tadpole Splash on Noble, and wins the championship without ever functioning as a serious participant. The moment gets a reaction, but it also changes the title's tone immediately. The wrestlers work hard; the booking turns the match into a punch line.

VERDICT

Decent cruiserweight action overtaken by a title change that transforms the division into comedy.

03Carlito def. The Sandman — Singapore Cane on a Pole MatchF

Carlito and The Sandman are hurt by a stipulation that promises one thing and then refuses to provide it. The entire point of a Singapore Cane on a Pole match is the anticipation of someone finally reaching the weapon, so the crowd waits for that escalation instead of investing in the ordinary wrestling underneath it. Sandman eventually retrieves the cane, but Carlito immediately cuts him off with the Backstabber and wins before the weapon creates any meaningful payoff. The finish is technically clever for a heel, yet it leaves the audience with the sense that the match avoided its own reason for existing. At barely five minutes, it feels more like an unfinished television angle.

VERDICT

A stipulation match that withholds the exact payoff the audience was waiting to see.

04Candice Michelle def. Melina — Women's ChampionshipD

Candice Michelle and Melina receive just over six minutes for a championship rematch, which leaves the bout with almost no time to develop beyond basic exchanges. Candice has clearly improved and hits several athletic spots cleanly, including the top-rope crossbody, while Melina supplies the steadier connective work and attacks the arm. The problem is rhythm. Transitions arrive too quickly, several sequences look loose, and the crowd never becomes fully invested in the possibility of a title change. Candice wins with the Candy Wrapper to retain and gets a positive celebration afterward. The result is fine, but the championship deserves a match with more structure and more breathing room.

VERDICT

An earnest but rushed title defense that shows improvement without reaching pay-per-view quality.

05Umaga def. Jeff Hardy — Intercontinental ChampionshipB+

Umaga and Jeff Hardy deliver the night's best undercard match by making the size difference the entire story. Umaga controls with brutal power, whips Jeff into the turnbuckles, and uses the vice grip to slow a challenger whose only real path is movement. Jeff's selling is excellent because every comeback feels like it costs him something. The crowd grows louder with each escape, then fully buys the Swanton Bomb as a possible finish when Jeff finally lands it. Umaga surviving, countering the Twist of Fate, and finishing with the Samoan Spike restores the monster presentation without erasing Jeff's effort. The last five minutes are especially strong and turn simple heavyweight psychology into genuine drama.

VERDICT

A terrific power-versus-speed match elevated by Jeff Hardy's selling and a crowd that believes in the comeback.

06John Morrison def. CM Punk — ECW World ChampionshipC

John Morrison and CM Punk again produce a match that is perfectly competent without matching the talent involved. Punk gets the stronger crowd reaction and creates the better bursts whenever he strings together kicks and counters, while Morrison tries to slow the challenger and repeatedly looks for ways to escape pressure. The match has a few awkward transitions, and the crowd never reaches the intensity expected from a world-title program. The finish is flat but logical: Punk attempts a springboard attack, Morrison raises a knee into Punk's leg, and the champion immediately covers for the pin. The result keeps the rivalry moving, yet nothing about the eight minutes feels like a definitive championship chapter.

VERDICT

Average title wrestling from two performers capable of far more, with another finish that lands softly.

07Randy Orton def. Dusty Rhodes — Texas Bullrope MatchC-

Randy Orton versus Dusty Rhodes is built around age, hatred, and the bullrope rather than athletic ambition, which is the correct approach. Dusty uses the rope to yank Orton into the post and creates sympathy through his selling, while Orton gradually shifts the match toward the cowbell and targeted punishment. A long chinlock slows an already short bout, but the closing sequence is clear and effective. Dusty starts his elbow comeback, Orton avoids the elbow drop, then uses the cowbell to the head for the pin. The post-match threat brings Cody Rhodes into the story. As Dusty's final match, it is more important as a generational handoff than as wrestling.

VERDICT

A short, functional generational match that succeeds through story more than physical quality.

08The Great Khali def. Batista and Kane — World Heavyweight ChampionshipF

The Great Khali, Batista, and Kane are forced into a match created by Edge's injury, and the emergency construction shows. Khali dominates with basic strikes and holds until Batista and Kane finally cooperate long enough to drive him through the announce table. That is the best idea because it removes the champion and lets the two challengers produce the match's fastest stretch. Several near falls briefly wake the crowd, especially Kane's Chokeslam and Batista's power offense. Khali eventually returns, pulls Batista away from a pin, and defeats Kane with the two-handed Chokeslam. The finish protects Batista, but the match never escapes the limitations created by centering the action on Khali.

VERDICT

A last-minute world-title solution structured mainly around keeping Khali out of the hardest parts.

09John Cena def. Bobby Lashley — WWE ChampionshipA-

John Cena and Bobby Lashley deliver exactly what the promotion promises: two heavily pushed athletes trying to prove which man belongs on top. Lashley starts with power and speed, Cena answers with experience, and the match gradually increases the scale instead of rushing through signature moves. The first Attitude Adjustment produces a strong near fall, Lashley's spear looks like a believable championship-winning moment, and the crowd stays loud because neither wrestler is treated as obviously secondary. The finish gives the match its best image, with Cena lifting Lashley from the second rope and landing the elevated Attitude Adjustment. The handshake afterward keeps Lashley strong and gives a serious main event a respectful ending.

VERDICT

A major-feeling WWE title match that delivers on its promotion and gives Lashley a credible main-event showcase.

BOOKING VERDICTC-

The Booking Verdict earns a C- because the top programs mostly land while several undercard decisions age badly. John Cena beating Bobby Lashley clean with the top-rope Attitude Adjustment gives the main event a decisive finish without humiliating the challenger, and the post-match handshake preserves Lashley's stature. MVP retaining against Matt Hardy continues a feud that would become one of SmackDown's strongest mid-card stories, while Umaga beating Jeff Hardy keeps the champion dominant after a competitive match. Randy Orton defeating Dusty Rhodes is also the obvious generational result and feeds directly into Orton's continuing feud with the Rhodes family.

The largest problem is Hornswoggle winning the Cruiserweight Championship. The surprise gets a reaction, but it turns a division title into a comedy prop and is followed by the championship's retirement only months later. The Khali title match protects Batista by having Kane take the fall, yet the entire world-title direction exists because Edge's injury forced a late rewrite. Candice-Melina and Carlito-Sandman add little, while Morrison-Punk continues a program that still has not found its best chemistry. The big matches make sense; the middle of the card often feels improvised or disposable.

CROWD & PRESENTATIONB

Crowd and Presentation earns a B because San Jose does more for the show than several of the matches deserve. Matt Hardy gets a strong opening reaction, Jeff Hardy's comeback against Umaga produces one of the loudest undercard responses, and the audience treats Cena-Lashley like a genuine heavyweight confrontation. That main event is helped by a strong video package and commentary that frames Lashley as a legitimate athletic equal rather than another challenger waiting for Cena's finish. The crowd also responds to Dusty Rhodes with affection and gives Randy Orton enough heat to make the generational angle work.

The energy falls sharply in the weakest middle-card stretches. Carlito-Sandman never gives the audience the weapon payoff the stipulation suggests, Morrison-Punk struggles to create urgency, and the Khali triple threat forces Batista and Kane to work around a champion with limited mobility. The production remains polished, and the sub-three-hour runtime keeps the event from becoming exhausting. Most importantly, the show knows how to present its main event: the final video package, entrances, crowd split, and respectful aftermath give Cena-Lashley a seriousness missing from much of the undercard.

HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB

Historical Significance earns a B because several developments from this event echo beyond the night itself. Hornswoggle wins the Cruiserweight Championship in one of the strangest title changes of the era, and the championship is retired later in 2007. Dusty Rhodes wrestles his final match, losing to Randy Orton in a Texas Bullrope match before Cody Rhodes makes the save from a post-match attack. That sequence is notable in hindsight because Cody would later join Orton in Legacy. The Great Khali also makes his first pay-per-view defense as World Heavyweight Champion after Edge's injury unexpectedly reshaped the SmackDown title picture.

The main event carries its own long-term significance. John Cena and Bobby Lashley meet in a heavily promoted WWE Championship match that becomes Lashley's final WWE pay-per-view appearance for more than a decade. Lashley would leave the company the following year and not return until 2018, making this match a striking snapshot of a career that seemed interrupted just as it was reaching the top tier. The event is also the first WWE Great American Bash to combine Raw, SmackDown, and ECW. None of those facts make the show essential by themselves, but together they give an otherwise uneven card a surprisingly dense historical footprint.

WHAT AGED WELL
  • John Cena versus Bobby Lashley remains an excellent example of serious main-event presentation and clean heavyweight escalation.
  • Umaga and Jeff Hardy turn a simple power-versus-speed formula into one of WWE's best undercard matches of that summer.
  • MVP and Matt Hardy continue building a rivalry that would become a dependable SmackDown highlight.
  • Randy Orton and Dusty Rhodes accomplish the generational story they need without overstaying the match.
  • The hot San Jose crowd materially improves the event's strongest matches.
  • The compact runtime keeps the weak middle of the card from becoming overwhelming.
WHAT AGED POORLY
  • Hornswoggle winning the Cruiserweight Championship turns a serious division title into a comedy device.
  • Carlito versus The Sandman never delivers the weapon payoff its stipulation advertises.
  • Candice Michelle and Melina receive too little time to create a substantial championship match.
  • John Morrison and CM Punk again produce less chemistry than their talent suggests.
  • The Great Khali title match is structured largely around hiding the champion's limitations.
  • Several programs on the card feel like temporary solutions created by injuries and roster movement.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

The review record supports The Great American Bash 2007 as slightly above average with a strong main event and several obvious misses. TJR Wrestling gives the show 6.75 out of 10, rates Cena-Lashley four stars, Umaga-Jeff Hardy three-and-three-quarters, and MVP-Matt Hardy three-and-a-quarter. The same review is much harsher on the weak material, giving Carlito-Sandman half a star, the Khali triple threat one star, and Candice-Melina one-and-a-half. That spread explains why retrospective assessments tend to praise the closing match while remaining lukewarm on the event as a whole.

The final C+ / 6.7 lands there because the advertised main event is also the best match, the crowd treats it like a major attraction, and a second strong undercard peak arrives in Umaga-Jeff Hardy. The lift stays controlled because the card contains three poor matches and several ordinary title defenses. The event is not consistently good enough for a B, but Cena-Lashley's placement and execution matter more than a simple arithmetic average would suggest.

RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
20 sources

These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

  1. TJR WrestlingFull Great American Bash 2007 review with match ratings and 6.75/10 event score
  2. 411ManiaContemporary Great American Bash 2007 live report with match grades
  3. 411ManiaRetrospective Great American Bash 2007 complete-show review
  4. 411ManiaGreat American Bash 2007 match ranking and retrospective context
  5. 411ManiaGreat American Bash 2007 preview and feud analysis
  6. WhatCulture2007 WWE pay-per-view ranking including The Great American Bash
  7. Seanomaniac Wrestling ReviewsRetrospective Great American Bash 2007 review
  8. CAGEMATCHExact Great American Bash 2007 event identity and community rating record
  9. DVD TalkGreat American Bash 2007 DVD review
  10. Inside PulseGreat American Bash 2007 DVD review with match-level discussion
  11. Feeds.NewsGreat American Bash 2007 retrospective with Cena-Lashley focus
  12. SwapADVdGreat American Bash 2007 DVD user-review context
  13. WhatCultureAll-time Great American Bash match ranking including Cena-Lashley
  14. 411ManiaAll-time Great American Bash top-five match discussion including Cena-Lashley
  15. PWTorchContemporary Great American Bash 2007 virtual-time report
  16. WWEOfficial Great American Bash 2007 results and event identity
  17. IMDbDetailed Great American Bash 2007 user review
  18. IMDbGreat American Bash 2007 user-review collection
  19. MetacriticRaw fallout episode review context following Great American Bash 2007
  20. PlexGreat American Bash 2007 event listing and runtime context
WHERE TO WATCH

Stream This Event

Checked August 25, 2026STATUS
No confirmed full-event stream

Netflix's public WWE Great American Bash page currently begins with the 2008 event and does not verify an exact 2007 replay. No current complete United States replay of The Great American Bash 2007 is claimed.

WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.