WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

Crown Jewel 2023: Drew McIntyre Starts Cracking While Roman Reigns Keeps Winning the Same Way

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

WWENovember 4, 2023Mohammed Abdo Arena
THE WRESTLEGRADEC+6.9 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#738OF 1030
PROMOTION
World Wrestling Entertainment
DATE
November 4, 2023
VENUE
Mohammed Abdo Arena
LOCATION
Riyadh, Riyadh
ATTENDANCE
9,109
EVENT TYPE
PLE
THE FILE

Crown Jewel 2023 is a show of important consequences trapped inside a merely decent card. Drew McIntyre loses cleanly to Seth "Freakin" Rollins and leaves before Damian Priest can try to cash in. Logan Paul wins his first WWE championship with brass knuckles. Kairi Sane returns to help IYO SKY. Solo Sikoa beats John Cena so decisively that the finish feels like an attempt to manufacture a new monster in one afternoon. Roman Reigns then retains against LA Knight with help from Jimmy Uso, because by late 2023 even the surprises around a Reigns defense have become familiar.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

The opener is the event's best wrestling. Rollins and McIntyre work a patient heavyweight title match that treats Drew as an equal without making the championship change feel necessary. The Claymore near fall is excellent, Rollins' finishing run is decisive, and McIntyre's quiet exit becomes more interesting once his frustration turns darker over the following weeks.

The middle of the card is professional without becoming memorable. Rhea Ripley's five-way is organized chaos, Solo-Cena tells a useful story with blunt force, Logan Paul and Rey Mysterio produce the most athletic singles match outside the opener, and Cody Rhodes-Damian Priest feels like a very good Raw main event imported into Riyadh. IYO SKY and Bianca Belair have too much interference to reach their ceiling, even though Kairi Sane's return matters immediately.

The main event has the loudest crowd and the most repetitive structure. LA Knight gets the near fall that briefly convinces the building, Jimmy Uso saves Roman, and Reigns eventually Spears his way out. It is good wrestling attached to a finish viewers have learned to anticipate before it happens.

WrestleFile lands at C+ / 6.9. Crown Jewel 2023 has no disastrous main-card match and one very good opener, but too many bouts settle into the same competent middle. The aftermath is more interesting than the event itself.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

Crown Jewel 2023 took place on November 4, 2023, at Mohammed Abdo Arena in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. WrestleTix estimated 9,109 tickets distributed for a configuration that was sold out. Seven matches aired on the premium event, while Sami Zayn versus JD McDonagh took place on the Kickoff show.

Roman Reigns defended the Undisputed WWE Universal Championship against LA Knight after Knight's rapid rise from popular midcard act to one of WWE's loudest crowd favorites. Seth "Freakin" Rollins defended the World Heavyweight Championship against Drew McIntyre in an opener built around Drew wanting the champion healthy enough that no excuses could follow.

Rhea Ripley defended the Women's World Championship in a five-way against Nia Jax, Raquel Rodriguez, Shayna Baszler and Zoey Stark. Rey Mysterio defended the United States Championship against Logan Paul, while IYO SKY defended the WWE Women's Championship against Bianca Belair. Cody Rhodes also continued his feud with The Judgment Day against Damian Priest.

John Cena's match with Solo Sikoa carried a different kind of pressure. Cena had openly discussed his lack of televised singles victories and hinted at retirement, giving Solo the chance to gain more from one decisive win than he could from weeks of ordinary victories.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • Seth "Freakin" Rollins vs. Drew McIntyre — World Heavyweight Championship
  • Logan Paul vs. Rey Mysterio — United States Championship
  • Roman Reigns vs. LA Knight — Undisputed WWE Universal Championship
SKIM
  • Rhea Ripley vs. Nia Jax vs. Raquel Rodriguez vs. Shayna Baszler vs. Zoey Stark — Women's World Championship
  • Solo Sikoa vs. John Cena
  • IYO SKY vs. Bianca Belair — WWE Women's Championship
  • Cody Rhodes vs. Damian Priest
  • Kairi Sane's return after IYO SKY vs. Bianca Belair
SKIP
  • Sami Zayn vs. JD McDonagh — Kickoff pre-show is outside the graded card
MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

The Card, On the Record

01Seth "Freakin" Rollins def. Drew McIntyre — World Heavyweight ChampionshipB+

McIntyre enters with a useful promise: he wants Rollins healthy enough that nobody can excuse the result. That strips the match of outside-story noise and lets the two wrestlers build around Drew's power against Seth's speed and accumulated damage. The opening minutes are patient rather than frantic.

McIntyre catches dives, throws Rollins with the overhead suplex and repeatedly forces the champion to create offense from disadvantage. Rollins answers with the Pedigree, but Drew's Claymore near fall is the match's peak because it comes close enough to make a title change feel possible without requiring it. The crowd responds accordingly.

Rollins escapes the next Claymore, lands the superkick, Pedigree and Stomp, and wins cleanly. Drew does not attack him afterward; he simply leaves. That restraint becomes more valuable once McIntyre's bitterness develops over the following weeks.

The best match on the card and a strong chapter in Drew's slow turn.

VERDICT

A very good heavyweight title match whose clean finish becomes more important once Drew McIntyre's frustration starts changing him.

02Rhea Ripley def. Nia Jax, Raquel Rodriguez, Shayna Baszler & Zoey Stark — Women's World ChampionshipC+

The five-way works best when it accepts that organization is impossible and gives each challenger a short window to matter. Nia Jax supplies mass, Raquel Rodriguez provides the closest power match for Ripley, Shayna Baszler brings submissions and Zoey Stark provides speed. The rotation keeps the match moving without making any one challenger feel particularly close to winning.

Ripley spends enough time displaced from the center that the others can create combinations, then returns whenever the match needs a focal point. The final avalanche Riptide onto the pile is the correct kind of excessive finish for a five-person title defense. It gives Ripley a decisive visual without requiring her to dominate everyone individually.

The match is entertaining in bursts and forgettable as a larger championship story. Ripley feels important throughout; the challengers mostly feel temporary.

VERDICT

A functional multi-person showcase with a strong finishing visual and little genuine suspense around Rhea Ripley's title.

03Solo Sikoa def. John CenaC

Cena approaches the match like a veteran trying to solve one weapon. He attacks Solo's right arm because the Samoan Spike is the danger, which gives the first half a simple and useful piece of psychology. Solo responds by turning the match into a physical grind.

Cena eventually reaches the familiar comeback and briefly has the crowd believing the story may become inspirational. Solo refuses that direction. He lands the Spike, then another, then keeps hitting it until Cena is no longer participating in a competitive match so much as surviving a public dismantling.

That is the point. The match is average as wrestling and effective as elevation. Cena's post-match ovation supplies the emotion the bell-to-bell work lacks.

VERDICT

A deliberately one-sided closing stretch that gives Solo Sikoa the biggest singles win of his career at the expense of competitive drama.

04Logan Paul def. Rey Mysterio — United States ChampionshipB-

Paul continues doing the irritating thing where a celebrity wrestler looks far more comfortable than the category should allow. Rey gives him an ideal opponent because Mysterio can create movement around Paul's size, catch mistakes and make every athletic counter look like part of a wrestling match rather than a rehearsed stunt. Their timing is strong from the beginning.

Paul's Buckshot Lariat and moonsault fallaway slam give him offense that feels distinct, while Rey's pace prevents the match from becoming a showcase entirely built around Paul's highlights. One particularly dangerous springboard sequence is rescued cleanly, which says something about how quickly Paul has developed situational awareness. The crowd gradually buys into the title change possibility.

The brass knuckles decide it after Santos Escobar inadvertently leaves them behind. Paul catches Rey with the loaded punch and wins his first WWE championship. The finish is cheap, useful and completely appropriate for the character.

A good title match with a memorable result.

VERDICT

A good, athletic title change that uses Logan Paul's heel shortcuts without hiding how naturally he has adapted to WWE's style.

05IYO SKY def. Bianca Belair — WWE Women's ChampionshipC+

IYO SKY and Bianca Belair are capable of wrestling a cleaner and more ambitious championship match than this one becomes. The athletic exchanges are sharp, Belair's power gives IYO natural obstacles to solve and the champion's movement keeps the pace from stalling. Then the match increasingly becomes about who is standing outside it.

Bayley distracts the referee at a critical moment, which already pushes the finish toward familiar Damage CTRL territory. The larger surprise arrives when Kairi Sane returns and attacks Belair, allowing IYO to hit Over the Moonsault and retain. The crowd is processing the return as much as the finish.

Kairi's appearance is historically useful and immediately changes the faction. The cost is that another IYO title defense ends with someone else doing the decisive work. The angle wins; the match settles for good.

VERDICT

A good match redirected into a major Damage CTRL angle, with Kairi Sane's return overshadowing the championship wrestling.

06Cody Rhodes def. Damian PriestC+

Cody and Priest wrestle a match that feels professionally assembled from pieces viewers have already seen throughout the Judgment Day feud. Priest controls with size, Cody rallies, and the expected parade of Bálor, McDonagh and Dominik arrives when the result needs complication. The work is clean and the structure is familiar.

Jey Uso neutralizes the interference with superkicks and a chair, leaving the two actual wrestlers to finish the match. Cody then strings together the Cody Cutter, Bionic Elbow and three Cross Rhodes for a decisive pin. The crowd reacts, but the whole sequence feels more like weekly-story maintenance than a destination.

Both men will reach much larger places within months. Here they are still stuck inside the Judgment Day traffic jam.

VERDICT

A solid Cody Rhodes win buried inside familiar Judgment Day interference and more useful as storyline maintenance than major-event wrestling.

07Roman Reigns def. LA Knight — Undisputed WWE Universal ChampionshipB-

LA Knight's greatest asset is the crowd's willingness to believe with him. Reigns controls much of the early pace, but every Knight comeback produces a reaction large enough to make the challenger feel more dangerous than his résumé says he should be. The match does not need technical novelty because the audience supplies urgency.

Knight survives a Spear, fights out of the guillotine and lands BFT near the ropes. For a moment the building has the exact near fall it came to see. Jimmy Uso puts Roman's foot on the rope, and the match enters territory every regular viewer recognizes.

Knight attacks Jimmy and briefly looks defiant enough to overcome the numbers, but Reigns Spears him through the barricade and again in the ring to retain. The work is good, the heat is excellent and the finish is a rerun.

That contradiction defines late-2023 Roman Reigns matches. The champion still feels enormous. The path to keeping him champion increasingly feels predetermined.

VERDICT

A hot, well-worked main event limited by another Bloodline-assisted finish that viewers can see coming before LA Knight does.

BOOKING VERDICTB-

Rollins retaining is the right decision because McIntyre benefits more from the loss than he would from a sudden title reign. Drew loses without interference, leaves frustrated, and begins sliding toward the resentment that eventually puts him alongside The Judgment Day at Survivor Series. The clean defeat gives that turn a grievance rather than an excuse.

Solo Sikoa beating John Cena is the boldest choice on the card. The repeated Samoan Spikes are not designed to create suspense; they are designed to make the audience watch Cena get overwhelmed. The match succeeds as an attempt to give Solo a defining singles victory, even if his later booking does not always preserve the same aura.

Logan Paul winning the United States Championship also makes sense. The brass-knuckles finish fits the character, Rey Mysterio can lose without being diminished, and the title gives Paul a reason to remain connected to weekly television despite a limited schedule. Santos Escobar leaving the weapon behind also feeds directly into his split from the Latino World Order.

Kairi Sane's return is useful, but the IYO SKY-Bianca Belair finish adds another layer of interference to a championship program that already leans heavily on Damage CTRL. The return matters more than the match result.

Reigns retaining is never the problem by itself. The issue is the mechanism. Jimmy Uso once again saves him after the challenger appears to have the match won. The Bloodline formula remains effective with the live crowd, but repetition has begun to make the champion feel less unpredictable.

CROWD & PRESENTATIONB-

Riyadh reacts like a major-event crowd for the biggest names and drifts during several stretches between them. Rollins receives the familiar singalong entrance, Cena gets the emotional star response, and LA Knight turns the main event into the loudest match of the night. The building is far less committed to some of the middle-card wrestling.

The opener benefits from clean presentation. Rollins and McIntyre receive time, championship introductions and enough room to make the World Heavyweight Championship feel important without relying on spectacle outside the ring. The Claymore near fall lands because the match has not exhausted the audience with false finishes beforehand.

The women's five-way is visually busy but readable. Ripley's avalanche Riptide onto the pile gives the match a memorable ending and keeps her dominance intact while allowing the challengers to spend most of the match colliding with one another. The structure is more efficient than elegant.

Cena's post-match ovation is one of the show's strongest pieces of presentation. The repeated Samoan Spikes leave him looking defeated in a way WWE had rarely shown, and the long walk out lets the crowd supply the emotion. No speech is needed.

The main event again exposes the difference between crowd heat and freshness. Knight is enormously over, and every comeback sounds important, but the interference arrives with such familiar timing that viewers watching the larger Reigns title run can feel the pattern before the audience in the building stops believing.

HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB-

The most important long-term development is Drew McIntyre's loss. He does not turn immediately, but Crown Jewel becomes another entry in his growing case against a roster he believes has repeatedly benefited from forgiveness and opportunity he did not receive. That resentment leads toward his alliance of convenience with The Judgment Day and, eventually, one of the best character reinventions of his career.

Logan Paul's United States Championship victory is historically significant in a more straightforward way. It is his first championship in WWE and establishes that the company is willing to make a part-time celebrity attraction part of a regular title picture. His reign becomes a major component of SmackDown heading into WrestleMania XL.

Kairi Sane's return reshapes Damage CTRL. Her arrival initially appears threatening to Bayley, then becomes part of the group's expansion before Asuka joins and Bayley is gradually pushed outside the circle. That story ultimately leads to Bayley winning the 2024 Royal Rumble and challenging IYO SKY at WrestleMania XL.

Solo Sikoa's victory over Cena is one of the strongest singles wins of Solo's early main-roster run. The repeated Samoan Spikes are designed to mark him as a killer, and WWE continues referencing the win as proof of his danger. Its historical value lies more in presentation than match quality.

The show also became the final WWE event officially distributed on DVD in Europe and the penultimate such release in the United States. Crown Jewel therefore sits near the end of WWE's physical-media era while several of its stories point directly toward the next WrestleMania cycle.

WHAT AGED WELL
  • Rollins-McIntyre has aged best because the loss becomes part of Drew's story rather than a dead end. His refusal to make excuses, his immediate departure and the frustration that follows all read more clearly once the heel turn develops. The match itself remains the cleanest piece of wrestling on the show.
  • Logan Paul and Rey Mysterio also hold up well. Paul looks increasingly natural in WWE's style, catches Rey cleanly on a dangerous springboard moment and works heel shortcuts into a match built around athletic exchanges. The brass-knuckles finish is cheap by design and useful for both men afterward.
  • Kairi Sane's return gains value from everything Damage CTRL does next. The initial confusion around Bayley becomes important, and the faction's expansion eventually creates one of SmackDown's central women's stories. The return is more consequential than the match that contains it.
  • Cena's willingness to be destroyed by Solo also deserves credit. The finish gives the younger wrestler a visual no competitive fifteen-minute decision could match. Even if Solo's later trajectory becomes uneven, this remains one of the clearest nights WWE tried to elevate him.
  • The show is also easier to revisit when the Kickoff match is omitted. Seven main-card matches over a little more than three hours is manageable by modern standards, even when several bouts settle into the middle.
WHAT AGED POORLY
  • The Reigns interference formula has aged worst. Jimmy Uso saving Roman after LA Knight's BFT is mechanically effective and narratively exhausted. By this point, another challenger appearing to have Reigns beaten before Bloodline interference no longer feels like escalation.
  • IYO SKY versus Bianca Belair also suffers from the same broader issue in miniature. The wrestling is capable of carrying a cleaner championship match, but Bayley's distraction and Kairi's interference make the title defense feel like an angle delivery system. The return is memorable; the match is not.
  • Cody Rhodes versus Damian Priest feels particularly transitional now. Both men eventually become world champions, yet here they are trapped in a Judgment Day interference loop with Jey Uso running in to neutralize the expected helpers. The match is competent and instantly overshadowed by what both wrestlers later become.
  • The five-way also looks more disposable with distance. Ripley is the obvious focal point, the challengers rarely feel like individual threats, and the match exists mainly to give the champion a dramatic multi-person retention. The avalanche Riptide remains the one lasting image.
  • Crown Jewel's 2023 Wrestling Observer award for Worst Major Wrestling Show also captures how unusually high WWE's floor had become that year. The show is not awful in isolation. It looks weaker because the company's other major events were routinely better.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

Long-term audience response is modest. Cagematch lists Crown Jewel 2023 at 5.93 from 281 valid votes. Seth Rollins versus Drew McIntyre leads the match guide at 7.96, followed by Logan Paul-Rey Mysterio at 6.72, Roman Reigns-LA Knight at 6.53, IYO SKY-Bianca Belair at 6.26, Cody Rhodes-Damian Priest at 6.14, the women's five-way at 5.85 and Solo Sikoa-John Cena at 5.14.

John Canton scores the complete event 7.5/10, calling it a pretty good show without a match-of-the-year contender and naming Rollins-McIntyre the best match. He also notes the repeated interference finishes in the Paul-Mysterio, IYO SKY-Belair and Reigns-Knight matches.

Reported Wrestling Observer ratings are warmer on several individual matches, led by Rollins-McIntyre at four-and-a-half stars. The same publication's year-end voting later named Crown Jewel the Worst Major Wrestling Show of 2023. Those two facts fit the event's strange reputation: individual work is often competent or better, while the full show leaves comparatively little behind.

The C+ / 6.9 verdict reflects that divide. Crown Jewel has one very good match, several solid matches and multiple storyline developments that become important, but the card rarely creates the feeling that a major event is doing something unavailable on weekly television.

RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
20 sources

These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

  1. WWE — Complete Crown Jewel 2023 resultsOfficial results, title changes, returns and main-event finish.
  2. WWE — Crown Jewel 2023 event hubOfficial match card and event archive.
  3. WWE — Roman Reigns vs. LA KnightOfficial Undisputed WWE Universal Championship match context.
  4. TJR Wrestling — Crown Jewel 2023 ReviewComplete review, match ratings and 7.5/10 event score.
  5. TJR Wrestling — Crown Jewel 2023 Observer ratingsReported Wrestling Observer match ratings.
  6. 411Mania — Hall's Crown Jewel 2023 ReviewIndependent complete-event review.
  7. 411Mania — Slimmer's Crown Jewel 2023 ReviewAdditional independent match-by-match assessment.
  8. Bleacher Report — Crown Jewel 2023 ResultsContemporary live grades and reaction.
  9. Pro Wrestling Dot Net — Crown Jewel 2023 poll resultsReader overall grade and best-match voting.
  10. Pro Wrestling Dot Net — Crown Jewel 2023 live reviewDetailed contemporary match-by-match review.
  11. POST Wrestling — Crown Jewel 2023 coverageContemporary event and aftermath discussion.
  12. Wrestling Republic — Crown Jewel 2023 ReviewAdditional independent full-show assessment.
  13. WhatCulture — Crown Jewel 2023 Ups & DownsContemporary critique of strengths and weaknesses.
  14. Cagematch — WWE Crown Jewel 2023Event identity, rating and match-guide ratings.
  15. Cagematch — Crown Jewel 2023 card with guideMatch-guide and historical rating cross-check.
  16. Cagematch — Crown Jewel 2023 KickoffSami Zayn-JD McDonagh Kickoff match cross-check.
  17. Wrestlenomics/WrestleTix — Crown Jewel 2023 ticketsEstimated tickets distributed and sold-out configuration.
  18. The SmackDown Hotel — Crown Jewel 2023Card and result cross-check.
  19. Wikipedia — Crown Jewel (2023)Date, venue, card, aftermath and physical-media historical cross-check.
  20. Netflix — WWE Crown JewelCurrent Crown Jewel collection page.
WHERE TO WATCH

Stream This Event

Checked August 16, 20261 OPTION
Availability may vary by country and account

Netflix - WWE Crown Jewel collection

Watch on NetflixNetflix maintains a WWE Crown Jewel page, but the public U.S. listing currently identifies the 2024 event rather than confirming the 2023 edition.

Availability varies by country and can change.

WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.