WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

Clash of Champions 2016: Good Wrestling Trapped Inside Frustrating Booking

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

WWESeptember 25, 2016Bankers Life Fieldhouse
THE WRESTLEGRADEC+6.7 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#767OF 1015
PROMOTION
World Wrestling Entertainment
DATE
September 25, 2016
VENUE
Bankers Life Fieldhouse
LOCATION
Indianapolis, Indiana
ATTENDANCE
13,467
EVENT TYPE
PPV
THE FILE

Clash of Champions 2016 has enough good wrestling to avoid being a bad show, but too many finishes leave the audience arguing with the booking instead of celebrating the matches. Cesaro and Sheamus produce the clear in-ring peak in the seventh bout of their series, Chris Jericho and Sami Zayn work a lively grudge match, and the Raw Women's Championship triple threat gives Charlotte, Sasha Banks, and Bayley a substantial showcase. Even the weaker title matches usually contain competent stretches. The problem is that several bouts end in ways that drain rather than amplify what came before them.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

That pattern reaches the main event. Kevin Owens and Seth Rollins build a credible Universal Championship match before Chris Jericho's interference, a referee bump, a missed Pedigree pin, and Stephanie McMahon's appearance turn the finish into another layer of story machinery. Cesaro-Sheamus suffers an even stranger fate when a hard, excellent match ends without a winner. WrestleFile lands at C+, 6.7 out of 10: a watchable first Raw-exclusive pay-per-view of the new brand split whose strongest wrestling repeatedly has to fight through booking that refuses to let the night breathe.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

Clash of Champions 2016 took place on September 25, 2016, at Bankers Life Fieldhouse in Indianapolis, Indiana, with 13,467 in attendance. The event replaced Night of Champions on WWE's calendar and became the first Raw-exclusive pay-per-view after the company restored the brand split in July. Its premise carried over the old Night of Champions idea: every active championship assigned to Raw was defended. Kevin Owens entered as the Universal Champion after Triple H helped him win the vacant title on Raw, Charlotte held the Raw Women's Championship, The New Day carried the Raw Tag Team Championship, Rusev held the United States Championship, and T.J. Perkins arrived as the newly crowned Cruiserweight Champion after winning the Cruiserweight Classic.

One Kickoff match, Nia Jax against Alicia Fox, is excluded from the WrestleFile match average. The seven pay-per-view matches were The New Day against Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson; Perkins against Brian Kendrick; Cesaro against Sheamus in the final match of their best-of-seven series; Chris Jericho against Sami Zayn; Charlotte against Sasha Banks and Bayley; Rusev against Roman Reigns; and Owens against Seth Rollins. The New Day, Perkins, Charlotte, and Owens retained their championships, while Reigns won the United States Championship. Cesaro-Sheamus ended without a winner after ringside doctors stopped the match, giving the card its most controversial non-finish and setting up the unlikely tag team that followed.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • Cesaro vs. Sheamus — No Contest — Best of Seven Series Match No. 7
  • Chris Jericho def. Sami Zayn
  • Charlotte (c) def. Sasha Banks and Bayley — Raw Women's Championship Triple Threat Match
SKIM
  • Roman Reigns def. Rusev (c) — United States Championship
  • Kevin Owens (c) def. Seth Rollins — Universal Championship
  • T.J. Perkins (c) def. Brian Kendrick — Cruiserweight Championship
SKIP
  • The New Day (Big E & Kofi Kingston) (c) def. Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson — Raw Tag Team Championship
MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

The Card, On the Record

01The New Day (Big E & Kofi Kingston) (c) def. Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson — Raw Tag Team ChampionshipC-

Gallows and Anderson attack with urgency and briefly make the opener feel like a needed reset for their stalled rivalry with The New Day. Their early control is direct, and Kofi Kingston sells the isolation well enough to give Big E's eventual involvement some momentum. The match never has time to grow much beyond that basic structure. Xavier Woods' trombone shot to Anderson while the referee is distracted leads directly to Midnight Hour and another New Day retention. The finish fits the champions' mischievous act, but it also makes Gallows and Anderson look foolish after weeks of trying to become serious threats. At under seven minutes, the bout is energetic without becoming memorable, and the interference matters more than any sustained in-ring sequence.

VERDICT

A brisk opener with competent tag work, but another shortcut finish keeps Gallows and Anderson from feeling like credible championship threats.

02T.J. Perkins (c) def. Brian Kendrick — Cruiserweight ChampionshipC

T.J. Perkins' first pay-per-view Cruiserweight Championship defense has an interesting veteran-versus-new-star idea, but the match feels more deliberate than explosive. Kendrick grounds Perkins, attacks openings, and wrestles like someone willing to use every veteran shortcut available to reclaim relevance. Perkins answers with quicker counters and enough athletic bursts to show why the Cruiserweight Classic had made the division feel fresh. The closing kneebar gives the champion a clean submission victory and protects the title's sporting presentation. Kendrick's post-match handshake turning into a headbutt is more memorable than much of the bout itself, because it immediately clarifies the rematch story. Solid technique and clear roles are present; the electricity expected from the new division is not yet fully there.

VERDICT

A sound first pay-per-view defense for Perkins that establishes Kendrick's desperation more effectively than it showcases the revived division's ceiling.

03Cesaro vs. Sheamus — No Contest — Best of Seven Series Match No. 7B+

Cesaro and Sheamus wrestle as though six previous matches have removed any reason to pace themselves. The offense is stiff, the counters feel earned from familiarity, and every late exchange carries the logic of two men who know the other's normal answers. Cesaro's dive ending with a frightening landing, followed by the barricade spill that leaves both men battered, pushes the match from athletic competition into genuine danger. That physical commitment makes the medical stoppage understandable in isolation. As the advertised seventh match of a tied series, however, a no contest is a brutal denial of payoff. The wrestling is comfortably the best on the card and nearly excellent enough to overcome the decision, but the ending changes the final emotion from exhilaration to frustration.

VERDICT

The night's best match by a wide margin, with outstanding physical escalation sabotaged by a no-contest finish to a series that promised a winner.

04Chris Jericho def. Sami ZaynC+

Jericho and Zayn give the middle of the card a needed dose of speed and personality. Zayn attacks with the urgency of someone trying to punish the man who embarrassed him on the Highlight Reel, while Jericho keeps interrupting that rhythm with veteran timing and increasingly smug counters. The Michinoku Driver, outside DDT, Walls of Jericho escape, and Blue Thunder Bomb create a convincing stretch in which Zayn seems close to finally gaining a major pay-per-view win. Instead, Jericho catches the Helluva Kick attempt and lands the Codebreaker for the pin. The match is clean, coherent, and better structured than several title bouts around it. The lingering issue is direction: Jericho gains momentum for his Owens partnership, while Zayn absorbs another loss when a breakthrough would have felt more valuable.

VERDICT

A lively, well-paced grudge match with a clean finish, even if Jericho's victory reinforces how difficult it was for Zayn to gain traction.

05Charlotte (c) def. Sasha Banks and Bayley — Raw Women's Championship Triple Threat MatchB-

Charlotte, Sasha Banks, and Bayley work a busy triple threat that benefits from having three distinct crowd relationships. Charlotte carries herself like the established champion, Banks brings urgency to regain the title, and Bayley operates as the newcomer trying to prove she belongs immediately. The match avoids long stretches with one wrestler conveniently absent, and the Bank Statement interruptions give the closing half credible submission tension. Dana Brooke's involvement adds another layer without completely swallowing the wrestling. Charlotte eventually boots Bayley into Banks and lands another big boot to pin Bayley, retaining while keeping Sasha from taking the fall. It is a strong television-era triple threat with enough action to satisfy, though the finish leaves Bayley feeling more like an added obstacle than an equal challenger.

VERDICT

A good three-way title match that showcases Raw's women's depth, with Charlotte's retention working better than the decision to make Bayley the fall guy.

06Roman Reigns def. Rusev (c) — United States ChampionshipC

Reigns and Rusev settle into a heavyweight title match that improves once the crowd accepts its slower opening pace. Rusev's control work gives Reigns something substantial to fight through, and the challenger responds with the familiar power offense that produces louder reactions as the match advances. Lana pulling the referee from the ring after a Spear creates the expected interference beat and gets her ejected, allowing the final stretch to return to the wrestlers. Rusev's kick and Accolade tease a successful defense before Reigns escapes and lands the decisive Spear. The title change is clean enough once Lana is removed, and both men work hard for more than seventeen minutes. The bout is sturdy rather than special, with a length that occasionally exposes how limited the dramatic variety can become.

VERDICT

A respectable power match and sensible title change that gains momentum late but never quite justifies its extended runtime.

07Kevin Owens (c) def. Seth Rollins — Universal ChampionshipC

Owens and Rollins have the pieces of a stronger main event before the finish becomes crowded. Owens targets Rollins' vulnerable body and knee, Rollins rallies with athletic counters, and the Spanish announce-table crash gives the match a natural escalation point. Then Chris Jericho arrives, the referee is knocked down, Rollins hits a Pedigree with nobody available to count, and the challenger has to fight both men while waiting for a replacement official. Stephanie McMahon sending that referee adds another visual without resolving the underlying chaos. Owens finally lands the Pop-up Powerbomb and retains, which is the correct championship outcome, but the route there makes the champion feel secondary to interference and authority intrigue. Good work survives underneath the machinery; the main event never gets to own its finish.

VERDICT

A capable Universal Championship match whose overbooked closing sequence turns a sound Owens retention into another argument about Raw's surrounding storylines.

BOOKING VERDICTC-

The Booking Verdict earns a C- because the show repeatedly chooses continuation over payoff. Roman Reigns beating Rusev for the United States Championship is a clean, useful title change, and keeping Kevin Owens champion is the right long-term direction so soon after his Universal Championship win. Charlotte retaining also protects the champion while keeping Sasha Banks and Bayley available for future programs. The New Day and T.J. Perkins retaining are sensible results. None of those decisions is inherently damaging, and several preserve stories that still had room to develop on weekly television.

The trouble is in how WWE reaches too many of those destinations. Cesaro and Sheamus spend nearly seventeen minutes escalating a violent series finale only for the doctors to declare a no contest, producing neither a series winner nor the catharsis the seventh match promised. Jericho beating Zayn is defensible for Jericho's Owens alliance but another setback for Zayn. The women's triple threat leaves Bayley feeling secondary only weeks after her main-roster arrival. Then Jericho's interference and a referee bump overwhelm Owens-Rollins. The card does not collapse because of its winners; it loses points because major matches so often feel designed to extend television rather than finish pay-per-view stories.

CROWD & PRESENTATIONC+

Crowd and Presentation earns a C+ because Indianapolis gives the better matches enough energy, but the show rarely develops the atmosphere of a major event. The arena responds strongly to Cesaro's comeback against Sheamus, reacts to the physical danger of their ringside spill, and stays invested in Jericho-Zayn's faster exchanges. Charlotte, Sasha Banks, and Bayley receive the kind of recognition expected from three central figures in Raw's women's division, while Roman Reigns and Rusev generate the louder, more polarized reaction that followed Reigns through this era. The championship-heavy format at least gives the card a clear visual identity.

Presentation is also where the event feels most like an extended episode of Raw. The stage and broadcast are polished, but the pacing does not build toward a singular crescendo, and multiple finishes ask the crowd to process storyline complications instead of celebrate decisive outcomes. Cesaro-Sheamus creates the night's strongest organic intensity, only to end with medical stoppage confusion. Owens-Rollins has main-event scale until the referee bump and Jericho involvement take over. The crowd remains responsive, yet the closing minutes never reach the emotional clarity of the best pay-per-views. It is professionally produced and periodically hot, but rarely electric from one segment to the next.

HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB-

Historical Significance earns a B-minus because Clash of Champions 2016 marks an important structural moment for WWE even though the individual show is not remembered as a classic. It is the inaugural Clash of Champions, the successor to Night of Champions, and the first Raw-exclusive pay-per-view of the second brand-split era. T.J. Perkins makes the first pay-per-view defense of the revived Cruiserweight Championship, Kevin Owens makes his first Universal Championship pay-per-view defense, and Roman Reigns begins a United States Championship reign. The card therefore documents WWE rebuilding distinct title ecosystems for Raw only two months after separating the rosters again.

The most enduring consequence comes from the match that technically has no winner. The Cesaro-Sheamus best-of-seven series ends 3-3 after their seventh bout is stopped, leading Mick Foley to pair them as a tag team instead of naming a superior singles wrestler. That compromise becomes one of Raw's defining teams of the next several years, eventually known as The Bar and responsible for multiple championship reigns. Owens' partnership with Jericho also grows more central through the main-event interference, while Charlotte's pay-per-view championship dominance continues. Clash of Champions matters less because of one historic match than because several ongoing pieces of the late-2016 Raw identity are visible taking shape.

WHAT AGED WELL
  • Cesaro and Sheamus treating the best-of-seven finale like a fight rather than another series installment.
  • The early chemistry among Charlotte, Sasha Banks, and Bayley before their Raw title stories separated.
  • Kevin Owens and Chris Jericho's partnership becoming increasingly central to Raw's main-event direction.
  • The revived Cruiserweight Championship receiving a dedicated pay-per-view title defense.
WHAT AGED POORLY
  • The Cesaro-Sheamus no contest denying the advertised best-of-seven series a decisive winner.
  • The Owens-Rollins main event becoming dominated by interference and referee chaos.
  • Sami Zayn taking another prominent pay-per-view loss while still searching for momentum.
  • A championship-heavy concept that often feels more like a long Raw than a distinct premium event.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

The contemporary critical record is unusually consistent about the central problem. TJR Wrestling scored Clash of Champions 7 out of 10 and praised the wrestling while calling several booking choices baffling. Larry Csonka's 411Mania review landed at 6.0, Kevin Pantoja's 411Mania review at 5.0, and Cageside Seats later graded the show C-. Sportskeeda was more generous at roughly a B+ level, but even that review repeatedly noted strong matches being weakened by their endings. Across those reactions, Cesaro-Sheamus stands out most often as the match of the night, with the women's triple threat and Jericho-Zayn usually forming the next tier.

The final C+ / 6.7 treats the match quality as broadly representative of the complete show, with only a small amount of additional event-level context. That event-level context includes the inaugural event's brand-split setting, five championship defenses, Roman Reigns' title change, and the long-term importance of pairing Cesaro and Sheamus after their unresolved series. Its impact remains limited because historical relevance cannot erase the immediate viewing experience: the strongest match has no winner, the main event becomes overbooked, and too many results feel like setup for Raw. The event is respectable wrestling undermined by its own decision-making.

RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
20 sources

These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

  1. Bleacher ReportClash of Champions 2016 results, winners, grades, reaction, and highlights
  2. Bleacher ReportClash of Champions 2016 review of major highlights and low points
  3. Bleacher ReportClash of Champions 2016 match-by-match power ranking
  4. TJR WrestlingJohn Canton complete-show review and match ratings for Clash of Champions 2016
  5. 411ManiaLarry Csonka complete-show review and match ratings for Clash of Champions 2016
  6. 411ManiaKevin Pantoja complete-show review of Clash of Champions 2016
  7. SportskeedaClash of Champions 2016 match analysis and grading
  8. FOX SportsClash of Champions 2016 match-by-match grading
  9. FanSidedClash of Champions 2016 review and match grades
  10. IWNerdWrestling Observer star ratings for Clash of Champions 2016
  11. CAGEMATCHClash of Champions 2016 ratings and canonical event identity
  12. IMDbClash of Champions 2016 audience-review context
  13. VAVEL USAClash of Champions 2016 contemporary review
  14. WhatCultureClash of Champions 2016 strengths-and-weaknesses retrospective
  15. WhatCulture2016 WWE pay-per-view ranking context including Clash of Champions
  16. Cageside SeatsClash of Champions 2016 live results and contemporary reaction
  17. Cageside Seats2016 WWE pay-per-view grading context including Clash of Champions
  18. Bleacher ReportClash of Champions 2016 live social-media reaction
  19. Smark Out MomentClash of Champions 2016 recap and review
  20. WWEOfficial Clash of Champions 2016 results and canonical event identity
WHERE TO WATCH

Stream This Event

Checked August 26, 2026STATUS
No confirmed full-event stream

Netflix title 81930357 is associated with the Clash of Champions collection, but the public title page does not expose enough event-specific detail to certify that the exact 2016 full-event replay is currently playable in the United States. No current exact provider is claimed.

WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.