WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

Battleground 2013: The Rhodes Family Saves a Bad Debut

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

WWEOctober 6, 2013First Niagara Center
THE WRESTLEGRADEC-5.8 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#898OF 1015
PROMOTION
World Wrestling Entertainment
DATE
October 6, 2013
VENUE
First Niagara Center
LOCATION
Buffalo, New York
ATTENDANCE
11,700
EVENT TYPE
PPV
THE FILE

Battleground 2013 is a weak inaugural event rescued by one excellent Rhodes family tag match and a solid Hardcore opener. Cody Rhodes and Goldust produce the night's only truly satisfying major payoff, while Alberto Del Rio and Rob Van Dam give the card useful early momentum. The rest of the show ranges from average to forgettable before the vacant WWE Championship main event ends without a winner.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

The event earns a C- because its biggest promised resolution does not happen. Daniel Bryan and Randy Orton wrestle for more than twenty-five minutes only for Big Show to knock out both men and leave the championship vacant, creating an ending widely criticized by contemporary reviewers. The low buyrate and poor reception reinforce the sense that WWE launched Battleground with a show that felt transitional rather than essential.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

Battleground 2013 took place on October 6 at First Niagara Center in Buffalo, New York, with an announced attendance of 11,700. It was the inaugural Battleground pay-per-view and replaced the discontinued Over the Limit name on WWE's calendar. Nine matches were contested overall, with eight airing on pay-per-view after Dolph Ziggler defeated Damien Sandow during the Kickoff pre-show. The event arrived three weeks after Night of Champions and three weeks before Hell in a Cell.

Daniel Bryan and Randy Orton fought for the vacant WWE Championship after Bryan's Night of Champions title win was overturned because referee Scott Armstrong admitted to a fast count. Alberto Del Rio defended the World Heavyweight Championship against Rob Van Dam under Hardcore rules, while Cody Rhodes and Goldust faced The Shield with their WWE jobs and Dusty Rhodes' NXT position at stake. CM Punk continued his feud with Paul Heyman by facing Ryback, AJ Lee defended the Divas Championship against Brie Bella, Curtis Axel defended the Intercontinental Championship against R-Truth, and Bray Wyatt faced Kofi Kingston. The Real Americans also met Santino Marella and The Great Khali in a supporting tag match.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • Alberto Del Rio (c) def. Rob Van Dam by Submission — World Heavyweight Championship Hardcore Match
  • Cody Rhodes & Goldust def. The Shield (Seth Rollins & Roman Reigns) — Tag Team Match
  • Daniel Bryan vs. Randy Orton ended in a No Contest — Vacant WWE Championship Match
SKIM
  • AJ Lee (c) def. Brie Bella — Divas Championship Match
  • Bray Wyatt def. Kofi Kingston — Singles Match
SKIP
  • The Real Americans (Jack Swagger & Antonio Cesaro) def. Santino Marella & The Great Khali — Tag Team Match
  • Curtis Axel (c) def. R-Truth — Intercontinental Championship Match
  • CM Punk def. Ryback — Singles Match
MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

The Card, On the Record

01Alberto Del Rio (c) def. Rob Van Dam by Submission — World Heavyweight Championship Hardcore MatchB

Alberto Del Rio and Rob Van Dam open the pay-per-view with a Hardcore Match that gives the card one of its stronger conventional attractions. Van Dam uses chairs, a ladder and a trash can to create the kind of chaotic environment the stipulation promises, while Del Rio keeps returning to the injured arm and his submission game. Ricardo Rodriguez briefly becomes involved, but the match never loses its focus on the championship. Van Dam survives several dangerous positions and creates late momentum with his aerial offense. Del Rio eventually traps the arm inside a chair and applies the Cross Armbreaker. Van Dam submits, giving Del Rio a decisive retention and a finish that uses the stipulation directly rather than treating the weapons as decoration.

VERDICT

A good hardcore title match with a logical submission finish and enough weapon use to justify the stipulation.

02The Real Americans (Jack Swagger & Antonio Cesaro) def. Santino Marella & The Great Khali — Tag Team MatchC+

The Real Americans against Santino Marella and The Great Khali is a short midcard tag match whose most memorable feature is Antonio Cesaro's strength. Swagger and Cesaro isolate Santino long enough to create a basic control segment, while Khali's size gives the babyface team an obvious comeback route once he enters. The match never develops enough depth for the result to feel especially important. Its defining moment comes when Cesaro gets Khali off his feet and sends him around in the Cesaro Swing. Cesaro follows that visual with the pin to secure the victory. The crowd gets a memorable power spot and the Real Americans get a clean win, but the bout otherwise plays like a compact television attraction on a pay-per-view card.

VERDICT

A functional tag match remembered mainly for Cesaro swinging Khali rather than for its competitive depth.

03Curtis Axel (c) def. R-Truth — Intercontinental Championship MatchC-

Curtis Axel's Intercontinental Championship defense against R-Truth receives enough time to become a real match, but very little about the presentation makes the title feel important. Truth brings the faster offense and earns several brief bursts of crowd support, while Axel works a steady control segment without generating much urgency. The match is technically competent and avoids major mistakes, yet the pacing stays flat for most of its seven-plus minutes. Truth creates one late opening and appears ready to push the champion into a stronger finishing sequence. Axel cuts him off, lands the Hangman's Facebuster and scores the clean pin. The retention is straightforward, but the match does little to elevate Axel, Truth or the Intercontinental Championship beyond their existing television roles.

VERDICT

A competent but flat title defense that reinforces the championship's weak position on the card.

04AJ Lee (c) def. Brie Bella — Divas Championship MatchC

AJ Lee and Brie Bella work a compact Divas Championship match built around Brie's recent non-title victory and the Total Divas conflict surrounding the champion. Brie gets enough offense to make the title opportunity feel legitimate, and AJ repeatedly looks for ways to slow the pace rather than engage in a longer exchange. Tamina Snuka and Nikki Bella remain important at ringside, which keeps the match connected to the broader division story. The finish comes when Tamina distracts Nikki and AJ capitalizes inside the ring. AJ catches Brie with a Schoolboy and scores the pin to retain. The bout is more coherent than spectacular, and the interference keeps the title reign moving while preventing the match from reaching a more satisfying competitive conclusion.

VERDICT

A decent short title defense whose ringside distraction keeps it from becoming a stronger championship match.

05Cody Rhodes & Goldust def. The Shield (Seth Rollins & Roman Reigns) — Tag Team MatchA

Cody Rhodes and Goldust against Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns is the emotional and wrestling high point of Battleground 2013. The stipulation gives every exchange urgency because a Rhodes victory restores Cody's job, while a loss would also cost Goldust and Dusty Rhodes their places in WWE. The Shield controls long stretches through teamwork and power, but Goldust's comeback changes the energy of the match before the finish becomes chaotic around ringside. Dusty neutralizes Dean Ambrose with an elbow, creating the opening his sons need. Cody catches Rollins and lands Cross Rhodes for the pin. The victory delivers the rare completely satisfying payoff on the show and immediately positions the Rhodes family story for the championship program that follows.

VERDICT

A tremendous emotional tag match with clear stakes, strong pacing and the show's most satisfying finish.

06Bray Wyatt def. Kofi Kingston — Singles MatchC+

Bray Wyatt's singles match with Kofi Kingston is designed to establish Wyatt's pay-per-view presence without asking the feud to carry major storyline weight. Kingston's speed creates enough contrast to keep the match moving, while Luke Harper and Erick Rowan at ringside make every escape feel temporary. Wyatt absorbs the faster offense and repeatedly turns the match back toward slower, heavier exchanges. Kingston produces a few credible comeback moments but never fully escapes the sense that he is fighting the entire Wyatt Family environment. Wyatt eventually cuts him off and lands Sister Abigail for the pin. The clean victory is useful for the newer character and the match is solid enough, but it remains a supporting attraction rather than an event-defining program.

VERDICT

A solid showcase for Wyatt that establishes his presence without producing a particularly memorable singles match.

07CM Punk def. Ryback — Singles MatchC

CM Punk and Ryback continue the Paul Heyman rivalry in a match that is more about advancing the feud than producing a satisfying pay-per-view finish. Ryback uses his size to control long stretches, while Punk works underneath and tries to create openings through speed, strikes and counters. The match never fully escapes a methodical rhythm, and Heyman's presence at ringside keeps the focus divided between the wrestlers and the ongoing manager story. Late in the match, Heyman pulls out a kendo stick while the referee is distracted. Punk uses the same distraction to hit Ryback with a low blow. He scores the pin immediately afterward, getting the victory without settling the feud and setting up the rematch inside Hell in a Cell.

VERDICT

A middling feud-advancement match with a protected Punk win but an unsatisfying low-blow finish.

08Daniel Bryan vs. Randy Orton ended in a No Contest — Vacant WWE Championship MatchC-

Daniel Bryan and Randy Orton receive more than twenty-five minutes to settle the vacant WWE Championship, but Battleground ends with the exact kind of unresolved finish the stipulation seems designed to avoid. The wrestling is solid and physical, with both men gradually building toward their signature finishing sequences while the crowd waits for a definitive champion. That investment collapses when Big Show enters and attacks Bryan, referee Scott Armstrong and finally Orton. The match is ruled a no contest, leaving the championship vacant. The angle advances Big Show's conflict with The Authority and sends Bryan and Orton toward Hell in a Cell. As the main event of a new pay-per-view, however, the absence of a winner produces a deeply frustrating final impression and overwhelms much of the good work before it.

VERDICT

A solid match undermined by a no-contest ending that leaves the vacant championship unresolved.

BOOKING VERDICTD+

The Rhodes family match is the clear booking success because the stipulation creates genuine stakes and the babyface victory pays them off cleanly. Del Rio retaining by submission is logical, Wyatt gets a useful singles victory, and Axel and AJ both continue their title reigns. Those outcomes are straightforward and mostly serve the existing television stories.

The main event overwhelms those positives. A match for a vacant WWE Championship ends in a no contest after Big Show attacks Bryan, Orton and the referee, leaving the exact championship question the show was built to answer unresolved. Punk also beats Ryback with a low blow, adding another intentionally compromised finish. The booking earns a D+ because the Rhodes payoff is excellent, but the two most prominent late-card programs prioritize continuation over satisfying pay-per-view resolution.

CROWD & PRESENTATIONC

Buffalo responds best to the Rhodes family story, where the possibility of Cody, Goldust and Dusty all being removed from WWE gives the match immediate emotional weight. The crowd also reacts well to Rob Van Dam's weapon-based offense and to the major exchanges between Bryan and Orton before the interference. Those stretches show that the audience is willing to invest when the stakes are clear.

The presentation collapses at the end. A long vacant-title main event creates the expectation of a champion, so Big Show knocking out everyone and producing a no contest leaves the arena with frustration rather than closure. The card also contains several matches that look and feel like weekly television rather than a new premium event. The crowd and presentation grade lands at C because the Rhodes match is genuinely effective, but the closing image and uneven card make Battleground feel smaller than its pay-per-view billing.

HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB

Battleground 2013 has meaningful historical significance despite its poor reputation. It launches the Battleground name as an annual WWE event, although the series moves from October to July the following year. It is also the only Battleground to air exclusively through traditional pay-per-view before WWE Network launches in February 2014. The event therefore captures a short transitional period in WWE's distribution history and the final months before its major streaming shift.

The show also sits at a key point in the Daniel Bryan and Authority storyline. The no-contest main event sends Bryan and Randy Orton directly into Hell in a Cell, while Big Show's interference accelerates his own conflict with Triple H and Stephanie McMahon. The Rhodes family victory leads to Cody and Goldust defeating The Shield for the WWE Tag Team Championship on Raw. Battleground is additionally the only edition to feature the previous World Heavyweight Championship as a separate active title. Its historical value is substantial enough for a B even though the event itself is remembered far more for disappointment than excellence.

WHAT AGED WELL
  • Cody Rhodes and Goldust versus The Shield remains a strong emotional tag match.
  • The Rhodes family stakes give the card one genuinely satisfying storyline payoff.
  • Del Rio versus Van Dam uses the Hardcore stipulation effectively.
  • The event directly feeds the Bryan-Orton Hell in a Cell rematch.
  • The inaugural Battleground has chronological value as WWE approaches the Network era.
WHAT AGED POORLY
  • The vacant WWE Championship main event ends without a winner.
  • Punk versus Ryback relies on a low blow rather than a satisfying finish.
  • Several undercard matches feel like ordinary weekly television.
  • The event drew a very weak pay-per-view buyrate for its era.
  • The debut edition never establishes Battleground as a distinctive major event.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

The event-focused review pool is strongly negative overall. The Rhodes family victory receives the clearest praise, while the no-contest WWE Championship main event is repeatedly identified as the defining failure. Contemporary criticism also targets the flat undercard and the sense that several matches are closer to house-show or weekly-television material than a meaningful new pay-per-view.

The reduction reflects the unresolved vacant-title main event, poor overall reception and weak commercial performance, while the score still gives credit to the excellent Rhodes match, the useful Hardcore opener and the event's transitional historical value. The final C- matches a debut remembered more for its failures than its successes.

RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
20 sources

These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

  1. bleacherreport.com — Battleground 2013 source 01Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  2. bleacherreport.com — Battleground 2013 source 02Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  3. bleacherreport.com — Battleground 2013 source 03Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  4. cagesideseats.com — Battleground 2013 source 04Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  5. tjrwrestling.net — Battleground 2013 source 05Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  6. 411mania.com — Battleground 2013 source 06Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  7. 411mania.com — Battleground 2013 source 07Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  8. 411mania.com — Battleground 2013 source 08Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  9. pwtorch.com — Battleground 2013 source 09Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  10. wrestleview.com — Battleground 2013 source 10Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  11. wrestlezone.com — Battleground 2013 source 11Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  12. wwe.com — Battleground 2013 source 12Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  13. profightdb.com — Battleground 2013 source 13Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  14. cagematch.net — Battleground 2013 source 14Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  15. onlineworldofwrestling.com — Battleground 2013 source 15Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  16. dvdtalk.com — Battleground 2013 source 16Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  17. iwnerd.com — Battleground 2013 source 17Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  18. dailyddt.com — Battleground 2013 source 18Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  19. vavel.com — Battleground 2013 source 19Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
  20. voicesofwrestling.com — Battleground 2013 source 20Event review, results, match quality or identity cross-checking.
WHERE TO WATCH

Stream This Event

Checked August 28, 2026STATUS
No confirmed full-event stream

Netflix title 81929521 is associated with WWE Battleground, but the public title page does not expose enough detail to certify that the exact 2013 full-event replay is currently playable in the United States. No current exact provider is claimed.

WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.