- AJ Styles def. Dean Ambrose (c) — WWE World Championship
- The Miz (c) def. Dolph Ziggler — Intercontinental Championship
- Becky Lynch def. Alexa Bliss, Carmella, Naomi, Natalya and Nikki Bella — Inaugural SmackDown Women's Championship Six-Pack Elimination Challenge
- Heath Slater & Rhyno def. The Usos — Inaugural SmackDown Tag Team Championship Tournament Final
Backlash 2016: SmackDown's Reboot Lands With Three New Champions and AJ Styles on Top
The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.
- PROMOTION
- World Wrestling Entertainment
- DATE
- September 11, 2016
- VENUE
- Richmond Coliseum
- LOCATION
- Richmond, Virginia
- ATTENDANCE
- 7,000
- EVENT TYPE
- PPV
Backlash 2016 works because SmackDown understands what its first brand-exclusive pay-per-view needs to accomplish. Becky Lynch becomes the inaugural SmackDown Women's Champion, Heath Slater and Rhyno complete an unexpectedly lovable tournament run to win the new tag titles, and AJ Styles defeats Dean Ambrose to become WWE World Champion less than eight months after debuting in the company. The Miz and Dolph Ziggler also deliver one of the strongest Intercontinental Championship matches of the year. For a card assembled from a newly split roster, the event finds a surprising amount of consequence.
Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis
The flaws are concentrated rather than constant. Randy Orton's medical absence forces WWE to replace his advertised match with a forfeit and an improvised Kane-Bray Wyatt bout, the Usos-Hype Bros qualifier is mostly functional, and several finishes rely on interference or shortcuts. Yet the show is concise, the crowd cares about the title crowning moments, and the main event delivers the level of match the night requires. WrestleFile lands at B, 7.5 out of 10: not a deep classic, but a focused and historically productive relaunch that gives SmackDown a distinct identity immediately.
Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting
Backlash 2016 took place on September 11, 2016, at Richmond Coliseum in Richmond, Virginia, with an announced attendance of 7,000. WWE had restored the brand split in July and made Backlash the first brand-exclusive pay-per-view of the second split, as well as the first Backlash since 2009. SmackDown entered the show without its own women's or tag-team champions, so both championships were created for the new roster. Dean Ambrose defended the WWE World Championship against AJ Styles, who had just defeated John Cena at SummerSlam and earned the number-one contender position.
Six actual matches were wrestled on the pay-per-view broadcast and are included in the WrestleFile match average. Becky Lynch won the six-pack elimination challenge for the inaugural SmackDown Women's Championship; The Usos beat The Hype Bros to reach the tag-title tournament final; The Miz retained the Intercontinental Championship against Dolph Ziggler; Kane defeated Bray Wyatt in an emergency No Holds Barred replacement match; Heath Slater and Rhyno defeated The Usos to become inaugural SmackDown Tag Team Champions; and Styles defeated Ambrose for the WWE World Championship. Baron Corbin's Kickoff win over Apollo Crews is excluded. Bray Wyatt's 25-second administrative forfeit win over the medically unavailable Randy Orton is also excluded because no wrestling match occurred.
Watch, Skim or Skip?
- The Usos def. The Hype Bros — SmackDown Tag Team Championship Tournament Second Chance Challenge
- Kane def. Bray Wyatt — No Holds Barred Match
The Card, On the Record
01Becky Lynch def. Alexa Bliss, Carmella, Naomi, Natalya and Nikki Bella — Inaugural SmackDown Women's Championship Six-Pack Elimination ChallengeB
The six-pack challenge has a difficult job because it must introduce a new championship while giving six women meaningful time. The opening stretch uses constant movement and quick pairings to establish relationships without turning into random chaos. Naomi's athletic bursts, Natalya's submissions, Nikki Bella's star presence, and Carmella's growing heel edge all create distinct beats around Becky Lynch's central pursuit. The eliminations accelerate rapidly in the second half, which slightly undercuts the drama, but the final exchange gets the important part right. Lynch survives Carmella's Superkick, chains together Exploder suplexes, and forces the submission with the Dis-arm-her. The crowd reaction makes the championship feel instantly significant, and Becky finally receives the singles accomplishment her popularity had been demanding.
A strong inaugural title match whose rushed elimination stretch is outweighed by the right winner and one of the night's most satisfying crowd reactions.
02The Usos def. The Hype Bros — SmackDown Tag Team Championship Tournament Second Chance ChallengeC-
The match is most useful as evidence that the Usos' heel turn has immediately changed how they work. Instead of relying on the same energetic babyface sequences, Jimmy and Jey isolate Zack Ryder, attack his knee, and use quick tags to make their control feel meaner and more deliberate. Mojo Rawley provides the expected hot tag and the Hype Bros generate enough offense to create a few believable near falls. The result is never especially mysterious because the Usos are clearly being positioned for the tournament final later in the night. Ryder eventually gets trapped in the Tequila Sunrise after another attack to the leg and submits. Technically sound and narratively useful, the bout remains a qualifier whose main purpose is preparing one team for a more important match.
A functional tournament bridge improved by the Usos' refreshed heel style, but too predictable and secondary to become more than a competent qualifier.
03The Miz (c) def. Dolph Ziggler — Intercontinental ChampionshipB+
Miz and Ziggler benefit from years of familiarity without making the match feel recycled. Miz slows the pace with targeted leg work and deliberately borrows Daniel Bryan's offense, turning the championship defense into an extension of his ongoing conflict with SmackDown management. Ziggler's comeback provides the athletic contrast, especially through the Fameasser, DDT, Superkick attempts, and repeated near falls. Nearly twenty minutes gives both wrestlers room to build rather than sprint through signature moves. The finish is appropriately cheap: Maryse sprays Ziggler in the eyes while the referee is distracted, allowing Miz to land the Skull Crushing Finale. It protects Ziggler while reinforcing Miz's increasingly effective heel identity. The interference prevents a cleaner conclusion, but the match itself is one of Miz's strongest pay-per-view performances of the year.
A very good Intercontinental Championship match that turns familiar opponents into a fresh story, with a cheap finish that fits Miz even while limiting the payoff.
04Kane def. Bray Wyatt — No Holds Barred MatchC-
Kane and Wyatt are forced into an impossible position because the audience expected Randy Orton and the replacement match has almost no independent buildup. The No Holds Barred stipulation helps by allowing them to skip ordinary pacing and move quickly toward chairs, ringside brawling, and the night's biggest stunt. Wyatt's running senton from one announce table through Kane on another earns a huge reaction and temporarily gives the match a sense of danger. The problem is the finish. Orton limps to ringside, hits Wyatt with an RKO, and Kane follows with a Chokeslam for the pin. The interference keeps the original feud alive but requires Wyatt to lose immediately after receiving an official forfeit victory over Orton. The spectacle is passable; the booking leaves almost everyone in a stranger position.
A decent emergency brawl with one excellent table spot, undermined by a replacement-match finish that makes Wyatt's earlier forfeit victory feel meaningless.
05Heath Slater & Rhyno def. The Usos — Inaugural SmackDown Tag Team Championship Tournament FinalC+
The wrestling is straightforward, but the crowd turns the tournament final into one of the show's most memorable moments. The Usos work Slater over with the aggression established earlier, keeping Rhyno outside and forcing the supposed weak link to survive. That structure is perfect for the story because Slater's entire summer has been about proving he deserves a roster spot. Rhyno's hot tag changes the energy immediately, and the finish cleverly gives both partners credit. Jimmy superkicks Slater, Rhyno cuts him down with the Gore, and Slater makes the cover to win the championships and his SmackDown contract. The match is not technically ambitious, yet the emotional logic is nearly flawless. A comedy angle becomes a legitimate championship celebration without abandoning the personality that made the team popular.
A basic tag match elevated by superb story payoff, giving Slater the pin, the contract, and a championship moment the crowd genuinely wants to celebrate.
06AJ Styles def. Dean Ambrose (c) — WWE World ChampionshipA-
Styles and Ambrose give the show the main event it needs, building patiently before turning the final ten minutes into a sequence of counters, dives, and increasingly dangerous near falls. Styles' precision controls much of the opening half, while Ambrose's comeback feels more explosive once he starts using the announce tables and barricade to create momentum. The Calf Crusher, Springboard 450 Splash, Lunatic Lariat, and Dirty Deeds attempts all receive enough space to feel significant. When Ambrose accidentally knocks down the referee, Styles immediately recognizes the opportunity, lands a low blow, and follows with the Styles Clash to win the championship. The cheating fits his heel character without overwhelming twenty-five minutes of excellent wrestling. More importantly, the finish feels historic: WWE has fully committed to AJ Styles as a world champion.
A great championship main event and the defining moment of the show, combining excellent late-match drama with the historic coronation of AJ Styles.
BOOKING VERDICTB+
The Booking Verdict earns a B+ because Backlash accomplishes most of the difficult foundational work facing a newly separated SmackDown roster. Becky Lynch is the correct first women's champion, and giving her a decisive submission victory creates an immediate centerpiece for the division. Slater and Rhyno winning the tag tournament pays off one of the brand split's best comedy-underdog stories while also earning Slater the contract that had become central to his character. AJ Styles winning the WWE World Championship is the most important decision of the night and confirms that WWE sees him as a genuine top-level star.
The show does take a hit from the Orton situation. WWE has little choice once he is not medically cleared, but having Wyatt collect a forfeit and then lose to Kane after Orton interference makes the replacement material feel awkward. Miz retaining through Maryse's spray is intentionally cheap, yet it fits his heel presentation and keeps the Ziggler program alive. Most importantly, the three new champions leave the show with clearly defined roles. For an event whose job is to establish an entire brand's hierarchy, Backlash gets far more right than wrong.
CROWD & PRESENTATIONB
Crowd and Presentation earns a B because Richmond gives the title moments real emotional weight. Becky Lynch's victory receives the reaction of a long-awaited breakthrough, Slater and Rhyno are treated like genuine folk heroes by the time the tag final reaches its finish, and AJ Styles' championship win produces the loudest sustained response of the night. The audience also stays invested through Miz-Ziggler's long middle-card title match and gives the main event the atmosphere of a major championship fight. Even the emergency Kane-Wyatt match gets a strong reaction for the announce-table senton.
The production itself is less distinctive. Backlash uses much of the same visual language as weekly SmackDown, and the smaller Richmond Coliseum setup does not create the scale associated with WWE's biggest events. What helps is the show's runtime: at roughly two hours and thirty-eight minutes, the pay-per-view avoids the bloat that hurt several 2016 cards. The three championship celebrations provide natural visual peaks, and the concise pacing keeps the crowd from becoming exhausted before Styles and Ambrose. It feels like a strong branded special rather than a supersized spectacle, which suits the event better than excess would have.
HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB+
Historical Significance earns a B-plus because Backlash 2016 establishes multiple pillars of the second brand split in one night. Becky Lynch becomes the inaugural SmackDown Women's Champion, beginning the title history of a championship that remains central to WWE's women's division. Heath Slater and Rhyno become the inaugural SmackDown Tag Team Champions, completing the free-agent storyline that turned Slater into one of the most unexpectedly popular acts of the summer. The event also marks the return of Backlash after a seven-year absence and the first brand-exclusive pay-per-view of WWE's revived roster split.
AJ Styles' victory is the largest historical marker. Less than a year after leaving New Japan Pro-Wrestling and only months after debuting at the Royal Rumble, Styles defeats Dean Ambrose to become WWE World Champion. That makes him the first wrestler since Kurt Angle to hold top championships in WWE, TNA, and New Japan, and it cements his transition from celebrated outsider to WWE main-event fixture. The match also launches the championship phase of Styles' first WWE year. Backlash is not historically important because of one experimental concept; it matters because several major lineages and careers visibly change direction on the same card.
WHAT AGED WELL
- AJ Styles being elevated to WWE World Champion only months after his company debut.
- Becky Lynch becoming the inaugural SmackDown Women's Champion in a crowd-pleasing payoff.
- Heath Slater and Rhyno turning a comedy free-agent story into a genuinely emotional championship moment.
- The Miz and Dolph Ziggler receiving nearly twenty minutes to build a substantial Intercontinental Championship match.
WHAT AGED POORLY
- The Randy Orton medical absence creating a forfeit and a hastily assembled Kane-Bray Wyatt replacement match.
- Wyatt officially winning by forfeit and then losing a different match on the same show after Orton interferes.
- The weekly-television stage and presentation making the first SmackDown-exclusive PPV feel visually smaller than its historical importance.
- Several important wins arriving through interference or shortcuts rather than clean championship conclusions.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands
The contemporary review record is positive and unusually consistent about the show's main strengths. TJR Wrestling gives Backlash 7.5 out of 10, calls it one of WWE's better pay-per-views of the year, rates Styles-Ambrose at four and a quarter stars, and gives Miz-Ziggler three and a half. Bleacher Report, FOX Sports, PWP Nation, Cageside Seats, Pro Wrestling Torch, and 411Mania likewise place the main event among the night's clear highlights. Becky Lynch's title win and the Slater-Rhyno payoff also receive broad praise because both feel like natural conclusions to stories created by the new SmackDown roster.
The final B / 7.5 reflects unusually efficient pacing, three foundational championship outcomes, and the historical importance of Styles' first WWE World Championship. The adjustment also recognizes that the show is better as a complete relaunch than the arithmetic average of six isolated matches suggests. It does not climb higher because the emergency Wyatt material is weak, the secondary tag qualifier is ordinary, and several finishes depend on interference. Backlash succeeds most as a coherent new-brand statement rather than as a card filled with elite matches.
RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology20 sources
These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.
- Bleacher ReportBacklash 2016 results, winners, grades, reaction, and highlights
- Bleacher ReportBacklash 2016 review of major highlights and low points
- FOX SportsBacklash 2016 results, analysis, and match grades
- TJR WrestlingJohn Canton complete-show review, star ratings, and 7.5/10 event score
- PWP NationBacklash 2016 review and B overall grade
- IWNerdWrestling Observer star-rating reference for Backlash 2016
- CAGEMATCHBacklash 2016 ratings and canonical event identity
- Gaming RespawnBacklash 2016 review and main-event evaluation
- 411ManiaBacklash 2016 retrospective review
- Pro Wrestling TorchContemporary complete Backlash 2016 pay-per-view report
- IMDbBacklash 2016 audience-review context
- WhatCultureBacklash 2016 match-by-match historical ranking
- Cageside SeatsBacklash 2016 match-of-the-night audience reaction
- Cageside Seats2016 WWE pay-per-view grading context including Backlash
- Cageside SeatsBacklash 2016 total wrestling-time analysis
- Cageside SeatsBacklash 2016 predictability analysis
- YardbarkerHistorical Backlash match-rating context
- Bleacher ReportBacklash 2016 live social-media reaction
- FOX SportsBacklash 2016 best-moments retrospective
- WWEOfficial Backlash 2016 results and canonical event identity
WHERE TO WATCHStream This Event
Stream This Event
Netflix title 81929461 is associated with Backlash, but the public title page does not expose enough event-specific detail to certify that the exact 2016 full-event replay is currently playable in the United States. No current exact provider is claimed.
WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.