WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

Against All Odds 2008: Angle-Cage Leads a Wild Card of Barbed Wire, Street Fighting and Title Stakes

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

TNAFebruary 10, 2008BI-LO Center
THE WRESTLEGRADEB7.7 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#549OF 1030
PROMOTION
TNA Wrestling
DATE
February 10, 2008
VENUE
BI-LO Center
LOCATION
Greenville, South Carolina
ATTENDANCE
3,500
EVENT TYPE
PPV
THE FILE

Against All Odds 2008 is a good show with a messy personality. Its strongest matches are built around clear stakes or stipulations: Abyss and Judas Mesias get the Barbed Wire Massacre, the Motor City Machine Guns and Jay Lethal fight Johnny Devine and Team 3D in a Street Fight for the X Division Championship, and Kurt Angle again faces Christian Cage for the TNA World Heavyweight Championship with Samoa Joe stationed as the special outside enforcer. Those attractions give the closing half real substance.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

The first half is less convincing, mixing brief title defenses, a novelty championship and a Feast or Fired briefcase match that makes the card feel busier than it needs to be. The result is an entertaining but uneven pay-per-view whose best material becomes increasingly concentrated as the night goes on.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

Against All Odds 2008 took place on February 10 with a locked attendance of 3,500 and nine main-card matches. A.J. Styles and Tomko open by defending the TNA World Tag Team Championship against B.G. James and Bob Armstrong, followed by Traci Brooks versus Payton Banks. Scott Steiner then faces Petey Williams with the X Division and World Heavyweight Feast or Fired briefcases involved, while Eric Young defends the World Beer Drinking Championship against James Storm and Awesome Kong defends the Knockouts Championship against ODB. The tone changes in the back half.

Abyss and Judas Mesias go 14:51 in Barbed Wire Massacre, Booker T and Robert Roode end in a double countout, the Motor City Machine Guns and Jay Lethal win a Street Fight that changes the X Division Championship, and Kurt Angle closes by retaining against Christian Cage in 20:40 with Samoa Joe as special outside enforcer. The card's strongest identity clearly arrives after the midpoint. The three longest matches all appear in the final four positions, which gives the event a pronounced back-loaded shape. By the closing bell, the show has moved from short novelty and title pieces into three matches with much clearer pay-per-view weight.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • Abyss defeated Judas Mesias (with Father James Mitchell)
  • The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin) and Jay Lethal defeated Johnny Devine (c) and Team 3D (Brother Devon and Brother Ray)
  • Kurt Angle (c) (with Karen Angle) defeated Christian Cage
SKIM
  • Scott Steiner (X) defeated Petey Williams (World)
  • Awesome Kong (c) (with Raisha Saeed) defeated ODB
SKIP
  • A.J. Styles and Tomko (c) defeated B.G. James and Bob Armstrong
  • Traci Brooks defeated Payton Banks
  • Eric Young (c) defeated James Storm (with Jackie Moore)
  • Booker T vs. Robert Roode (with Payton Banks) ended in a double countout
MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

The Card, On the Record

01A.J. Styles and Tomko (c) defeated B.G. James and Bob ArmstrongC

A.J. Styles and Tomko (c) defeated B.G. James and Bob Armstrong. The bout is presented as tag team match for the tna world tag team championship (this was james' feast or fired tag team title match) on the main card and runs 7:45. The tag champions face an unusual challenger combination created by the Feast or Fired opportunity, but the match lasts under eight minutes. Styles and Tomko retaining is logical and clear, yet the limited time keeps the title defense from reaching the level of the stronger matches later on the card. Within Against All Odds 2008, the match grades as serviceable match. The 6.0 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition: placement, time allocation where established, competitive stakes, stipulation value and how much the result adds to the surrounding card are weighed together rather than treating reputation or later significance as a substitute for what the match contributes on this night.

VERDICT

Serviceable without becoming a destination.

02Traci Brooks defeated Payton BanksD+

Traci Brooks defeated Payton Banks. The bout is presented as singles match on the main card and runs 5:07. Brooks and Banks receive just over five minutes, making this one of the night's most compressed bouts. The result advances their issue, but the match does not have the time or stakes to compete with the championship and specialty matches around it. Within Against All Odds 2008, the match grades as minor material with limited payoff. The 5.4 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition: placement, time allocation where established, competitive stakes, stipulation value and how much the result adds to the surrounding card are weighed together rather than treating reputation or later significance as a substitute for what the match contributes on this night.

VERDICT

Minor material that adds little beyond the result.

03Scott Steiner (X) defeated Petey Williams (World)C+

Scott Steiner (X) defeated Petey Williams (World). The bout is presented as singles match for the tna x division and tna world heavyweight championships feast or fired briefcases on the main card and runs 9:24. The Feast or Fired briefcases make the Steiner-Williams singles match unusually complicated because both the X Division and world-title opportunities are represented. The nine-minute runtime lets the concept register, although the multiple future stakes make the match feel more procedural than emotionally decisive. Within Against All Odds 2008, the match grades as useful supporting material. The 6.8 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition: placement, time allocation where established, competitive stakes, stipulation value and how much the result adds to the surrounding card are weighed together rather than treating reputation or later significance as a substitute for what the match contributes on this night.

VERDICT

Useful supporting material, but not essential.

04Eric Young (c) defeated James Storm (with Jackie Moore)C

Eric Young (c) defeated James Storm (with Jackie Moore). The bout is presented as singles match for the tna world beer drinking championship on the main card and runs 7:49. Young and Storm work around the Beer Drinking Championship, a novelty title that gives the bout a distinct premise but limited major-card importance. The match is competent and concise, yet its stakes feel intentionally lighter than the serious championships elsewhere on the show. Within Against All Odds 2008, the match grades as serviceable match. The 6.0 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition: placement, time allocation where established, competitive stakes, stipulation value and how much the result adds to the surrounding card are weighed together rather than treating reputation or later significance as a substitute for what the match contributes on this night.

VERDICT

Serviceable without becoming a destination.

05Awesome Kong (c) (with Raisha Saeed) defeated ODBC+

Awesome Kong (c) (with Raisha Saeed) defeated ODB. The bout is presented as singles match for the tna women's knockout championship on the main card and runs 6:54. Kong's defense against ODB is short but physically direct, and the champion retaining reinforces her control of the Knockouts division. The sub-seven-minute runtime limits the ceiling, though the clear title stakes keep the match from feeling disposable. Within Against All Odds 2008, the match grades as useful supporting material. The 6.8 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition: placement, time allocation where established, competitive stakes, stipulation value and how much the result adds to the surrounding card are weighed together rather than treating reputation or later significance as a substitute for what the match contributes on this night.

VERDICT

Useful supporting material, but not essential.

06Abyss defeated Judas Mesias (with Father James Mitchell)B+

Abyss defeated Judas Mesias (with Father James Mitchell). The bout is presented as barbed wire massacre on the main card and runs 14:51. Barbed Wire Massacre gives Abyss and Mesias the kind of violent environment their rivalry has been building toward. Nearly fifteen minutes allows the stipulation to feel like a genuine pay-per-view attraction, and Abyss's victory supplies the decisive outcome the feud needed. Within Against All Odds 2008, the match grades as a strong feature that materially improves the event. The 8.0 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition: placement, time allocation where established, competitive stakes, stipulation value and how much the result adds to the surrounding card are weighed together rather than treating reputation or later significance as a substitute for what the match contributes on this night.

VERDICT

A strong feature that is comfortably worth watching.

07Booker T vs. Robert Roode (with Payton Banks) ended in a double countoutC

Booker T vs. Robert Roode (with Payton Banks) ended in a double countout. The bout is presented as singles match on the main card and runs 9:17. Booker T and Roode receive more than nine minutes, but the double-countout finish denies the match the payoff expected from a featured singles program. The work has enough space to develop, yet the unresolved conclusion makes it feel more like another chapter than a destination. Within Against All Odds 2008, the match grades as serviceable match. The 6.2 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition: placement, time allocation where established, competitive stakes, stipulation value and how much the result adds to the surrounding card are weighed together rather than treating reputation or later significance as a substitute for what the match contributes on this night.

VERDICT

Serviceable without becoming a destination.

08The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin) and Jay Lethal defeated Johnny Devine (c) and Team 3D (Brother Devon and Brother Ray)B+

The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin) and Jay Lethal defeated Johnny Devine (c) and Team 3D (Brother Devon and Brother Ray). The bout is presented as street fight for the tna x division championship on the main card and runs 12:30. The Street Fight combines the X Division title with a multi-man feud and produces a championship change, giving the match immediate consequence. The twelve-and-a-half-minute runtime is enough for the teams to create chaos without overstaying the concept, and the result clearly advances the division. Within Against All Odds 2008, the match grades as a strong feature that materially improves the event. The 8.2 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition: placement, time allocation where established, competitive stakes, stipulation value and how much the result adds to the surrounding card are weighed together rather than treating reputation or later significance as a substitute for what the match contributes on this night.

VERDICT

A strong feature that is comfortably worth watching.

09Kurt Angle (c) (with Karen Angle) defeated Christian CageA-

Kurt Angle (c) (with Karen Angle) defeated Christian Cage. The bout is presented as singles match for the tna world heavyweight championship with samoa joe as the special outside enforcer on the main card and runs 20:40. Angle and Cage get more than twenty minutes with Samoa Joe positioned as special outside enforcer, which makes the world-title match feel like the event's true centerpiece. Angle retaining preserves the championship while Joe's visible involvement keeps the next layer of the title picture in view. Within Against All Odds 2008, the match grades as an excellent match and one of the event's strongest attractions. The 8.6 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition: placement, time allocation where established, competitive stakes, stipulation value and how much the result adds to the surrounding card are weighed together rather than treating reputation or later significance as a substitute for what the match contributes on this night.

VERDICT

Excellent and one of the event's strongest attractions.

BOOKING VERDICTB

The booking provides enough consequential outcomes to overcome the clutter. The Street Fight creates a title change and gives the X Division program a tangible payoff, while Angle retaining against Cage keeps the world-title picture centered on the champion with Joe visibly attached to the main-event story. Abyss defeating Mesias in the Barbed Wire Massacre gives that feud a decisive specialty-match chapter. The weaker decisions are less about outcomes than about congestion: several early matches carry championships, briefcases or novelty stakes without receiving enough time to feel major. Booker T and Roode ending in a double countout also leaves a featured singles program unresolved. Against All Odds works because the final three major attractions provide direction that the first half sometimes lacks.

CROWD & PRESENTATIONB

The 3,500 attendance gives Against All Odds more physical scale than the Impact Zone cards surrounding it, and the varied stipulations help the show use that space. Barbed Wire Massacre has an immediate visual identity, the Street Fight creates a chaotic championship showcase, and the 20-minute world-title main event feels appropriately substantial at the end. The presentation is less coherent when the first half cycles through several different kinds of stakes in quick succession. A tag-title defense, Feast or Fired briefcases, the Beer Drinking Championship and the Knockouts title all appear before the show reaches its more dramatic material. That variety prevents monotony, but it also makes the event feel scattered until the closing run settles into clearer pay-per-view priorities.

HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEB

Against All Odds 2008 is most useful as a bridge in several ongoing TNA programs rather than as a singular turning point. Kurt Angle and Christian Cage again anchor the world-title picture, but Samoa Joe's role as special outside enforcer keeps him visibly connected to the championship scene. The X Division story produces a title change through the Street Fight involving Jay Lethal, the Motor City Machine Guns, Johnny Devine and Team 3D. Awesome Kong continues as Knockouts champion, while Abyss and Judas Mesias receive a major stipulation to define their rivalry. The card also reflects the promotion's appetite for layered gimmicks, from Feast or Fired briefcases to specialty championships and violent stipulations. That makes the show representative of its period: ambitious, crowded and often entertaining, with the strongest ideas emerging when the stakes are simple enough to understand immediately.

WHAT AGED WELL
  • Angle-Cage gets more than twenty minutes and keeps Samoa Joe visibly connected to the world-title story.
  • The X Division Street Fight delivers a championship change and a strong late-card payoff.
  • Barbed Wire Massacre gives Abyss and Mesias a distinct feud-ending environment.
WHAT AGED POORLY
  • The first half carries too many different kinds of stakes for several matches to feel important.
  • The Beer Drinking Championship material feels slight beside the serious title programs around it.
  • The Booker T-Roode double countout interrupts the momentum of the stronger closing stretch.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

Against All Odds lands at 7.7 because the card contains three clearly worthwhile late attractions but asks the audience to navigate a cluttered first half to reach them. Abyss-Mesias provides violent spectacle, the X Division Street Fight combines championship stakes with a decisive title change, and Angle-Cage gives the show a long main event with Samoa Joe integrated into the presentation. The early matches are more variable in time, purpose and payoff, and the double countout keeps one featured feud from producing a satisfying conclusion. The event is still comfortably above average because its best material is substantial rather than incidental. It simply lacks the consistency and clean thematic focus required for a higher grade.

RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
5 sources

These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

  1. Pro Wrestling HistoryCard results, match durations, stipulations, title context, and historical corroboration.
  2. TheSmackDownHotelCard results, match durations, stipulations, title context, and historical corroboration.
  3. History of WWEHistorical card results, event context, and chronology corroboration.
  4. WikipediaEvent identity, card results, venue/date context, and historical corroboration.
  5. 411ManiaContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
WHERE TO WATCH

Stream This Event

Checked September 19, 2026STATUS
No confirmed full-event stream

Locked factual research established no current provider that can be asserted safely here; no territory-safe direct viewing destination is included.

WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.