WRESTLEFILE EVENT FILE

Against All Odds 2006: Christian Cage's World-Title Win Gives TNA a Complete Pay-Per-View Payoff

The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.

TNAFebruary 12, 2006TNA Impact! Zone
THE WRESTLEGRADEA-8.7 / 10FINAL EVENT SCOREMASTER FILE RANK#158OF 1015
PROMOTION
TNA Wrestling
DATE
February 12, 2006
VENUE
TNA Impact! Zone
LOCATION
Orlando, Florida
ATTENDANCE
900
EVENT TYPE
PPV
THE FILE

Against All Odds 2006 has the kind of ending that can organize an entire pay-per-view. Christian Cage defeating Jeff Jarrett for the NWA World Heavyweight Championship gives the show a definitive final payoff, but the card is strong before that moment arrives. Rhino and Abyss deliver a substantial Falls Count Anywhere match, Samoa Joe retains against A.

Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis

J. Styles and Christopher Daniels, Team 3D and Team Canada provide a solid late tag, and the undercard contains enough X Division and tag-team variety to keep the event moving. Two disposable pre-show matches hold the floor down, yet the main card builds steadily toward the championship change.

Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting

Against All Odds 2006 took place at the TNA Impact! Zone in Orlando. Pro Wrestling History lists attendance at 900, while the alternate Wikipedia source lists 775, so the exact figure is not perfectly settled. The ten-match card includes two pre-show bouts, one of them lasting only 1:43. The main card begins with The Naturals defeating Austin Aries and Roderick Strong, followed by Jay Lethal winning a four-way X Division match. America's Most Wanted retain the NWA World Tag Team Championship against Chris Sabin and Sonjay Dutt in 10:43. The upper card then becomes substantially stronger: Rhino defeats Abyss in a 15:25 Falls Count Anywhere match, Samoa Joe retains the TNA X Division Championship against A.J.

Styles and Christopher Daniels, and Team 3D defeat Team Canada in 13:12. Christian Cage closes by defeating Jeff Jarrett in 16:14 to win the NWA World Heavyweight Championship. That progression gives the event a clean rise from division-building undercard work to rivalry matches, a major X Division title defense and finally a decisive world-title change. The card works best when its hierarchy becomes obvious in the second half. Earlier matches supply different styles and ongoing programs, but the later bouts carry the clearest stakes and strongest sense of consequence. That progression prevents the event from feeling flat even when some supporting material is modest, because the show keeps building toward matches that are presented as more important.

VIEWING GUIDE

Watch, Skim or Skip?

WATCH
  • Jay Lethal defeated Matt Bentley (with Traci), Alex Shelley and Petey Williams
  • Rhino defeated Abyss (with James Mitchell)
  • Samoa Joe (c) defeated A.J. Styles and Christopher Daniels
  • Christian Cage defeated Jeff Jarrett (c) (with Gail Kim)
SKIM
  • The Naturals (Andy Douglas and Chase Stevens) defeated Austin Aries and Roderick Strong
  • America's Most Wanted (Chris Harris and James Storm) (c) defeated Chris Sabin and Sonjay Dutt
  • Team 3D (Brother Ray and Brother Devon) defeated Team Canada (Bobby Roode and Eric Young) (with Coach D'Amore)
SKIP
  • Ron Killings defeated A-1
  • Lance Hoyt, Cassidy Riley and Shark Boy defeated Shannon Moore and The Diamonds in the Rough (Elix Skipper and David Young) (with Simon Diamond)
  • The James Gang (B.G. James and Kip James) defeated The Latin American Exchange (Homicide and Machete) (with Konnan)
MATCH-BY-MATCH ANALYSIS

The Card, On the Record

01Ron Killings defeated A-1D

Ron Killings defeated A-1. The match is presented as singles match and runs 1:43. On the pre-show, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match is minor material whose short duration or limited consequence keeps it from becoming an important part of the event. The 4.5 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Against All Odds 2006, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.

VERDICT

Safe to skip unless watching the event completist-style.

02Lance Hoyt, Cassidy Riley and Shark Boy defeated Shannon Moore and The Diamonds in the Rough (Elix Skipper and David Young) (with Simon Diamond)C-

Lance Hoyt, Cassidy Riley and Shark Boy defeated Shannon Moore and The Diamonds in the Rough (Elix Skipper and David Young) (with Simon Diamond). The match is presented as six-man tag team match and runs 5:49. On the pre-show, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match is acceptable but slight, with too little time or consequence to create much lasting value beyond filling its position on the card. The 5.8 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Against All Odds 2006, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.

VERDICT

Skimmable material with limited replay value.

03The Naturals (Andy Douglas and Chase Stevens) defeated Austin Aries and Roderick StrongB

The Naturals (Andy Douglas and Chase Stevens) defeated Austin Aries and Roderick Strong. The match is presented as tag team match and runs 10:29. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match is consistently good and earns its place on the card, even if it lacks the extra consequence or singular peak needed to join the night's top tier. The 7.5 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Against All Odds 2006, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.

VERDICT

A good match that rewards a full-card watch.

04Jay Lethal defeated Matt Bentley (with Traci), Alex Shelley and Petey WilliamsB+

Jay Lethal defeated Matt Bentley (with Traci), Alex Shelley and Petey Williams. The match is presented as x division four-way match and runs 10:30. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match is a strong feature that materially improves the event, with enough time, stakes or stylistic distinction to stand clearly above routine supporting material. The 8.0 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Against All Odds 2006, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.

VERDICT

A strong match that is comfortably worth watching.

05The James Gang (B.G. James and Kip James) defeated The Latin American Exchange (Homicide and Machete) (with Konnan)C

The James Gang (B.G. James and Kip James) defeated The Latin American Exchange (Homicide and Machete) (with Konnan). The match is presented as tag team match and runs 5:59. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match does its basic job without damaging the show, though its limited stakes or modest presentation make it easy to leave off a selective rewatch. The 6.4 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Against All Odds 2006, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.

VERDICT

Serviceable but nonessential. within the context of this event.

06America's Most Wanted (Chris Harris and James Storm) (c) defeated Chris Sabin and Sonjay DuttB

America's Most Wanted (Chris Harris and James Storm) (c) defeated Chris Sabin and Sonjay Dutt. The match is presented as tag team match for the nwa world tag team championship and runs 10:43. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match is consistently good and earns its place on the card, even if it lacks the extra consequence or singular peak needed to join the night's top tier. The 7.8 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Against All Odds 2006, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.

VERDICT

A good match that rewards a full-card watch.

07Rhino defeated Abyss (with James Mitchell)A-

Rhino defeated Abyss (with James Mitchell). The match is presented as falls count anywhere match and runs 15:25. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. Falls Count Anywhere gives Rhino and Abyss room to make their rivalry feel larger than a standard singles bout, and the 15:25 duration makes it one of the card's major attractions. The match is an excellent piece of the card, combining meaningful placement with enough time and consequence to remain one of the event's strongest reasons to revisit the show. The 8.6 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Against All Odds 2006, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.

VERDICT

An excellent match and one of the event's strongest attractions.

08Samoa Joe (c) defeated A.J. Styles and Christopher DanielsA

Samoa Joe (c) defeated A.J. Styles and Christopher Daniels. The match is presented as three-way match for the tna x division championship and runs 10:06. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. Joe retaining against both Styles and Daniels compresses the division's three central names into a fast championship match, keeping Joe's reign intact while protecting the match's intensity. The match reaches elite territory because its stakes and structure are clear, the featured time is justified, and the result feels worthy of a major pay-per-view attraction. The 9.3 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Against All Odds 2006, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.

VERDICT

A major match that belongs on any focused rewatch of the event.

09Team 3D (Brother Ray and Brother Devon) defeated Team Canada (Bobby Roode and Eric Young) (with Coach D'Amore)B

Team 3D (Brother Ray and Brother Devon) defeated Team Canada (Bobby Roode and Eric Young) (with Coach D'Amore). The match is presented as tag team match and runs 13:12. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. The match is consistently good and earns its place on the card, even if it lacks the extra consequence or singular peak needed to join the night's top tier. The 7.9 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Against All Odds 2006, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.

VERDICT

A good match that rewards a full-card watch.

10Christian Cage defeated Jeff Jarrett (c) (with Gail Kim)A-

Christian Cage defeated Jeff Jarrett (c) (with Gail Kim). The match is presented as singles match for the nwa world heavyweight championship and runs 16:14. On the main card, its value comes from how clearly the result, stipulation and allotted time define its role on the card. Christian Cage defeating Jarrett for the NWA World Heavyweight Championship provides the decisive title change the card is built toward and gives the final match a clear payoff. The match is an excellent piece of the card, combining meaningful placement with enough time and consequence to remain one of the event's strongest reasons to revisit the show. The 8.9 score reflects the complete bell-to-bell proposition rather than later reputation: immediate match quality, placement on Against All Odds 2006, and the amount of consequence created by the result are weighed together.

VERDICT

An excellent match and one of the event's strongest attractions.

BOOKING VERDICTA

The world-title change is the central booking success. Christian Cage's win over Jarrett rewards the contender direction established on earlier shows and gives the pay-per-view a finish that clearly alters the top of the roster. Joe retaining against Styles and Daniels keeps his X Division reign strong without making the division feel static, while Rhino's Falls Count Anywhere victory over Abyss gives their feud another decisive result. America's Most Wanted also retain the tag titles. The card therefore changes the championship that most needs a major payoff while allowing the other title programs to continue with credible champions. That balance keeps the event moving forward even when the supporting material is less memorable than the strongest championship and rivalry work.

CROWD & PRESENTATIONB+

Against All Odds benefits from a card that becomes progressively more substantial. The pre-show is brief and disposable, but the main card gives its strongest matches increasingly prominent placement. Falls Count Anywhere adds physical variety, the three-way X Division title match changes the pace again, and the conventional world-title main event can then feel important without needing another elaborate stipulation. The compact Impact! Zone setting remains visually modest, yet the 900 locked attendance and the sequence of upper-card attractions give the final hour stronger pay-per-view energy than the opening portion.

HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEA

Against All Odds 2006 carries clear historical weight because Christian Cage leaves with the NWA World Heavyweight Championship. The result is more than a closing upset: it follows the contender path established at Turning Point and the top-card tag victory at Final Resolution, giving several months of card structure a direct payoff. Samoa Joe simultaneously retains the X Division Championship against A.J. Styles and Christopher Daniels, keeping the division's three central names tied together while Joe remains champion. Rhino-Abyss, Team 3D-Team Canada and America's Most Wanted's tag-title retention supply continuity across the rest of the roster. The attendance sources also disagree, with Pro Wrestling History listing 900 and the alternate Wikipedia source listing 775, so the event's exact scale should be treated with some caution. As a historical event, the world-title change is the defining fact.

WHAT AGED WELL
  • Christian Cage's world-title victory gives the show a decisive and earned closing payoff.
  • Rhino-Abyss and Joe-Styles-Daniels create two different upper-card peaks before the main event.
  • The tag-title and X Division champions retain while the world title changes, preserving continuity around the major shift.
WHAT AGED POORLY
  • The two pre-show matches contribute little to the event's lasting value.
  • Some mid-card tags are functional rather than destination viewing.
  • The compact venue still relies on match stakes to create a major-event atmosphere.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands

The card earns an A- because it combines a strong final hour with a genuinely consequential ending. Rhino-Abyss, Joe-Styles-Daniels and Christian-Jarrett give the show three major singles-style attractions with different structures, while the tag divisions provide adequate support. The pre-show and some shorter middle-card material prevent a higher grade, but the event's best matches are not merely decorative: they either defend a championship, resolve a feud beat or change the top title. That combination gives Against All Odds more completeness than several nearby TNA pay-per-views.

RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology
6 sources

These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.

  1. WikipediaEvent identity, card results, match context, and historical corroboration.
  2. History of WWEHistorical card results, event context, and chronology corroboration.
  3. 411ManiaContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
  4. Pro Wrestling HistoryCard results, match durations, stipulations, title context, and historical corroboration.
  5. TheSmackDownHotelCard results, match durations, stipulations, title context, and historical corroboration.
  6. 411ManiaContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
WHERE TO WATCH

Stream This Event

Checked September 18, 2026STATUS
No confirmed full-event stream

Locked factual research established no current provider that can be asserted safely here; no territory-safe direct viewing destination is included.

WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.