- Jay Lethal defeated Matt Bentley (with Traci), Alex Shelley and Petey Williams
- Rhino defeated Abyss (with James Mitchell)
- Samoa Joe (c) defeated A.J. Styles and Christopher Daniels
- Christian Cage defeated Jeff Jarrett (c) (with Gail Kim)
- The Naturals (Andy Douglas and Chase Stevens) defeated Austin Aries and Roderick Strong
- America's Most Wanted (Chris Harris and James Storm) (c) defeated Chris Sabin and Sonjay Dutt
- Team 3D (Brother Ray and Brother Devon) defeated Team Canada (Bobby Roode and Eric Young) (with Coach D'Amore)
Against All Odds 2006: Christian Cage's World-Title Win Gives TNA a Complete Pay-Per-View Payoff
The factual record, historical context, match-by-match analysis, and WrestleFile verdict.
- PROMOTION
- TNA Wrestling
- DATE
- February 12, 2006
- VENUE
- TNA Impact! Zone
- LOCATION
- Orlando, Florida
- ATTENDANCE
- 900
- EVENT TYPE
- PPV
Against All Odds 2006 has the kind of ending that can organize an entire pay-per-view. Christian Cage defeating Jeff Jarrett for the NWA World Heavyweight Championship gives the show a definitive final payoff, but the card is strong before that moment arrives. Rhino and Abyss deliver a substantial Falls Count Anywhere match, Samoa Joe retains against A.
Read the Full FileContinue the event-level analysis
J. Styles and Christopher Daniels, Team 3D and Team Canada provide a solid late tag, and the undercard contains enough X Division and tag-team variety to keep the event moving. Two disposable pre-show matches hold the floor down, yet the main card builds steadily toward the championship change.
Event ContextBackground, stakes & historical setting
Against All Odds 2006 took place at the TNA Impact! Zone in Orlando. Pro Wrestling History lists attendance at 900, while the alternate Wikipedia source lists 775, so the exact figure is not perfectly settled. The ten-match card includes two pre-show bouts, one of them lasting only 1:43. The main card begins with The Naturals defeating Austin Aries and Roderick Strong, followed by Jay Lethal winning a four-way X Division match. America's Most Wanted retain the NWA World Tag Team Championship against Chris Sabin and Sonjay Dutt in 10:43. The upper card then becomes substantially stronger: Rhino defeats Abyss in a 15:25 Falls Count Anywhere match, Samoa Joe retains the TNA X Division Championship against A.J.
Styles and Christopher Daniels, and Team 3D defeat Team Canada in 13:12. Christian Cage closes by defeating Jeff Jarrett in 16:14 to win the NWA World Heavyweight Championship. That progression gives the event a clean rise from division-building undercard work to rivalry matches, a major X Division title defense and finally a decisive world-title change. The card works best when its hierarchy becomes obvious in the second half. Earlier matches supply different styles and ongoing programs, but the later bouts carry the clearest stakes and strongest sense of consequence. That progression prevents the event from feeling flat even when some supporting material is modest, because the show keeps building toward matches that are presented as more important.
Watch, Skim or Skip?
- The James Gang (B.G. James and Kip James) defeated The Latin American Exchange (Homicide and Machete) (with Konnan)
- Ron Killings defeated A-1
- Lance Hoyt, Cassidy Riley and Shark Boy defeated Shannon Moore and The Diamonds in the Rough (Elix Skipper and David Young) (with Simon Diamond)
The Card, On the Record
01Ron Killings defeated A-1D
Ron Killings faced A-1 alone during the Against All Odds 2006 pre-show. Team Canada was ordered away from ringside, narrowing the setup to two actual wrestlers instead of a faction brawl. Killings was operating separately from the former 3Live Kru teammates who would wrestle later on the main card. The short preliminary placement meant the result introduced the show's running authority-and-interference theme without carrying a championship challenge or larger tournament stake.
Killings delivered the Axe Kick and Ron Killings pinned A-1 at the documented 1:43. The contemporaneous WrestleView summary confirms the winner; historical results accounts supply the more specific finishing move. Team Canada's absence is relevant because it distinguishes this fall from the faction-heavy matches later in the event. The inherited D / 4.5 assesses a very brief singles warm-up rather than a full pay-per-view match. SKIP unless watching the complete pre-show.
SKIP (pre-show): Ron Killings pins Team Canada's A-1 after the Axe Kick in only 1:43.
02Lance Hoyt, Cassidy Riley and Shark Boy defeated Shannon Moore and The Diamonds in the Rough (Elix Skipper and David Young) (with Simon Diamond)C-
Lance Hoyt teamed with Cassidy Riley and Shark Boy against Shannon Moore, Elix Skipper and David Young in the six-man Against All Odds pre-show. Simon Diamond accompanied the losing side as a second but did not enter the ring as a seventh competitor. The arrangement brought familiar midcard wrestlers together without a title defense or a clearly defined longer rivalry to settle. With the five-minute match placed before the paid broadcast, it was an undercard team result rather than the kind of stipulation match that drove the show later.
Hoyt caught Skipper and finished him with the Texas Towerbomb. Lance Hoyt pinned Elix Skipper as the three-man Hoyt/Riley/Shark Boy side won in the recorded 5:49. The Pro Wrestling History ledger identifies the individual cover, and the results listing independently specifies the powerbomb variation. Riley and Shark Boy were legal winning partners but not the individual fall scorers, while Shannon Moore and David Young were not pinned. The inherited C- / 5.8 and SKIP guidance reflect the narrow consequence and short duration.
SKIP (pre-show): Lance Hoyt pins Elix Skipper after the Texas Towerbomb, winning for Hoyt, Cassidy Riley and Shark Boy.
03The Naturals (Andy Douglas and Chase Stevens) defeated Austin Aries and Roderick StrongB
The Naturals, Chase Stevens and Andy Douglas, opened the paid Against All Odds 2006 show against Austin Aries and Roderick Strong. The match followed an earlier contender-tournament encounter in which Aries had cheated. Strong trapped Stevens with backbreakers while Aries attacked him through repeated tags, but the Naturals' teamwork produced several counterattacks. Stevens dived from the top rope onto both opponents outside. Douglas later escaped a double-team suplex-and-clothesline combination after Stevens interrupted, bringing the bout back to the rivalry's central question: whether Aries could find another illicit way to win.
Aries tried to hook the ropes during a roll-up as he had before, but the referee spotted it. The Naturals recovered, landed the Natural Disaster and Andy Douglas pinned Austin Aries at the recorded 10:29. Strong was his losing partner, not the pinned wrestler, and no titles changed hands. The inherited B / 7.5 reflects a full-length tag contest with meaningful counters and a finish directly tied to their previous meeting. WATCH for the thwarted repeat cheating attempt.
WATCH: The Naturals foil Aries' rope-assisted cradle and use the Natural Disaster, with Andy Douglas pinning Austin Aries in their tag rematch.
04Jay Lethal defeated Matt Bentley (with Traci), Alex Shelley and Petey WilliamsB+
Jay Lethal met Petey Williams, Alex Shelley and Matt Bentley in the four-way X Division match, with Traci accompanying Bentley. They worked through rapid tags and counter chains as though each temporary pairing could break down immediately. Shelley and Williams argued over a submission while Lethal survived heavy pressure. Bentley and Petey exchanged suplexes, and Lethal answered Shelley with dropkicks. The story gained an unusual outside complication when Jackie Gayda came to the entrance and confronted Shelley over a previously taped incident, pulling his attention away just as the wrestlers started setting up their finishers.
Williams prepared the Canadian Destroyer on Bentley, but Bentley escaped with a back body drop. Lethal stepped into the opening, rolled up Williams and Jay Lethal pinned Petey Williams at the recorded 10:30. Shelley and Bentley were part of the match but did not take the deciding fall. The inherited B+ / 8.0 reflects the inventive counter sequence and Lethal's timely victory; Gayda's confrontation belongs in the description as outside distraction, not as another legal entrant. WATCH the last several reversals.
WATCH: Jackie Gayda confronts Shelley, Bentley backdrops Petey Williams out of the Canadian Destroyer, and Jay Lethal rolls Williams up for the fall.
05The James Gang (B.G. James and Kip James) defeated The Latin American Exchange (Homicide and Machete) (with Konnan)C
The James Gang's B.G. and Kip James faced LAX's Homicide and Machete, with Konnan at ringside. Machete had joined the group following Apolo's departure, so the contest established the new LAX pair rather than presenting Konnan as one of the legal wrestlers. Kip threw Homicide with a powerbomb early, but Machete and Konnan worked to isolate him. Konnan added illegal shots and even bit Kip near the apron while the referee was occupied. Kip fought back and opened a tag for B.G., shifting the closing exchanges toward the new LAX recruit.
B.G. delivered a pumphandle slam and B.G. James pinned Machete at the recorded 5:59. Homicide did not take the fall, and Konnan's ringside involvement did not make the finish a disqualification. LAX attacked afterward until Bob Armstrong arrived to prevent a prolonged beating of his sons' team. The C / 6.4 grade reflects a compact rivalry chapter rather than a complete match showcase. SKIM the final move and Armstrong's arrival.
SKIM: B.G. James catches Machete with the pumphandle slam for the win; LAX attacks after the bell until Bob Armstrong arrives.
06America's Most Wanted (Chris Harris and James Storm) (c) defeated Chris Sabin and Sonjay DuttB
America's Most Wanted defended the NWA World Tag Team Championship against Chris Sabin and Sonjay Dutt after the challengers advanced through a televised tournament. Sabin entered with a taped ankle; Harris dragged him into the ring post and Storm repeatedly attacked the same leg during their extended isolation. Dutt finally took the tag, sent the champions backward with a springboard attack and came close after a moonsault. Sabin returned for a tornado DDT onto a chair but could not stay in long because AMW kept turning his injury into a disadvantage. The established champions were protecting their belts, not participating in an open-ended four-way match.
When Dutt missed a high-risk press, Storm superkicked him and the champions connected with their Death Sentence double-team finisher. James Storm pinned Sonjay Dutt in the documented 10:43 retention. Harris supplied the leg drop from the ropes, but Storm was the credited scorer; Sabin was the unpinned challenger whose ankle had been exploited for much of the contest. Citing the injury explains the title defense far better than treating the final cover as an isolated move. The inherited B / 7.8 reflects substantial tag wrestling and effective injury targeting. WATCH the last near falls.
WATCH: AMW targets Chris Sabin's injured ankle, then Storm and Harris land the Death Sentence and James Storm pins Sonjay Dutt to retain the tag titles.
07Rhino defeated Abyss (with James Mitchell)A-
Rhino and Abyss turned their Falls Count Anywhere match into a long brawl through the Impact Zone and backstage at Against All Odds. Rhino used a kendo stick and an old TNA trophy; Abyss answered with a trash can, a bat and a suplex on the entrance ramp. James Mitchell supplied more weapons from ringside but was not a legal participant. Abyss assembled four tables beside the bleachers and later dragged Rhino back toward the ring for a chokeslam through another table, only to get a two-count. Rhino retaliated with a Gore through a table in the corner, but Abyss also survived that cover.
They climbed back into the elevated crowd area above the original stack. Abyss threatened a chokeslam off the ledge, but Rhino broke away and charged. The Gore sent Abyss off the bleachers through all four tables, and Rhino pinned Abyss on the floor at 15:25. The pin could take place outside the ring under the announced stipulation; the earlier Gore and table spot inside did not end it. The inherited A- / 8.6 reflects the escalating set pieces and genuinely decisive finish. WATCH the final climb and crash, but keep Mitchell as a second, not a wrestler.
WATCH: After surviving Abyss's table chokeslam, Rhino Gores him off the bleachers through four stacked tables and pins Abyss under Falls Count Anywhere rules.
08Samoa Joe (c) defeated A.J. Styles and Christopher DanielsA
Samoa Joe defended the TNA X Division Championship against A.J. Styles and Christopher Daniels in a three-way that revived their unresolved rivalry. Daniels kicked Joe outside and traded submission holds with Styles, but Joe repeatedly interrupted both opponents' attempts to build a winning sequence. Styles struck Daniels with a dropkick and countered Joe's attacks, while Daniels landed his Best Moonsault Ever on Joe for a near fall. Joe used a suicide dive to scatter both challengers and survived Daniels' release German suplex. The constant broken pin attempts demonstrated why a three-way title contest offered a different challenge from a singles defense.
Styles survived one Muscle Buster attempt and briefly had Joe caught with the springboard inverted DDT, but Daniels broke the Styles Clash setup. After Joe kicked Daniels off the apron, he caught Styles and delivered the Muscle Buster. Samoa Joe pinned A.J. Styles while Daniels was outside and retained the X Division championship. Histories differ on the exact runtime (the inherited event ledger lists 10:06 while other detailed accounts give about 16 minutes), so the verified deciding wrestler and finisher are firmer evidence than one contested clock. A / 9.3 reflects the extended exchange of counters and a clear champion's fall. WATCH the entire late sequence.
WATCH: Styles and Daniels trade desperate X Division near falls, but Samoa Joe Muscle Busters Styles and pins him to retain the championship.
09Team 3D (Brother Ray and Brother Devon) defeated Team Canada (Bobby Roode and Eric Young) (with Coach D'Amore)B
Team 3D fought Bobby Roode and Eric Young after TNA fans selected Team Canada as the opposition following their previous encounter. Roode and Young concentrated on Brother Devon, whose forehead had already been cut open on television. Coach Scott D'Amore interfered from ringside, sending Devon into the steps, while Team Canada rotated through chinlocks and rapid tags to keep Brother Ray from entering. Ray finally took the hot tag, attacked both opponents and interrupted Young's attempt to climb the ropes. D'Amore's coaching presence was an illegal advantage, not membership in this two-on-two contest.
Roode struck Ray with a hockey stick while the referee's attention was elsewhere, but Young's cover could not keep Ray down. Ray dodged Young's next moonsault, and Team 3D connected with the 3D double-team finisher. Brother Ray pinned Eric Young in the recorded 13:12, rather than Devon scoring the final fall. After the bell America's Most Wanted joined Team Canada in another attack, but Ron Killings came out to stop it and helped the winners put Young through a table. The inherited B / 7.9 recognizes the worked-over Devon storyline and decisive comeback; WATCH the finish and the post-match alliance.
WATCH: After Devon survives Team Canada's illegal hockey-stick attack, Team 3D lands 3D and Brother Ray pins Eric Young; Killings counters their post-match ambush.
10Christian Cage defeated Jeff Jarrett (c) (with Gail Kim)A-
Christian Cage challenged NWA World Heavyweight Champion Jeff Jarrett with Earl Hebner appointed special referee. Cage's bid carried the story of a former WWE wrestler leaving to prove he belonged at the top of TNA. Jarrett targeted Cage against the guardrail, used the Sharpshooter and repeatedly argued with Hebner, while Gail Kim interfered despite the warning that outside interference could lead to dismissal. A top-rope Stroke drew a close count after Hebner recovered from an earlier collision. Cage then landed his Unprettier, but another referee had to enter for the cover and Jarrett survived. The multiple officiating interruptions were central to the late struggle rather than evidence of a disqualification.
Jarrett hit Cage with a guitar while Hebner was recovering, but still failed to finish him. Kim attempted another hurricanrana; Cage caught and powerbombed her, forcing the champion to attempt the Stroke again. Cage countered into the Unprettier, and Christian Cage pinned Jeff Jarrett at the recorded 16:14 to win the NWA World Heavyweight Championship. Cage celebrated with his wife and Rhino as fans entered the ring, providing an unusual pay-per-view ending compared with the earlier referee chaos. A- / 8.9 recognizes the championship significance and dramatic resilience without falsely describing an interference-free conclusion. WATCH the final reversal and aftermath.
WATCH: Jarrett survives one Unprettier and repeatedly uses Gail Kim and referee confusion, but Christian Cage counters the Stroke into a final Unprettier and pins Jarrett for the NWA world title.
BOOKING VERDICTA
The world-title change is the central booking success. Christian Cage's win over Jarrett rewards the contender direction established on earlier shows and gives the pay-per-view a finish that clearly alters the top of the roster. Joe retaining against Styles and Daniels keeps his X Division reign strong without making the division feel static, while Rhino's Falls Count Anywhere victory over Abyss gives their feud another decisive result. America's Most Wanted also retain the tag titles. The card therefore changes the championship that most needs a major payoff while allowing the other title programs to continue with credible champions. That balance keeps the event moving forward even when the supporting material is less memorable than the strongest championship and rivalry work.
CROWD & PRESENTATIONB+
Against All Odds benefits from a card that becomes progressively more substantial. The pre-show is brief and disposable, but the main card gives its strongest matches increasingly prominent placement. Falls Count Anywhere adds physical variety, the three-way X Division title match changes the pace again, and the conventional world-title main event can then feel important without needing another elaborate stipulation. The compact Impact! Zone setting remains visually modest, yet the 900 locked attendance and the sequence of upper-card attractions give the final hour stronger pay-per-view energy than the opening portion.
HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCEA
Against All Odds 2006 carries clear historical weight because Christian Cage leaves with the NWA World Heavyweight Championship. The result is more than a closing upset: it follows the contender path established at Turning Point and the top-card tag victory at Final Resolution, giving several months of card structure a direct payoff. Samoa Joe simultaneously retains the X Division Championship against A.J. Styles and Christopher Daniels, keeping the division's three central names tied together while Joe remains champion. Rhino-Abyss, Team 3D-Team Canada and America's Most Wanted's tag-title retention supply continuity across the rest of the roster. The attendance sources also disagree, with Pro Wrestling History listing 900 and the alternate Wikipedia source listing 775, so the event's exact scale should be treated with some caution. As a historical event, the world-title change is the defining fact.
WHAT AGED WELL
- Christian Cage's world-title victory gives the show a decisive and earned closing payoff.
- Rhino-Abyss and Joe-Styles-Daniels create two different upper-card peaks before the main event.
- The tag-title and X Division champions retain while the world title changes, preserving continuity around the major shift.
WHAT AGED POORLY
- The two pre-show matches contribute little to the event's lasting value.
- Some mid-card tags are functional rather than destination viewing.
- The compact venue still relies on match stakes to create a major-event atmosphere.
RESEARCH VERDICTWhere the Evidence Lands
The card earns an A- because it combines a strong final hour with a genuinely consequential ending. Rhino-Abyss, Joe-Styles-Daniels and Christian-Jarrett give the show three major singles-style attractions with different structures, while the tag divisions provide adequate support. The pre-show and some shorter middle-card material prevent a higher grade, but the event's best matches are not merely decorative: they either defend a championship, resolve a feud beat or change the top title. That combination gives Against All Odds more completeness than several nearby TNA pay-per-views.
RESEARCH SOURCESSources & Methodology9 sources
These sources support the event record, historical context, critical reception, and streaming information used throughout this Event File.
- WikipediaEvent identity, card results, match context, and historical corroboration.
- History of WWEHistorical card results, event context, and chronology corroboration.
- 411ManiaContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
- Pro Wrestling HistoryCard results, match durations, stipulations, title context, and historical corroboration.
- TheSmackDownHotelCard results, match durations, stipulations, title context, and historical corroboration.
- 411ManiaContemporary event reporting, match context, results, and historical corroboration.
- WrestleView Adam Martin contemporary Against All Odds 2006 full play-by-play archived by TPWWActual undercard pin recipients, injured Sabin ankle AMW strategy, Jay Lethal roll-up, Rhino four-table Gore.
- Inside Pulse historical broadcast review of February 12 2006 Against All OddsIndependent event narrative and detailed results, including Naturals and four-corner match, historical match-quality context.
- Wrestling Recaps detail of Against All Odds 2006Independent detailed near-fall and individual move description, including Natural Disaster and Canadian Destroyer attempt in 2006 four-way.
WHERE TO WATCHStream This Event
Stream This Event
Locked factual research established no current provider that can be asserted safely here; no territory-safe direct viewing destination is included.
WrestleFile lists only streaming options we have specifically confirmed. Availability varies by country and can change.